The Definition Of A 2-Way Player TRIGGERS Gil's Arena
YouTube · JNsy9Px8hDA
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Gil Arenas defines a "gold standard" two-way player as a top 2-3 scorer (29-30+ PPG) and a First-Team All-Defense selection.
- ❖He argues that players like Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, and Hakeem Olajuwon exemplify this elite tier.
- ❖Other hosts contend that players like Klay Thompson, Gary Payton, and Kawhi Leonard (in his DPOY years) are legitimate two-way players despite not always reaching Gil's scoring thresholds.
- ❖The debate centers on whether "two-way" requires statistical dominance or simply high-level impact on both ends of the court.
- ❖Gil criticizes the media for "watering down" statistical categories to include more players, using the triple-double stat (Draymond Green vs. Oscar Robertson/Westbrook) as an analogy.
Insights
1Gil's Elite Two-Way Player Criteria
Gil asserts that a true "two-way player" must be a top 2-3 scorer in the league (averaging 29-30+ points) and simultaneously a First-Team All-Defense selection. He cites historical figures like Michael Jordan, Kobe Bryant, Hakeem Olajuwon, and Shaquille O'Neal as examples of this "gold standard."
Two-way players were very high level scorers, top two, three in the league and they were first team defense... When we think about the Kobes, the the Keem Elijah ones, the Shaquille O'Neals, the Kobe, the Jordans, those guys are top 23 in scoring. They're averaging 2930 in scoring and they're locking down on defense.
2Critique of "Watered Down" Definitions
Gil argues that the definition of a two-way player has been diluted by the media, similar to how other statistical categories (like triple-doubles) have been broadened to include players with less dominant numbers. He uses the example of Draymond Green's triple-double stats being grouped with Oscar Robertson and Russell Westbrook despite significantly lower scoring averages.
They lowered it down for everyone to be consult a two-way player... They dumbed the stat down to put Draymond in it... Same thing with two-way players. There was a two there was two-way players that averaged at least led the league in scoring or was number two with 29 to 32 and was first team defense. Then they dropped it all the way down to guys who average 2021 and put him in the same tier even though it's two different tiers of scoring and they just dumbed down the thought of what a two-way player was.
3Alternative View: High-Level Effectiveness on Both Ends
Other hosts counter that a player doesn't need to be a top-tier scorer to be considered a two-way player, as long as they provide high-level impact on both offense and defense. They argue that players like Klay Thompson (averaging 23 points), Gary Payton (averaged 24 points as his high), and Kawhi Leonard (averaging 21 points during a DPOY season) demonstrate sufficient two-way ability.
You don't have to leave the league in scoring and be to be considered a two-way guy... He's a two-way player and there's no distinction. Like I'm not just I'm not I'm not putting... I know I know what he's saying. I said I know what he's saying but I don't agree with it. That's what I'm saying. I hear him but I don't agree with saying that guys like Clay and other guys that average 22 23 and and can lock down a lower tier at anything cuz it ain't easy to average 23 24 in his league... It doesn't matter about your stat. It means we respect you on both. We respect you on both sides of the ball.
4The "Who is They?" Challenge
A recurring point of contention is Gil's reference to "they" (the media) who allegedly watered down the criteria. Other hosts repeatedly challenge him to specify who "they" are, highlighting the subjective nature of these evolving definitions and the lack of a clear, official body setting these standards.
Who is they? You keep saying they... What media, Gil? Any media, dog?
Quotes
"Two-way players were very high level scorers, top two, three in the league and they were first team defense."
"You don't have to leave the league in scoring and be to be considered a two-way guy."
"It doesn't matter about your stat. It means we respect you on both. We respect you on both sides of the ball."
"They moved the criteria so far down to make... you still ain't told me who is they."
"I watch basketball and I know Thaddeus Young don't belong on that [expletive] page."
"When they first did this that it was only gold members of this. Now it's silver and bronze and you're trying to mix it in like they're together."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
Gil's Arena COOKS Skip Bayless For HATING On LeBron
"Skip Bayless passionately defends his controversial ranking of LeBron James as the ninth-best NBA player of all time, citing perceived mental fragility and clutch failures, while the hosts vehemently counter with statistical dominance and career longevity."
IS WEMBY GETTING SPECIAL TREATMENT FROM THE NBA, CARMELO SAYS PLAYERS SHOULD STREAM & IS UTAH LIT?!
"Carmelo Anthony's radical proposal for NBA players to stream post-game instead of traditional press conferences sparks a debate on player autonomy, league regulations, and brand management, while the NBA's handling of Wemby's ejection raises questions of favoritism."
The Pat McAfee Show Live | Wednesday May 13th 2026
"Pat McAfee and guests dive into the latest in sports, from NBA playoff drama and NFL international expansion debates to Ronda Rousey's MMA return and college football buzz, all while sharing wild behind-the-scenes stories from the Disney upfronts."
Unc, Ocho & Iso react to Cavs beat Hawks, Cade returns, JJ Redick drama brewing w/ Lakers | Nightcap
"The hosts dissect critical NBA playoff races, the financial implications of player contracts, and the brewing internal drama within the Lakers, offering strong opinions on player power and team management."