Yes, Democrats Could Win the Senate in 2026 (w/ Ron Brownstein)
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Midterm elections function as quasi-parliamentary votes, primarily reflecting the incumbent president's approval rating, not the opposition party's image.
- ❖No president with unified government control has retained it through a midterm since 1978, a pattern likely to continue if Trump's approval remains low.
- ❖Democrats currently hold 10 of 12 Senate seats in swing states (MI, PA, WI, NV, GA, AZ), a potentially unsustainable advantage.
- ❖Trump's disapproval among non-college educated whites is now polling in the 48-51% range nationally, a significant increase from 35% in 2018.
- ❖Historically, non-college educated whites who disapprove of Trump vote overwhelmingly Democratic (around 90%), indicating no 'extra layer of defense' for Republicans.
- ❖Wave elections, characterized by accelerated shifts and unexpected state contests, are a real possibility given Trump's current weak standing.
Insights
1Presidential Approval as the Primary Midterm Predictor
The single most important factor in any off-year election during a presidency is the approval rating of the incumbent president. Voters make choices based on which party they want in control, and this judgment is overwhelmingly tied to the president's performance. Historically, 90-93% of voters disapproving of Trump have voted Democratic for the House.
The single most important factor in midterm, in fact, every off-year election during a presidency is the approval rating of that president. ... In 2018, 90% in the national exit poll, 90% of the voters who disapproved of Trump voted Democratic for the House. In 2020, 93% of voters who disapproved of Trump voted Democratic for the House.
2The 'Trump 25' States and Democratic Senate Challenges
There are 25 states that have voted for Trump three consecutive times, and Democrats currently hold zero Senate seats in these states. This represents a significant Republican base of 50 senators. For Democrats to achieve a Senate majority, they must break into these traditionally red states, as their current advantage in swing states is likely unsustainable.
There are now 25 states that have voted three times for Trump... today Democrats have zero. Zero of the Senate seats in the 25 states... 50 Republican senators. That's a pretty good base for the Republicans.
3Shifting Disapproval Among Working-Class White Voters as a Democratic Pathway
Trump's core constituency, non-college educated white voters (working-class whites), is showing significant cracks. Recent polls indicate Trump's disapproval among this demographic is now in the 48-51% range nationally, a substantial increase from 35% in 2018. If this higher disapproval sustains, it provides a crucial pathway for Democrats to win Senate seats in states with a higher proportion of these voters, especially outside the evangelical South.
We've had four or five polls since January 1st with this disapproval among non-college whites in the 48 to 51% range nationally... If Trump's disapproval rating among working-class whites is somewhere between 7, 8 to 10, 12, 15 points higher than it was in 2018. That to me is the pathway to a Democratic Senate.
4Unified Government Control Rarely Survives Midterms
A consistent historical pattern shows that no president with unified control of government (controlling both the White House and Congress) has maintained that control through a midterm election since Jimmy Carter in 1978. This trend, observed across five consecutive presidencies (Biden, Trump, Obama, Bush, Clinton), suggests a strong voter tendency to revoke unified control.
No president has gone into a midterm election with unified control of government and held it through that midterm election since Jimmy Carter in 1978... Biden in 22, Trump in 18, Obama in 10, Bush in '06, and Clinton in 94. They all lost voters revoked unified control from them.
Bottom Line
Non-college educated white voters who disapprove of Trump are just as likely to vote Democratic as college-educated whites or non-white voters who disapprove of Trump. This contradicts the notion that there's an 'extra layer of defense' for Republicans among these voters due to cultural issues.
This implies that if Trump's disapproval among working-class whites continues to rise, Democrats can expect a direct translation of that sentiment into votes, rather than these voters being held back by perceived Democratic cultural extremism.
Democratic campaigns targeting these demographics should focus on economic and performance-based criticisms of Trump, rather than assuming cultural wedge issues will prevent voters from switching parties once they sour on Trump.
Key Concepts
Laws of Political Gravity
This model asserts that fundamental political patterns, such as the incumbent president's approval rating dictating midterm outcomes and the historical loss of unified government control in midterms, consistently apply, even in the era of Donald Trump. It suggests that while Trump may seem to defy traditional politics, his party remains susceptible to these underlying forces.
Quasi-Parliamentary Elections
This model describes modern American midterm elections as functioning less on individual candidate appeal and more as a referendum on which party voters want to control the government, primarily driven by their assessment of the sitting president's performance.
Lessons
- Democratic campaigns should prioritize increasing Donald Trump's disapproval rating, particularly among non-college educated white voters, as this directly correlates with Democratic vote share.
- Strategists must identify and target states where Trump's approval rating is likely to fall below 50%, as these states historically become highly competitive for Senate races.
- Democrats need to develop strategies to establish 'beachheads' in the 25 states that have consistently voted for Trump, as relying solely on swing states for Senate control is unsustainable long-term.
Democratic Strategy to Win the Senate in 2026
**Sustain and Amplify Trump Disapproval**: Continuously highlight issues that drive down Trump's approval, especially focusing on economic performance and cost of living concerns that resonate with working-class white voters.
**Target Key Demographics**: Focus campaign efforts on non-college educated white voters, particularly those outside the evangelical South, where Trump's disapproval is already showing majority levels.
**Defend Swing State Incumbents**: Secure re-election for Democratic senators in battleground states like Michigan and Georgia, which are critical for maintaining the existing Senate advantage.
**Penetrate Red States**: Invest in strong candidates and campaigns in traditionally Republican-leaning states (e.g., Ohio, Alaska, Iowa, Kansas) where Trump's approval is on the bubble, aiming to flip at least one or two seats.
**Leverage Wave Dynamics**: Be prepared for potential 'wave election' conditions where unexpected states and candidates might become competitive, and capitalize on any accelerated shifts in public sentiment.
Notable Moments
The discussion of Kansas as a potential Senate battleground, citing a poll showing Trump's approval at 48% and issues with the farm economy linked to Trump's trade policies.
This highlights how specific economic grievances directly tied to presidential policies can create unexpected vulnerabilities for incumbents even in strongly red states, potentially expanding the Democratic Senate map beyond traditional swing states.
The observation that outside the South, Donald Trump now has majority disapproval among non-college educated white voters who are not evangelicals.
This demographic shift is crucial because it represents a significant portion of the working-class white vote that has historically been a strong base for Trump. A majority disapproval here indicates a potential realignment and a key pathway for Democrats to gain ground in states like Maine, Michigan, and Minnesota.
Quotes
"The single most important factor in midterm, in fact, every off-year election during a presidency is the approval rating of that president."
"If you are giving away 50 seats before you before the kickoff... the only way you get a majority is by running the table and everything else and having the White House."
"If they disapprove of Trump, history says most of them, the vast majority of them in fact, are going to vote Democratic."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
A major shift is happening right now
"Donald Trump is losing his grip on the Republican party and movement, evidenced by internal dissent and a broader political landscape grappling with a collapse of accountability and truth."
SOTU: Trump In FREEFALL With Independents Ahead Of Big Speech
"Donald Trump faces unprecedented declines in independent voter approval, with his populist promises from a year prior largely unfulfilled, signaling a significant shift in his political standing."
SHOCK BREAKING: SHOCKED TRUMP STORMS OUT OF SUPREME COURT IN RAGE!
"This episode dissects Donald Trump's contentious Supreme Court appearance regarding birthright citizenship, the growing disillusionment of right-wing figures like Alex Jones with Trump, and the political fallout from Kristi Noem's husband's alleged cross-dressing scandal."
HOT TOPICS | WARNING: Donald Trump's Iran War Chaos Has Hit the Point of No Return!
"Don Lemon delivers a scathing critique of Donald Trump's recent actions, framing them as desperate, unconstitutional attempts to consolidate power, undermine democracy, and distract from economic and foreign policy failures, all while questioning his mental stability."