It Is What It Is
It Is What It Is
January 5, 2026

THE ORACLE WAS RIGHT!!! OSU VS. MIAMI IS BACK!!! | START WITH THE FACTS | S1 EP69

Quick Read

After Miami's victory over Ohio State, hosts debate the implications for both teams' futures, the transfer portal, and the re-establishment of Miami's 'meat and potatoes' brand.
Miami re-established its brand with a 'meat and potatoes' physical style, enabling strategic 'French pastry' offensive plays.
Ohio State faces a 'slippery slope' post-loss, with transfer portal exits and a tough schedule threatening sustained dominance.
Player attitude and performance in critical moments are key differentiators, often outweighing star ratings or initial hype.

Summary

Following Miami's win against Ohio State, the hosts engage in a spirited discussion about the game's aftermath. The Miami fan celebrates the re-establishment of the 'U' brand through a 'meat and potatoes' physical play style, which allowed for 'French pastry' offensive wrinkles. The Ohio State fan acknowledges the loss with class but expresses concern over the team's potential 'slippery slope' due to player transfers and a challenging upcoming schedule. They also analyze individual player performances, coaching strategies, and the broader impact of the transfer portal on college football programs, setting the stage for Miami's next game against Ole Miss.
This episode offers a raw, post-game analysis from the perspective of rival fans, highlighting the immediate emotional and strategic fallout of a significant college football game. It provides specific insights into team dynamics, coaching philosophy, and player development, which are critical for understanding the current landscape of college football, especially with the impact of the transfer portal and NIL money. The discussion on 'meat and potatoes' football versus 'French pastry' wrinkles offers a valuable framework for understanding successful team building.

Takeaways

  • Miami's coaching staff successfully implemented a 'meat and potatoes' strategy, focusing on physical play to set up unexpected offensive wrinkles.
  • Ohio State's loss could initiate a 'slippery slope' of losing players via the transfer portal and struggling with a difficult upcoming schedule.
  • The transfer portal is not always a loss; players who fail to perform when given opportunities are often moved on.
  • Miami is actively re-establishing its brand, moving from 'The U is back' to 'The U is here,' signifying a present-focused dominance.
  • Quarterback mobility and the ability to extend plays are crucial against aggressive pass rushes, as seen in the comparison between Ohio State's and Ole Miss's quarterbacks.

Insights

1Miami's Strategic Shift: From 'Back' to 'Here'

Miami's coaching staff, led by Mario Cristobal, successfully implemented a 'meat and potatoes' football philosophy throughout the season, prioritizing physical play and establishing the run. This foundation allowed them to introduce 'French pastry' offensive wrinkles in critical games, surprising opponents and showcasing athlete versatility. This strategic patience, despite fan criticism, re-established the team's brand, shifting the narrative from 'The U is back' (stuck in past glory) to 'The U is here' (present dominance).

The host details how Miami ran the ball 20-30 times in the gut all year, then used wrinkles like sneaking Fletcher out of the backfield on the goal line or putting defensive end Scott over the nose. Coach Christian Ball's quote, 'No, the U is here,' is cited as a new mantra.

2The Transfer Portal's Impact on Program Stability

The transfer portal significantly affects program stability, especially for teams experiencing a downturn. While some transfers are due to depth, losing key 'next man up' players or an offensive coordinator can signal a 'slippery slope.' Teams like Ohio State, despite past championships, risk losing top recruits from outside their core region if they consistently underperform, mirroring Miami's own decline in the early 2000s.

The host notes Ohio State lost 15 players, including 2-3 'next man up' prospects, and their OC. He argues that Ohio State's fan base is already questioning Ryan Day, and a tough schedule could make it harder to recruit from South Florida or Georgia, leading to a slide from 10-2 to 8-4, similar to Miami's past.

3Player Accountability and Attitude in the Transfer Era

In the era of the transfer portal, player accountability for on-field performance and attitude is heightened. Coaches are less inclined to retain highly-rated recruits who fail to perform when given clear opportunities, especially if they struggle with plays or display poor attitudes. Only players with strong personal connections or specific positional depth issues are genuinely missed when they transfer.

The Miami host states that players who transferred had opportunities when others went down but 'weren't what you believe' or 'don't know the plays.' He specifically mentions only missing Gelani Thurman due to a personal relationship and positional depth, while other transfers were due to underperformance or poor attitude.

4Aggressive Pass Rush Dictates Quarterback Performance

An aggressive, disruptive defensive front fundamentally alters a quarterback's ability to execute. When the pocket collapses early, quarterbacks develop 'happy feet,' shifting their focus from route concepts to self-preservation. This disruption, even against mobile quarterbacks, prevents them from seeing downfield and executing trained plays, turning structured offense into 'street ball.'

The Ohio State host attributes their struggles to Miami's defensive ends (Bane, Mezador) causing the pocket to collapse, leading to the quarterback having 'happy feet' and not looking at route concepts. He notes that even mobile quarterbacks like Trinidad Chambers struggle when flushed from the pocket because passing lanes change.

5The 'U is Here' Mentality and Fan Base Resurgence

The shift from 'The U is back' to 'The U is here' signifies a crucial change in Miami's football program, moving past nostalgic reliance on past glory to focus on present and future dominance. This new mindset is reflected in a tangible resurgence of fan enthusiasm and visible support, even at unrelated games, indicating a strong re-establishment of the team's brand identity.

Coach Christian Ball's quote 'No, the U is here' is highlighted as a departure from dwelling on the past. One host describes seeing Miami gear 'everywhere' in South Florida, even at an Oregon vs. Texas Tech game, and receiving 167 unread texts in a group chat after the win, indicating a massive surge in fan engagement.

Key Concepts

Meat and Potatoes vs. French Pastry Football

This model describes a football strategy where a team first establishes a strong, physical, run-heavy foundation ('meat and potatoes'). This consistent, aggressive approach wears down opponents and forces them to commit resources to stopping the run. Once this foundation is set, the team can then introduce creative, unexpected offensive plays or 'wrinkles' ('French pastry') that exploit the opponent's overcommitment to the base strategy. This allows for high-impact, surprising plays that are only effective because of the established physical identity.

Slippery Slope of Program Decline

This model suggests that a dominant college football program, after a significant loss or period of underperformance, can quickly enter a downward spiral. Initial losses can lead to key players entering the transfer portal, a decline in recruiting top talent from outside the immediate region, and increased pressure on coaching staff. This creates a cycle where perceived weakness makes it harder to compete, leading to more losses and further erosion of the program's brand and talent base, transforming a perennial contender into an average team.

Quotes

"

"You can't make excuses when you lose. You can't say, you know, we go back and if we play this game nine or 10 times, we win. It don't matter. You didn't get it done when you were supposed to get it done."

Ohio State Fan
"

"We are a meat and potatoes outfit. This ain't French pastry. And what Miami did throughout this year was establish the foundation. The foundation was we're going to play fast, aggressive on both sides of the line."

Miami Fan
"

"It hurts because if you don't win it all, none of it means shit."

Ohio State Fan
"

"The quote that used to be said was 'The U is back.' After the game, Coach Christian Ball said, 'No, the U is here.'"

Miami Fan

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes