"We Had Whistles. They Had Guns": Nationwide Protests Held over ICE Killing of Renee Good
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Renee Good, a mother of three, was fatally shot by ICE agent Jonathan Ross in Minneapolis after a brief encounter captured on video.
- ❖Footage shows Good calmly speaking to Ross, saying "I'm not mad at you," before the shooting, directly contradicting federal claims of her weaponizing her vehicle.
- ❖Following the shooting, a male voice, possibly Ross's, was heard saying "Effing bitch."
- ❖Homeland Security Secretary Christy Nome, Donald Trump, and JD Vance immediately labeled Good a 'domestic terrorist' and defended the agent's actions.
- ❖ICE agent Jonathan Ross is a firearms instructor with a history of defending white supremacists online and is described as a 'hardcore conservative Christian and MAGA supporter.'
- ❖Federal authorities, including the FBI, refused to cooperate with Minnesota's Bureau of Criminal Apprehension in the investigation, withholding evidence.
- ❖Civil rights attorney Nikima Levy Armstrong argues that state and local officials have the authority to charge and arrest Jonathan Ross for murder.
- ❖Nationwide protests, led by the 'ICE out for good' campaign, erupted from Los Angeles to New York, demanding justice and accountability.
- ❖The largest deployment of ICE agents in US history is occurring in Minneapolis, which activists believe is retaliation for the governor's political stance.
Insights
1Contradictory Narratives on Renee Good's Killing
Newly released video footage of Renee Good's encounter with ICE agent Jonathan Ross shows her calmly telling him, "I'm not mad at you," just before she was shot. This directly contradicts the narrative pushed by Homeland Security Secretary Christy Nome, Donald Trump, and JD Vance, who immediately claimed Good 'weaponized her vehicle' and engaged in 'domestic terrorism.' The host highlights the stark difference between the official federal stance and the visual evidence.
Good's wife, Becca, stated, 'We had whistles, they had guns.' The video shows Good sitting in her car, speaking calmly. A male voice, possibly Ross's, is heard saying 'Effing bitch' after the shooting. Federal officials, including Christy Nome, publicly asserted Good 'weaponized her vehicle to conduct an act of violence against a law enforcement officer and the public.'
2Federal Obstruction of State Investigation
The federal government, through the FBI, explicitly disinvited Minnesota's Bureau of Criminal Apprehension (BCA) from participating in the investigation into Renee Good's killing and refused to share evidence. This move effectively blocked the state's primary agency for investigating deadly force from performing its duties, leading to initial silence from state and local Democratic officials.
The FBI made it clear they were disinviting the Bureau of Criminal Apprehension, stating they could no longer participate and would not share evidence. Civil rights attorney Nikima Levy Armstrong noted, 'there was silence on the part of a lot of our elected officials... after that.'
3ICE Agent Jonathan Ross's Background and Perceived Motives
ICE agent Jonathan Ross, identified by the Minnesota Star Tribune, is a firearms instructor with a history of defending white supremacists online. Described by friends and family as a 'hardcore conservative Christian and MAGA supporter,' his actions are framed by the guest as potentially driven by hate, particularly towards women, given Good's unarmed and calm demeanor.
The Minnesota Star Tribune reported Ross 'appears to have defended white supremacists online,' was deployed to Iraq, and is described as a 'hardcore conservative Christian and MAGA supporter.' Nikima Levy Armstrong stated, 'the way in which he treated Renee Good from my perspective demonstrated hate towards women.'
4Call for Local Accountability Despite Federal Immunity Claims
Despite claims from federal officials like JD Vance that federal agents have 'complete immunity,' civil rights attorney Nikima Levy Armstrong asserts that Minnesota state and local authorities possess the legal power to charge and arrest Jonathan Ross for Renee Good's murder. She highlights a double standard, noting a civilian would be immediately arrested for similar actions.
JD Vance claimed 'federal agents have complete immunity, which is a lie.' Nikima Levy Armstrong stated, 'under the law, you are able to charge and arrest Jonathan Ross for the murder of Renee Good' and contrasted it with the immediate arrest of a young Black man for a similar crime.
5Increased ICE Deployment as Alleged Political Retaliation
Minneapolis is experiencing the largest deployment of ICE agents in US history, with agents reportedly engaging in aggressive tactics like dragging people from cars, breaking down doors, and arresting employees at local stores. Activists believe this surge is intentional retaliation against Minnesota's governor for challenging Donald Trump and MAGA.
Nikima Levy Armstrong stated, 'the largest deployment of ICE agents in US history, it's not a coincidence that this is happening. And we believe in retaliation for our governor running to become the vice president of the United States and taking on Donald Trump and MAGA.' She described agents 'dragging people out of their cars, busting down people's doors... showing up at at local Target stores and arresting employees.'
Lessons
- Challenge official government narratives that contradict video evidence or witness accounts, especially in cases of law enforcement use of force.
- Support local and state efforts to investigate federal agents when federal agencies refuse to cooperate, advocating for state-level charges where applicable.
- Engage with civil rights organizations and activist groups like the Racial Justice Network to demand accountability and justice for victims of alleged police misconduct.
Quotes
"She weaponized her vehicle to conduct an act of violence against a law enforcement officer and the public."
"If they can call her a domestic terrorist, then we're all domestic terrorists."
"DHS Secretary Christy Nome is not only lying, she's rushing to judgment."
"The largest deployment of ICE agents in US history, it's not a coincidence that this is happening. And we believe in retaliation for our governor running to become the vice president of the United States and taking on Donald Trump and MAGA."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes

Black Woman Killed in ICE Pursuit. Newsom “Can’t Read” Remark. Tariff Repayment Push. TPS Fight
"This episode dissects multiple critical events, from the tragic deaths during an ICE pursuit and a police shooting, to debunking a viral controversy around Governor Gavin Newsom's remarks, and honoring Reverend Jesse Jackson's enduring legacy in economic and media justice."

Don Lemon, Georgia Fort Arrested Over Church Protest. Press Freedom on the Line Under Trump.
"The Trump administration's arrest of journalists Don Lemon and Georgia Fort for covering a church protest is framed as a direct assault on press freedom and a calculated distraction from the release of damaging Epstein files."

HOT TOPICS | MAGA Tries to Justify Another ICE Shooting. WTF Is Wrong With These People?!
"Don Lemon and his guests vehemently condemn the ICE shooting of Alex Prey, accusing the Trump administration of intentional lawlessness, weaponizing federal agencies, and manipulating public discourse through lies and media complicity."

Trump Impact On Black America. SCOTUS Birthright Citizenship Case. Alabama College DEI probe
"This episode dissects the multifaceted impacts of Trump-era policies on Black America, from economic destabilization and civil rights rollbacks to an inspiring narrative of an entrepreneur rebuilding her life and community."