Brian Tyler Cohen
Brian Tyler Cohen
January 26, 2026

WHOA: Republicans TURN on Trump amid ICE shooting

Quick Read

Amid a controversial ICE shooting and attempts to annex Greenland, the Trump administration faces unprecedented backlash from its own allies and a damaged global standing, revealing a strategy of power over principle.
A fatal ICE shooting of an ICU nurse sparked rare conservative backlash against the Trump administration.
Trump's attempt to annex Greenland was a vanity project that severely damaged US alliances and global trust.
Congressional inaction allows the executive branch to overstep, eroding checks and balances.

Summary

The episode analyzes the Trump administration's actions, starting with a fatal ICE shooting of an ICU nurse, Alexander Prey, which drew condemnation from conservative groups like the NRA and Gun Owners of America, as well as Republican figures. The host and guests discuss the optics of CBP head Greg Bavino's uniform, comparing it to SS garb, and California Governor Gavin Newsom's strategy of directly opposing Trump. New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill details her state's efforts to resist Trump's policies, including ending cooperation with ICE and addressing utility costs. Congresswoman Sarah Jacobs critiques Trump's attempt to annex Greenland as a vanity project that severely damaged US alliances and global trust, highlighting congressional inaction in reclaiming its constitutional powers. The discussion concludes with concerns about media consolidation and Trump's strategy of distraction, which, despite its intent, often leads to further unpopularity.
This episode illustrates how the Trump administration's aggressive tactics, from domestic law enforcement actions to international relations, are creating significant internal and external opposition. It highlights the erosion of traditional political alliances, the weaponization of government agencies, and the impact on global trust, offering a critical perspective on the long-term consequences of prioritizing power and spectacle over established norms and principles.

Takeaways

  • The ICE shooting of Alexander Prey, an ICU nurse, led to strong condemnation from conservative groups like the NRA and Gun Owners of America, who criticized the administration's narrative.
  • CBP head Greg Bavino's uniform was likened to SS garb, raising concerns about the militarization and optics of federal agents.
  • California Governor Gavin Newsom actively positions himself as a direct opponent to Trump, using perceived censorship attempts to gain more attention.
  • New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill has taken immediate action to counter federal overreach, including freezing utility rate hikes and maintaining an immigrant trust directive against ICE cooperation.
  • Trump's attempt to annex Greenland was widely unpopular (96% disapproval) and significantly damaged US alliances, particularly with Denmark and other NATO partners.
  • The media landscape is increasingly consolidated and skewed, making it harder for the public to access unbiased information and hold power accountable.
  • Congressional failure to assert its constitutional power, especially regarding war and peace, enables executive overreach and weakens democratic checks and balances.
  • Trump's strategy of distraction often involves moving from one unpopular action to another, which ultimately entrenches public perception that he is not working for Americans.

Insights

1Conservative Backlash to ICE Shooting of Alexander Prey

The fatal shooting of Alexander Prey, an ICU nurse with a legal concealed carry permit, by ICE agents sparked significant criticism from typically pro-gun and conservative voices. The Trump administration's narrative, labeling Prey a 'domestic terrorist' and claiming he brandished a weapon, was directly contradicted by video evidence and condemned by groups like the NRA and Gun Owners of America, as well as Republican Senator Rand Paul's staffer and former George W. Bush counsel.

NRA: 'This sentiment from the first assistant US attorney for the Central District of California is dangerous and wrong.' () Gun Owners of America: 'We condemn the unoured comments of US Attorney Billy. Federal agents are not highly likely to be legally justified in shooting concealed carry lences who approach while lawfully carrying a firearm.' () Conservative subreddit comments: 'Don't know how anyone can side with ICE here.' ()

2CBP Head Greg Bavino's Optics and Perceived Authoritarianism

The appearance of CBP head Greg Bavino in a distinctive coat was widely compared to SS officers from the 1930s. This sartorial choice, combined with ICE's aggressive actions like demanding papers and 'killing people on the streets,' reinforced concerns about the administration's authoritarian tendencies and its disregard for democratic values.

