The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show
April 20, 2026

SCOTUS Secrets From Dobbs Decision, w/ Hemingway / Meghan Markle's FAILED Australia Tour, w/ Shuter

YouTube · BViXVcDsOHU

Quick Read

Megyn Kelly and guests expose the hidden tensions within the Supreme Court after the Dobbs leak, the political machinations of the Iran war, and the calculated PR stunts of Hollywood's elite, including Meghan Markle's 'faux royal tour' and Blake Lively's public downfall.
Liberal Supreme Court justices allegedly endangered colleagues by delaying the Dobbs decision amidst threats.
Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's 'royal tours' are seen as cynical, self-serving PR stunts by palace insiders.
The Met Gala is losing its relevance and struggling to sell tickets as designers shift focus to digital influencers.

Summary

This episode features deep dives into the political landscape and celebrity culture. Megyn Kelly analyzes President Trump's Iran war strategy, highlighting internal frustrations and the political risks for the GOP. Molly Hemingway, author of 'Alito,' reveals explosive details about the Dobbs decision, including how liberal justices allegedly slow-walked the opinion amidst threats to conservative colleagues and the breakdown of collegiality on the Supreme Court. Later, celebrity insider Rob Shuter uncovers the true nature of Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's 'faux royal tour' in Australia, the public's growing disdain for Blake Lively, and the declining relevance of events like the Met Gala. He also shares behind-the-scenes drama from the 'Today Show' and the orchestrated nature of celebrity paparazzi photos.
The episode exposes critical vulnerabilities in judicial integrity and national security policy, revealing how partisan divides can compromise the safety of Supreme Court justices and complicate international relations. It also unmasks the manufactured reality of celebrity culture, offering a cynical yet insightful look into how public perception is manipulated, from staged paparazzi photos to 'faux royal tours,' and the real-world consequences for those who fail to maintain their image.

Takeaways

  • President Trump's Iran war strategy is fraught with internal White House frustration and risks GOP midterm chances.
  • Justice Samuel Alito is not expected to retire this year, despite earlier speculation, though other Supreme Court retirements are possible.
  • The leak of the Dobbs decision was followed by liberal justices intentionally delaying its release, despite threats to conservative justices' lives.
  • The Department of Justice and the Biden White House were criticized for failing to prosecute those who threatened Supreme Court justices after the Dobbs leak.
  • The collegiality among Supreme Court justices has significantly deteriorated, with liberal justices openly attacking conservative colleagues in public forums.
  • Celebrity publicist Rob Shuter confirms that many 'candid' paparazzi photos are staged, with stars actively tipping off photographers.
  • Ben Affleck is reportedly willing to walk away from a multi-million dollar share in his mansion with Jennifer Lopez, indicating a desire to be 'done' with their divorce.
  • Blake Lively's public image has suffered significantly due to a lawsuit, leading to a lack of acting offers and consideration of moving to the UK.
  • Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's 'faux royal tour' in Australia was a self-serving attempt to maintain relevance, angering palace insiders who now feel powerless to stop them.
  • Prince Harry is reportedly planning a self-help book focused on mental health, despite being perceived as 'miserable' by commentators.
  • The Met Gala is facing declining interest and is reportedly discounting tickets for the first time, reflecting a shift in fashion industry influence away from traditional media like Vogue.
  • Ratings for Savannah Guthrie's return to the 'Today Show' were underwhelming, highlighting the show's struggle to recapture past celebrity-driven viewership.

Insights

1Delayed Dobbs Decision Amidst Threats to Justices

Molly Hemingway's book reveals that after the draft Dobbs decision was leaked, liberal Supreme Court justices intentionally slow-walked their dissents for two months. This delay occurred while conservative justices faced serious threats, including an assassination attempt on Justice Kavanaugh, and despite requests from the majority to expedite the process. The dissenters even included a footnote to an unreleased decision, further delaying the final announcement.

Justice Alito's draft opinion was completed by early February 2022, with other conservative justices signing on immediately. However, the dissenters delayed their response, making the decision a 'C' (nowhere near done) in conference after the leak. Elena Kagan reportedly 'screamed' at Justice Breyer not to accommodate requests to speed up the dissent, ultimately delaying the final release by over three weeks.

2White House and DOJ Inaction on Judicial Threats

Following the Dobbs leak, massive protests erupted at the Supreme Court and justices' homes, and pro-life clinics were firebombed. Despite laws against intimidating judges, Merrick Garland's Department of Justice and the Biden White House, including then-Press Secretary Jen Psaki, refused to condemn or prosecute those protesting outside justices' private residences, effectively allowing the intimidation to continue.

Jen Psaki stated, 'I know that there's an outrage right now... about protests that have been peaceful to date and we certainly continue to encourage that outside of judges homes and that's the president's position.' This stance was maintained even after an individual attempted to assassinate Justice Kavanaugh.

3Breakdown of Collegiality on the Supreme Court

The Supreme Court has experienced a significant decline in collegiality, particularly since the Dobbs decision. Justice Clarence Thomas noted that the court is 'not the court of that era' regarding friendships among justices. Liberal justices have openly attacked the integrity of the court and their conservative colleagues in public forums, a departure from historical norms.

Justice Thomas, speaking to an audience in Dallas, expressed concern about 'keeping it at the court now' regarding friendships. Justices Kagan, Sotomayor, and Katanji Brown Jackson have publicly criticized the court's decisions, with Sotomayor even issuing a paper apology after ripping on Justice Kavanaugh.

4Meghan Markle and Prince Harry's 'Faux Royal Tour' Strategy

Meghan Markle and Prince Harry are engaging in 'faux royal tours' in Commonwealth countries, such as their recent trip to Australia, to maintain public interest and leverage their royal association for personal gain. Palace insiders are reportedly angry but feel powerless to stop them, as Harry's connection to Diana and his royal status ensures public turnout.

Rob Shuter states, 'The only thing that makes these two people interesting is the royal family... He will always be Diana's son. He will always be Harry... he doesn't need the royals family to be a part-time royal. He is a part-time royal.' The tours are seen as a 'prototype' for future engagements, despite being perceived as 'tone-deaf' and 'cosplay' by critics.

5The Met Gala's Declining Influence and Financial Struggles

The Met Gala, once a pinnacle of fashion and celebrity, is reportedly struggling to sell tickets and has resorted to discounting prices for the first time. Its declining relevance is attributed to the diminished influence of Vogue magazine and its editor, Anna Wintour, as designers increasingly prioritize digital influencers over traditional media for brand exposure.

Rob Shuter reported that the Met Gala 'has not sold out' and designers are questioning the return on investment for tables costing 'hundreds of thousands of dollars' when 'Vogue is no longer a success.' The event has also shifted towards featuring reality stars, further eroding its perceived glamour.

6Internal Drama and Low Ratings at the Today Show

The 'Today Show' is experiencing internal tensions and disappointing ratings, particularly following Savannah Guthrie's return. The show's attempt to generate a 'massive moment' around her comeback fell flat, with only modest viewership increases. Underlying this is a long-standing, 'vicious' rivalry between Savannah Guthrie and Hoda Kotb, dating back to Matt Lauer's tenure.

Savannah's return saw a 6% increase in overall viewers and a mere 2% in the key 25-54 demo, far below NBC's expectations. Rob Shuter's reporting indicates that 'Savannah and Hoda have never got along,' and Hoda's promotion was initially a 'punishment' by Matt Lauer against Savannah.

Quotes

"

"I'm just worried about keeping it at the court now. This is not the court of that era."

Justice Clarence Thomas
"

"I know that there's an outrage right now... about protests that have been peaceful to date and we certainly continue to encourage that outside of judges homes and that's the president's position."

Jen Psaki
"

"If you see a photograph of a celebrity in full hair and makeup looking fabulous walking through the park maybe with a with a puppy or maybe a baby that is probably staged. If you see a photograph of a celebrity picking their nose at Starbucks that is not staged."

Rob Shuter
"

"The only thing that makes these two people interesting is the royal family. The one thing they're trying to run away from, the one thing that they say they want no part of, that's all they've got."

Rob Shuter
"

"Megan's bubble has still not shattered. They think this trip was wildly successful. They're going to use this as a as a prototype, as a roll out for other countries. And now you can expect to see them going on tour like their Beyonce or Madonna except when they turn up in your country, they've got nothing to sell."

Rob Shuter
"

"The Today Show still operates as if it's 2000. They still think that they are the most important game in town. And that's no longer the case. And so wake up, smell the coffee."

Rob Shuter

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes