The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show
January 6, 2026

Debating Trump's Maduro Approach, Mamdani's Extreme Tenant Pick's Views, with Greenwald and Lowry

Quick Read

Megyn Kelly, Glenn Greenwald, and Rich Lowry dissect Trump's 'keep the oil' Venezuela policy, New York City's radical tenant advocate, and a clarinetist's career derailed by DEI policies, highlighting journalistic failures and the erosion of meritocracy.
New York Times accused of journalistic failure for a 'puff piece' on Brian Coberger's sister, ignoring critical background.
Trump's Venezuela policy, including 'keeping the oil,' sparks debate over American imperialism and a shift from his non-interventionist promises.
A clarinetist wins a blind audition but is denied the job due to his past opposition to DEI, illustrating meritocracy's erosion.

Summary

The episode features Megyn Kelly, Glenn Greenwald, and Rich Lowry discussing several contentious topics. They criticize the New York Times for a 'puff piece' on Brian Coberger's sister, alleging journalistic negligence in failing to scrutinize her claims against extensive prior reporting. The conversation then shifts to former President Trump's aggressive stance on Venezuela, including his 'keep the oil' rhetoric and the perceived shift towards interventionism, which Greenwald argues contradicts his base's anti-war sentiment, while Lowry defends it as a resurrection of the Monroe Doctrine. The hosts also expose the extreme views of New York City's new tenant advocate, CIA Weaver, who advocates for 'impoverishing the white middle class' and views homeownership as racist. Finally, they cover the story of James Zimmerman, a clarinetist who won a blind audition but was denied a job due to his past opposition to DEI policies at another orchestra, framing it as a case of meritocracy being sacrificed for ideological purity.
This episode exposes critical issues across journalism, foreign policy, urban governance, and cultural institutions. It highlights how journalistic integrity can be compromised, the potential for a return to interventionist foreign policy under populist leaders, the dangers of radical ideologies in public office, and the real-world consequences of DEI initiatives on individual careers and merit-based systems. The discussions underscore a broader concern about accountability, transparency, and the impact of ideological capture on various sectors of society.

Takeaways

  • The New York Times published a 'rehabilitative puff piece' on Brian Coberger's sister, omitting crucial details about the family's potential knowledge and suspicious behavior.
  • Donald Trump's stated intention to 'keep the oil' in Venezuela signals a potential return to resource-driven interventionism, contradicting his previous anti-regime change rhetoric.
  • NYC's new tenant advocate, CIA Weaver, advocates for 'impoverishing the white middle class' and views homeownership as 'racist,' reflecting extreme socialist and anti-white sentiments.
  • A professional clarinetist, James Zimmerman, won a blind audition but was denied the position due to his prior stance against DEI policies, raising concerns about meritocracy in arts organizations.
  • Mainstream media outlets are criticized for failing to conduct investigative journalism on the Minneapolis Somali daycare fraud, instead focusing on discrediting independent reporters.

Insights

1New York Times Accused of Journalistic Failure in Coberger Interview

Megyn Kelly and Glenn Greenwald criticize the New York Times for publishing an interview with Brian Coberger's sister, Mel, which they describe as a 'rehabilitative puff piece.' Kelly argues the reporter, Mike Baker, failed to scrutinize Mel's claims, particularly her assertion that she only briefly considered her brother's involvement due to a car model year discrepancy, despite extensive prior reporting (e.g., by Howard Bloom) suggesting the family, including Mel, had more suspicions and witnessed suspicious behavior (like disposing of trash in Ziploc bags in a neighbor's bin). Kelly also highlights the omission of Brian Coberger's phone calls with his mother totaling over three hours immediately after the murders.

Mel Coberger's claims about car model year and lack of suspicion; omission of Brian Coberger's phone records with his mother; Howard Bloom's prior reporting on family suspicions and suspicious behavior.

2Trump's 'Keep the Oil' Venezuela Policy Sparks Imperialism Debate

Donald Trump's explicit statement to Joe Scarborough that the U.S. will 'keep the oil' in Venezuela, following the ousting of Maduro, is debated. Glenn Greenwald argues this contradicts Trump's prior anti-regime change stance and is a dangerous, self-serving policy that will lead to a 'guerrilla war' and benefit only oil conglomerates. He points out the shifting rationales for intervention (drugs, liberation) and the lack of campaign discussion. Rich Lowry, conversely, defends the action as a modern application of the Monroe Doctrine, a 'minimalistic' intervention to counter a hostile regime allied with U.S. enemies and project American power, despite the 'pretextual' nature of the 'law enforcement operation' claim.

Trump's quote: 'We are going to keep the oil.' Greenwald's analysis of shifting rationales and potential for 'guerrilla war.' Lowry's defense citing the Monroe Doctrine and 'minimalistic' intervention.

3NYC Tenant Advocate Advocates for 'Impoverishing White Middle Class'

New York City's new tenant advocate, CIA Weaver, is exposed for extreme views, including advocating to 'impoverish the white middle class,' declaring 'home ownership is racist,' and promoting 'rent control and public housing for everyone.' Rich Lowry notes that Weaver's views align with Mayor Mamdani's, who cited South Africa as a model. Kelly and Lowry criticize these policies as economically illiterate and morally reprehensible, highlighting their historical failure (e.g., 'the Bronx is burning' due to rent control) and discriminatory nature.

CIA Weaver's social media posts: 'Impoverish the white middle class. Home ownership is racist,' 'Rent control is a perfect solution to everything.' Mamdani's reference to South Africa as a model.

4Clarinetist Denied Job After Winning Blind Audition Due to DEI Opposition

James Zimmerman, a highly accomplished clarinetist, won a blind audition for the Knoxville Symphony but was subsequently denied the position. He alleges this was due to his past opposition to DEI policies at the Nashville Symphony, where he advocated for a black oboist to get a fair chance but later opposed the oboist's permanent hire based on performance and 'woke' activism, leading to Zimmerman's own termination. Zimmerman's lawsuit claims discrimination based on skin color and retaliation for exercising his rights, with the DOJ's civil rights division reportedly showing interest.

Zimmerman winning a blind audition; Knoxville Symphony CEO Rachel Ford's alleged reason for not hiring him; Zimmerman's account of the Nashville Symphony incident, including the 'Jesse Smollett-like narrative' against him and the 'human virtue signal' accusation.

5Mainstream Media Fails to Investigate Somali Daycare Fraud, Attacks Independent Journalists

Megyn Kelly and Rich Lowry criticize mainstream media outlets, including the Minneapolis Star Tribune, New York Times, and AP, for their failure to conduct investigative journalism into the alleged Somali daycare fraud in Minneapolis. Instead of uncovering the fraud, these outlets are accused of 'covering for the scandal,' 'attacking the guy who advanced the story' (independent journalist Nick Shirley), and framing the criticism as a 'political campaign against Somali Minnesotans,' allegedly due to fears of being labeled racist. This highlights a perceived dereliction of duty and a focus on narrative control over factual reporting.

Minneapolis Star Tribune's focus on 'trans policies' over fraud; New York Times accusing Nick Shirley of 'politically charged footage'; AP relying on a daycare head's defense; Minnesota Lieutenant Governor Peggy Flanigan's 'culturally appropriated' hijab and defense of the Somali community.

Bottom Line

Trump's 'audacious' foreign policy, exemplified by the Venezuela intervention, combines aggressive military action with a 'high degree of caution' to minimize downside risk, creating a new model of 'minimalist imperialism' that might appeal to a base tired of prolonged wars while still projecting strength.

So What?

This approach could redefine U.S. foreign policy, allowing for swift, decisive actions without the long-term commitments of traditional nation-building, but risks unpredictable 'blowback' and alienating allies if perceived as unilateral or purely self-interested.

Impact

Analysts should study this 'audacious but cautious' intervention model to understand its effectiveness, political appeal, and long-term geopolitical implications, especially in regions where U.S. influence is contested.

The case of James Zimmerman reveals that 'blind auditions,' designed to ensure meritocracy, are being undermined by post-audition background checks that screen for ideological compliance (specifically on DEI), effectively reintroducing bias and punishing individuals for past 'wrongthink.'

So What?

This suggests that DEI initiatives, when implemented without clear boundaries, can paradoxically erode the very meritocratic principles they claim to enhance, leading to a chilling effect on free speech and an environment where ideological purity trumps talent and performance.

Impact

Organizations committed to true meritocracy should re-evaluate their hiring processes, ensuring that post-audition background checks do not become tools for ideological vetting, and establish clear policies to protect employees from retaliation for expressing dissenting views on internal policies.

Key Concepts

Journalistic Quid Pro Quo

Glenn Greenwald describes how journalists can compromise their objectivity when a source provides a significant story, leading them to become an 'advocate' for the source rather than a neutral interrogator, often by omitting inconvenient facts to maintain access or benefit their career.

Monroe Doctrine (Resurrected)

Rich Lowry frames Trump's Venezuela intervention as a modern application of the Monroe Doctrine, asserting U.S. supremacy in the Western Hemisphere to exclude foreign adversaries and address regional instability, even if it involves 'pretextual' acts of war.

Blowback (CIA Term)

Glenn Greenwald uses the CIA term 'blowback' to explain the long-term, unintended negative consequences that arise from aggressive foreign policy actions, such as bullying other countries or taking their resources, leading to widespread anti-American sentiment and empowering rival powers like China.

Virtue Signaling (Human)

James Zimmerman describes how the Nashville Symphony management used the black oboist as a 'human virtue signal,' parading him around for his skin color to demonstrate their righteousness, which Zimmerman argues is inherently racist and tokenizing.

Lessons

  • Demand greater journalistic scrutiny: Be skeptical of 'exclusive' interviews that lack critical follow-up questions or ignore extensive prior reporting, especially when dealing with sensitive legal cases or political narratives.
  • Monitor local government appointments: Investigate the stated views and past statements of public officials, particularly those in influential roles, to understand their ideological leanings and potential impact on policy.
  • Support independent journalism: Recognize the value of independent journalists who undertake investigative work that mainstream media may avoid due to political correctness or other biases, and hold legacy media accountable for their reporting gaps.
  • Advocate for merit-based systems: Challenge instances where ideological purity or DEI mandates appear to override merit, especially in professional fields where objective performance is measurable, to prevent the erosion of talent and fair opportunity.
  • Understand geopolitical shifts: Pay attention to changes in foreign policy rhetoric and actions, particularly regarding interventionism and resource control, to anticipate potential international conflicts and their domestic implications.

Notable Moments

Megyn Kelly criticizes the New York Times for a 'rehabilitative puff piece' on Brian Coberger's sister, highlighting journalistic failures and omissions.

This segment exposes how major news outlets can compromise journalistic integrity by failing to scrutinize sources, especially in high-profile criminal cases, potentially manipulating public perception.

Glenn Greenwald and Rich Lowry debate Trump's 'keep the oil' policy in Venezuela, with Greenwald arguing against imperialism and Lowry defending it as a return to the Monroe Doctrine.

This discussion reveals a significant shift in U.S. foreign policy rhetoric and action, sparking debate about American interventionism, its motivations, and potential long-term consequences, both domestically and internationally.

The hosts expose NYC tenant advocate CIA Weaver's radical views, including 'impoverishing the white middle class' and calling homeownership 'racist.'

This highlights the infiltration of extreme ideologies into local governance, demonstrating how radical views can shape public policy with potentially destructive economic and social outcomes.

James Zimmerman details how he won a blind audition for the Knoxville Symphony but was denied the job due to his past opposition to DEI policies at the Nashville Symphony.

This personal story illustrates the real-world impact of DEI initiatives on individual careers and the erosion of meritocratic principles in cultural institutions, raising questions about fairness and ideological conformity.

Criticism of mainstream media for failing to investigate the Minneapolis Somali daycare fraud, instead attacking independent journalists who broke the story.

This segment underscores a perceived crisis in investigative journalism, where fear of being labeled 'racist' or adherence to certain narratives prevents major outlets from pursuing critical stories, leaving it to independent reporters.

Quotes

"

"If your mind goes to my brother might be the homicidal maniac who took those four lives, but technically his white Elantra was built two years after the years they're looking for, I'm calling on you. If you've placed your sibling in the field of possible killers, you're actually not relieved that that maybe it was a the cut off was 2013 as opposed to 2015."

Megyn Kelly
"

"The president's response, Joe, on the difference between Iraq and Venezuela is that Bush didn't keep the oil. We are going to keep the oil."

Donald Trump (quoted by Joe Scarborough)
"

"This is like a very psychological need that I think comes from weakness that a lot of people feel like they don't get to really go to war... by getting to watch our military from afar carry out successful operations, people get to feel strong and powerful."

Glenn Greenwald
"

"Impoverish the white middle class. Home ownership is racist. Failed public policy. Impoverish the white middle class is the stated goal of our new tenant ZAR in New York."

CIA Weaver (quoted by Megyn Kelly)
"

"We're not accepting people from immigration, ICE agents, DHS into our property. It's just a management ownership."

Hampton Inn Front Desk Manager
"

"It's a human virtue signal, which by the way is quite racist to tokenize somebody and do this. Parade them around for their skin color. And I objected to all of this."

James Zimmerman

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

Sunny Hostin LOSES IT Over Ava Navarro And The View Panel CELEBRATING Trump Arresting Nicolas Maduro
Black Conservative PerspectiveJan 5, 2026

Sunny Hostin LOSES IT Over Ava Navarro And The View Panel CELEBRATING Trump Arresting Nicolas Maduro

"The host dissects the controversial US-led arrest of Venezuelan dictator Nicolas Maduro, celebrating the outcome while fiercely critiquing 'The View' panel's 'Trump derangement' and perceived hypocrisy regarding international law and regime change."

VenezuelaNicolas MaduroDonald Trump+2
HOT TOPICS | WARNING: Donald Trump's Iran War Chaos Has Hit the Point of No Return!
The Don Lemon ShowApr 1, 2026

HOT TOPICS | WARNING: Donald Trump's Iran War Chaos Has Hit the Point of No Return!

"Don Lemon delivers a scathing critique of Donald Trump's recent actions, framing them as desperate, unconstitutional attempts to consolidate power, undermine democracy, and distract from economic and foreign policy failures, all while questioning his mental stability."

Donald TrumpElection IntegrityMail-in Voting+2
Trump 1 Year Approval TANKS Over Economy, ICE Raids
Breaking PointsJan 21, 2026

Trump 1 Year Approval TANKS Over Economy, ICE Raids

"One year into his second term, Donald Trump's approval ratings on the economy, immigration, and foreign policy have significantly declined, driven by an 'expectation vs. reality' gap in policy implementation and a perceived lack of focus on domestic affordability."

Donald TrumpApproval RatingsEconomy+2
Young Venezuelan DESTROYS Zohran Mamdani LASHING OUT Against Trump Arresting Socialist Dictator!
Black Conservative PerspectiveJan 4, 2026

Young Venezuelan DESTROYS Zohran Mamdani LASHING OUT Against Trump Arresting Socialist Dictator!

"A Venezuelan immigrant details the devastating impact of socialism in his home country and celebrates the US-led arrest of Nicolás Maduro, contrasting it with the opposition from American socialists like NYC Mayor Zohran Mamdani."

Venezuelan politicsNicolás MaduroSocialism+2