Host: 'I'm going to put the side by side right here on the screen of what Bo looks like and what like SS officers in the 1930s...looked like.' () Tommy Vtor: 'He's the only one dressed in a giant coat from the 1930s.' () Host: 'There are the obvious similarities between what ISIS is doing and what the Gestapo did about demanding papers from people on the streets.' ()

3Gavin Newsom's Strategy of Direct Opposition to Trump

California Governor Gavin Newsom has effectively positioned himself as a leading opponent to Donald Trump. His strategy involves actively challenging the administration, even leveraging perceived attempts at censorship (like a canceled speech at Davos) to generate exponentially more attention and solidify his image as a counter-force.

Tommy Vtor: 'One way to look like Donald Trump's opponent is to go out there and make yourself Donald Trump's opponent...he went to Davos and was I guess going to give a speech...and then they canceled on them last minute. So Gavin went out and made this aggressive case that the government is trying to censor him and in so doing got exponentially more attention than he would have otherwise.' ()

4New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill's Resistance to Federal Overreach

Upon taking office, New Jersey Governor Mikey Sherrill immediately declared a state of emergency on utility costs, freezing rate hikes and planning long-term power generation expansion. She also affirmed New Jersey's 'immigrant trust directive,' refusing to cooperate with ICE's 'proto-military force' and 'spurious investigations' targeting blue states, framing these actions as a defense of democratic values against a 'lawless dictator.'

Governor Sherrill: 'The minute I got in office, I was going to declare a state of emergency on utility cost, freezing rate hikes.' () 'He's actually targeting quite a few blue states...with spirious investigations to root out fraud.' () 'Certainly here in New Jersey, we have the immigrant trust directive which I will continue to carry out to ensure that our public safety officers...are acting in the interest of the public.' ()

5Greenland Annexation Attempt Damaged US Alliances

Trump's attempt to annex Greenland was a 'vanity project' that yielded no strategic gains beyond existing treaties but severely eroded trust with allies like Denmark. The move led to widespread international bafflement, the largest protest in Danish history against the US, and a dramatic drop in Danish public perception of the US as an important ally, highlighting the long-term damage to transatlantic relationships and NATO.

Congresswoman Jacobs: 'All of this saber rattling, all of this lack of trust with our allies...All of that appears to be so that we could get something that we already were would be able to get under the existing frameworks. And this is classic Trump, right? He sets the fire and then he claims to put it out and wants to get credit for it.' () '80% of Danes thought that the United States was an important ally. Now only single digits level of Danish people think that we are an important ally.' ()

6Congressional Inaction Enables Executive Overreach

Congress's failure to reclaim its constitutional power to declare war and peace has allowed the executive branch, under Trump, to operate with unchecked authority. This inaction creates a dangerous precedent where major foreign policy decisions, like potential invasions or tariffs, are made based on 'the whims of a single person,' undermining the foundational principles of the US government.

Congresswoman Jacobs: 'The constitution, article one of the constitution gives the power to declare war and peace to congress because the founders knew that this was too important of a role for one person to be responsible for.' () 'The world we're all living in is actually the fault of Congress for not standing up and reclaiming our power to be the ones to make these decisions.' ()

7Trump's Misunderstanding and Undermining of NATO

Trump's actions, particularly regarding Greenland, demonstrate a fundamental misunderstanding of NATO's collective defense principle. His questioning of NATO's ability to protect Greenland, and the implicit suggestion that US ownership is necessary for defense, actively undermines the alliance. This approach weakens the very institution that prevents incursions by rivals like China or Russia, creating a self-fulfilling prophecy of NATO's demise.

Congresswoman Jacobs: 'Donald Trump doesn't care about, believe in, or understand NATO. Because he, I think, truly believes that the only way the US would protect Greenland is if we owned Greenland. Not recognizing that the whole point of NATO is that if Greenland were to be attacked or invaded by Russia or China, the entire NATO alliance would come to its defense.' ()

Lessons

  • Recognize that capitulation to bullying tactics, whether from political figures or institutions, often leads to further exploitation, not goodwill. Direct pushback is often more effective.
  • Support independent media outlets to counter the consolidation and rightward skew of information, ensuring diverse perspectives and accountability for powerful figures.
  • Advocate for congressional action to reclaim its constitutional powers, particularly regarding war and peace, to prevent executive overreach and safeguard democratic checks and balances.
  • Understand that the optics and symbolism of leadership, from uniforms to rhetoric, significantly impact public perception and international relations, often revealing underlying intentions.
  • Be aware that political figures may use 'distraction' as a strategy, but these distractions often involve unpopular actions that can still be leveraged to highlight their broader policy failures.

Quotes

"

"If you approach law enforcement with a gun, there's a high likelihood they will be legally justified in shooting you."

Billy, US Attorney
"

"This sentiment from the first assistant US attorney for the Central District of California is dangerous and wrong. Responsible public voices should be awaiting a full investigation, not making generalizations, and demonizing law-abiding citizens."

NRA
"

"I am enraged and embarrassed by DHS's lawlessness, fascism, and cruelty. Impeach and remove Trump now."

Former counsel to George W. Bush
"

"When you look at the video, uh, it was said that Mr. Petti was banishing a weapon. Well, he was not banishing a weapon. Yes, he did have a weapon. It was said that by the White House that Mr. Petti attacked those agents. No, he did not attack those agents."

Fox News guest
"

"If Trump does not reign in his administration from letting their low IQ behavior hurt this administration's goals, then we aren't just going to lose this midterm, we're going to lose every election for decades."

MAGA supporter on conservative subreddit
"

"The only thing they actually care about is power like unbridled uncompromising power. That's why they've undermined their own positions on family values, on states rights, on fiscal conservatism because it was all just window dressing to make themselves look virtuous when in reality all they cared about was power."

Brian Tyler Cohen
"

"You don't buy yourself any goodwill by capitulating to these people. All you show Donald Trump is that you are weak and you can be bought by him and bullied."

Tommy Vtor
"

"Trump is Biff from Back to the Future. All right. Like when you're walking to school and like the bully beats you up and takes her lunch money, is that a one time thing? No. If you like cry and let him have it, he'll beat you up again and again and again. Like you got to throw a punch. You got to push back on this guy."

Brian Tyler Cohen
"

"This ICE agency is different. This president is uh really putting together his private militia. I've been flagging this for months now as we started to see them on the streets with masks and no insignia acting outside the purview of their duties."

Governor Mikey Sherrill
"

"All of this saber rattling, all of this lack of trust with our allies. You know, when I was there, I heard from Greenlandic families who told me that their kids couldn't sleep. Um we've seen world leaders start to call out how they no longer trust the United States as an ally. We saw the biggest protest in Danish history against the United States while I was there."

Congresswoman Sarah Jacobs
"

"I don't think anyone in the world will agree to make a deal with the United States that's longer than four years because they just don't believe that any deal will actually be implemented longer than four years."

Congresswoman Sarah Jacobs
"

"The world we're all living in is actually the fault of Congress for not standing up and reclaiming our power to be the ones to make these decisions."

Congresswoman Sarah Jacobs

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

SHOCK BREAKING: TRUMP PRESSER JUST MADE ME NEARLY THROW UP!
The Luke Beasley ShowMar 26, 2026

SHOCK BREAKING: TRUMP PRESSER JUST MADE ME NEARLY THROW UP!

"The host details a "nauseating" Trump cabinet meeting, dissecting his rambling, his cabinet's "pampering," and his questionable statements on war and policy, alongside a progressive Christian politician's impactful response to a death threat."

Political CommentaryCabinet MeetingsUS National Debt+2
Trump’s Weakness EXPOSED After Epic Losing Week for Republicans
Pod Save AmericaMar 6, 2026

Trump’s Weakness EXPOSED After Epic Losing Week for Republicans

"This episode dissects a tumultuous week for Republicans, highlighting Donald Trump's political vulnerabilities through the lens of Christine Gnome's firing, the incoherent Iran war strategy, and shifting dynamics in key primary races."

Republican PoliticsChristine GnomeDepartment of Homeland Security+2
They’re talking about 1 to 2 years in Iran
The David Pakman ShowMar 31, 2026

They’re talking about 1 to 2 years in Iran

"David Pakman dissects the escalating Iran conflict, the controversial White House ballroom project, and internal political fractures, arguing that Trump's erratic leadership and self-interest are driving concerning national and international developments."

Iran conflictMilitary draftTrump administration
Reality distortion has become the norm
The David Pakman ShowFeb 24, 2026

Reality distortion has become the norm

"David Pakman dissects the pervasive political reality distortion, highlighting Donald Trump's consistent pattern of fabricating facts, exhibiting cognitive decline, and undermining democratic institutions."

Political RhetoricState of the UnionDonald Trump+2