6 Mind Blowing Interrogation Confessions
YouTube · 6TnSqDl6upA
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Richard Cottingham, the 'torso killer,' casually confessed to 'well over 80' murders across multiple states, denying he was a 'serial killer' because he didn't 'go out to kill somebody.'
- ❖Shaina Hubers, accused of shooting her boyfriend six times, claimed self-defense but exhibited erratic behavior in interrogation, including dancing and singing, which undermined her defense.
- ❖Taylor Schabusiness confessed to strangling, sexually abusing, and dismembering Shad Thyrion, describing body parts' locations and showing little remorse, despite an insanity plea.
- ❖Russell Jones, involved in Aaron Frier's murder, rambled about 'manipulating cops' and 'releasing his bipolar' before detailing a plan to 'rescue' Ellie Frier that escalated to murder.
- ❖Babysitter Lindseay Parton initially denied harming 3-year-old Hannah Weshi but eventually admitted to shaking and slapping her out of frustration over spilled ketchup.
- ❖Chris Watts initially blamed his wife for killing their daughters before confessing to strangling his pregnant wife and then smothering his two young daughters.
Insights
1Richard Cottingham's Casual Admission to Dozens of Murders
Richard Cottingham, known as the 'torso killer,' confessed in 2014 to 'well over 80' killings across multiple states, including Florida, Connecticut, New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and Baltimore. He stated his strategy was to avoid patterns and signatures to evade capture. Despite the high number of victims, he denied being a 'serial killer,' claiming he didn't 'go out to kill somebody' and had let 'hundreds' of potential victims go.
Cottingham's statement: 'I would say there's well over 80.' and 'My whole thing was not to make a pattern, which I never did.'
2Shaina Hubers' Erratic Self-Defense Claim
Shaina Hubers admitted to shooting her on-again, off-again boyfriend, Ryan Poston, six times, claiming self-defense due to alleged physical abuse. However, her behavior during interrogation, including dancing, singing, and discussing her appearance and future marriage prospects, raised significant doubts about her claim of fear for her life. No physical evidence of abuse or a disarrayed crime scene was found.
Hubers' statement: 'I shot him in self-defense because he's done stuff before where I've hit my head on the headboard.' and later, 'I don't know if anyone will ever want to marry me if they know that I killed a boyfriend.'
3Taylor Schabusiness' Graphic and Unremorseful Confession
Taylor Schabusiness confessed to strangling Shad Thyrion with a metal chain, sexually abusing his body, and then dismembering him, attributing her actions to a 'meth-infused stupor.' She casually described cutting up his body, sexually abusing it simultaneously, and where she left various body parts, including his head in a bucket. Despite pleading insanity, a jury quickly convicted her of intentional homicide and abuse of a corpse.
Schabusiness' statement: 'I think I went a little too far cuz like I was blacking out while I was doing it, right?' and 'I was cutting at the same time.' and 'The head I put in that bucket. That black bucket.'
4Russell Jones' Bizarre Negotiation and Confession
Russell Jones, involved in the murder of Aaron Frier, engaged in a bizarre monologue in the interrogation room, attempting to 'manipulate cops' and threatening to 'release my bipolar' if his demands weren't met. He eventually confessed to being part of a plan to 'rescue' Ellie Frier from her father, whom they falsely believed was sexually abusing her. The plan to kidnap Aaron escalated to Gavin McFarland beating him to death.
Jones' statement: 'I know everything that I'm saying is being recorded and I'm doing it on purpose.' and 'Make a deal or I let out my bipolar.' and 'Killing was not my idea at all. We were supposed to try and find chloroform.'
5Lindseay Parton's Admission of Shaking and Slapping a Child
Babysitter Lindseay Parton initially denied harming 3-year-old Hannah Weshi, attributing her severe brain injuries to falls. Faced with medical evidence contradicting her claims, Parton eventually admitted to shaking and slapping Hannah out of frustration after the child squirted ketchup into the toilet and clung to her father, delaying his departure for work. Hannah later died from her injuries.
Parton's statement: 'I didn't want to be in trouble.' and 'I slapped her upside with my hand.' and 'I shook her and I remember picking her up and squeezing her and we did fall.'
6Chris Watts' Evolving and Haunting Confession
Chris Watts initially denied involvement in the disappearance of his pregnant wife, Shannan, and their two daughters, failing a polygraph test. He then told his father that Shannan had suffocated the girls, prompting him to strangle her. Later, in prison, Watts provided a different account, admitting he strangled Shannan after an argument about divorce, then smothered his daughters, Bella and Celeste, and disposed of their bodies in oil tanks.
Watts' statement to his father: 'I heard like a little commotion upstairs, but I didn't think anything of it.' and later, 'Being a dad was the best part of my life. I took it all away.'
Lessons
- Investigators must meticulously document defendant behavior and statements during interrogations, as seemingly irrelevant details can significantly impact legal outcomes.
- Legal professionals should be prepared to challenge self-defense claims when physical evidence or defendant conduct contradicts the narrative presented.
- The use of polygraph tests, while not always admissible as direct evidence, can be a crucial tool in eliciting initial confessions or prompting suspects to change their stories.
Quotes
"It's sad to say I couldn't count that they start to get jumbled. I would say there's well over 80."
"I shot him in self-defense because he's done stuff before where I've hit my head on the headboard."
"I think I went a little too far cuz like I was blacking out while I was doing it, right? And then like and then like I look at him, he's already purple. I'm like I don't know if he's fucking is he good? Is he good?"
"I know everything that I'm saying is being recorded and I'm doing it on purpose."
"Being a dad was the best part of my life. I took it all away."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes

Major Twist in Pregnant Mom Murder Case
"The sister of a murdered pregnant woman, initially arrested for lying to police about the crime, has had all charges against her dropped, adding a significant twist to a case where the victim's birth mother and step-father remain the primary suspects."

D4vd Murder Case: Every Disturbing Twist and Turn
"This episode meticulously reconstructs the shocking timeline of events surrounding the alleged murder and dismemberment of 14-year-old Celeste Rivas Hernandez by musician David Burke, known as D4vd, from their initial meeting to his formal charges."

“Pretty” 20-Yr-Old Girl Kills Her Dates For Being “Needy”, But Men Want To "Fix Her"
"A 20-year-old South Korean woman, Kim Soyong, drugged and killed multiple dates, prompting a national discussion on beauty standards, online deception, and the disturbing public reaction to her perceived attractiveness."

6 'Temper Tantrums' Caught on Police Bodycam
"This episode showcases six real-life police bodycam incidents where individuals' refusal to comply with law enforcement escalated into arrests and legal consequences, often stemming from perceived slights or entitlement."