The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show
March 11, 2026

Charlie Kirk's Mission of Dialogue, Ben vs. Piers, and Nancy Guthrie 2013 Segment, w/ Kolvet & Neff

Quick Read

Megyn Kelly dissects media manipulation, conservative infighting, and celebrity hypocrisy, using specific examples like CNN's misreporting on a NYC terror attack and the Ben Shapiro-Piers Morgan feud.
CNN and CBS demonstrably misreported a NYC terror attack, framing it to fit a political agenda.
Conservative infighting, exemplified by Ben Shapiro and Piers Morgan, undermines unity by policing who can be 'platformed'.
Celebrities like Whoopi Goldberg and Gwyneth Paltrow exhibit hypocrisy and exhibitionism, selling luxury items while claiming oppression or engaging in controversial acts.

Summary

Megyn Kelly opens by criticizing media outlets like CNN and CBS for misrepresenting facts, particularly regarding a New York City terror attack, and highlights the dangers of media manipulation. She then critiques celebrities Whoopi Goldberg and Gwyneth Paltrow for perceived hypocrisy and exhibitionism, citing their luxury auction items and controversial film roles. A significant portion of the episode focuses on the escalating feud between Ben Shapiro and Piers Morgan, framing it as a symptom of conservative infighting over platforming diverse or critical voices. Kelly also discusses the ongoing challenges for Turning Point USA following Charlie Kirk's passing, emphasizing the internal divisions within the right, especially concerning foreign policy and public sentiment on the Iran war, and the impact of media narratives on President Trump's immigration approval.
This episode provides a critical lens on contemporary media practices, exposing how narratives are shaped and facts can be distorted. It illuminates the internal struggles and ideological fault lines within the conservative movement, particularly regarding foreign policy and media engagement, which impacts political strategy and unity. For anyone navigating the current media landscape or observing political discourse, understanding these dynamics is essential for discerning truth from propaganda and recognizing the forces at play in public opinion.

Takeaways

  • Media outlets like CNN and CBS actively engaged in narrative manipulation regarding a NYC terror attack, misrepresenting the perpetrators and victims.
  • The host criticizes Sean Hannity for failing to challenge Lindsey Graham's 'frothing at the mouth claims' about bombing countries.
  • A 2013 'Today Show' segment showing Nancy Guthrie's bedroom is highlighted as potential source material for a kidnapper's note, raising concerns about media oversharing.
  • Pima County Sheriff Nanos's past blunders and alleged resume fudging are presented as reasons to question the competence of the Nancy Guthrie investigation.
  • Whoopi Goldberg's claims of systemic racism are contrasted with her auctioning off luxury items, including a $9,000 diamond ring and a $6,000 gold cigarette case.
  • Gwyneth Paltrow is criticized for auctioning personal items like a photo of her ex-husband and a naked portrait, and for taking on controversial, age-inappropriate sex scenes.
  • Ben Shapiro is accused of being a 'propagandist' for attacking Piers Morgan over platforming critics of Israel, while Piers Morgan defends his journalistic approach of debating all sides.
  • The Charlie Kirk show's producers face backlash for platforming guests critical of the Iran war, highlighting the conservative movement's foreign policy divisions.
  • Public support for the Iran war is significantly lower than previous conflicts (41% vs. 75-97%), indicating potential political repercussions for Republicans.
  • President Trump's net approval rating on immigration dropped significantly among independents (from +3 to -30) due to media narratives around deportation policies.

Insights

1Media Manipulation and Misinformation in Terror Attack Coverage

CNN and CBS are accused of intentionally misrepresenting a New York City terror attack. Abby Phillip of CNN repeatedly framed the attack by two radical Muslim men on anti-Muslim protesters and police as an attack *on* Mayor Zoran Mdani, a Muslim. CBS News used imagery of a Trump supporter while reporting on the attack by Muslim extremists. This deliberate distortion of facts to fit a political narrative is highlighted as a severe breach of journalistic integrity.

Abby Phillip's repeated on-air statements and a later 'correction' tweet (-), CBS News using a Trump supporter's image during reporting on the attack (-), CNN's initial article framing the attackers as 'Pennsylvania teenagers' on a 'normal day' (-).

2Celebrity Hypocrisy and Exhibitionism

The host criticizes Whoopi Goldberg for complaining about racism in America while auctioning off high-value luxury items, framing it as hypocrisy. Gwyneth Paltrow is similarly critiqued for auctioning deeply personal items (like a photo of her ex-husband and a naked portrait) and participating in age-inappropriate 'steamy sex scenes' in a film, which is framed as a desperate attempt to cling to youth and attention.

Whoopi Goldberg's auction items including an $9,000 diamond ring and a $6,000 cigarette case (-). Gwyneth Paltrow auctioning a photo of Chris Martin for $100, a naked signed portrait for $250, and engaging in sex scenes with a much younger actor (-, -).

3Conservative Infighting and the 'Platforming' Debate

The feud between Ben Shapiro and Piers Morgan is presented as a microcosm of deeper divisions within the conservative movement. Shapiro attacked Morgan for 'platforming' critics of Israel like Dave Smith, whom Shapiro labeled 'Nazis' or 'Nazi adjacent.' Morgan defended his approach as journalistic, allowing debate from all sides, and accused Shapiro of being a 'propagandist' who only airs one side. This highlights a tension between open debate and ideological purity within conservative media.

Ben Shapiro's clip accusing Piers Morgan of platforming 'actual Nazis and Nazi adjacent' (-). Piers Morgan's rebuttal, showing clips of himself challenging controversial guests and calling Shapiro a 'propagandist' (-). Megyn Kelly's commentary on Shapiro's pattern of attacking former allies (-).

4Charlie Kirk's Legacy and Conservative Foreign Policy Divisions

Andrew Kovvat and Blake Nef, producers of The Charlie Kirk Show, discuss the challenges of maintaining Charlie Kirk's vision for Turning Point USA after his death. They emphasize Kirk's skepticism of regime change and war with Iran, despite his trust in President Trump. They face criticism for platforming diverse views on the Iran war, reflecting the deep 'fault line' within the American right on foreign policy, which Kirk himself had warned about.

Charlie Kirk's producers discussing his skepticism of war with Iran and trust in the president (-). Criticism received for platforming Robert Barnes, a war skeptic (-). Charlie Kirk's past warning about foreign policy being the 'greatest divide on the American right' (-).

5Political Impact of Public Sentiment on War and Immigration

Public support for the Iran war is notably low (41%) compared to historical conflicts, raising concerns about its political repercussions for Republicans in future elections. Similarly, President Trump's approval rating on immigration among independents significantly declined (from +3 to -30) after media narratives focused on 'sob stories' related to deportation policies, demonstrating how media framing can erode support for key political issues.

New York Times poll showing 41% public support for the Iran war compared to 75-97% for previous wars (-). Harry Anton's data on Trump's net approval rating on immigration among independents, dropping from +7 to -17 overall, and +3 to -30 among independents (-).

Lessons

  • Diversify your news consumption beyond mainstream outlets to counter narrative manipulation and obtain a more accurate understanding of events.
  • Critically evaluate information, especially from sources with clear ideological leanings, and cross-reference facts to avoid being swayed by propaganda.
  • Engage in respectful debate on contentious issues, particularly within your own political alignment, focusing on policy and avoiding personal attacks to maintain unity and effectiveness.

Quotes

"

"There is no greater divide on the American right than foreign policy."

Charlie Kirk
"

"The lie gets halfway around the world before the truth has a chance to put on its pants."

Andrew Kovvat (paraphrasing a common saying)

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes