The Oreo Problem! | Are You Garbage Comedy Podcast w/ Kevin Ryan & H. Foley

Quick Read

The hosts hilariously dissect the perceived decline of Double Stuffed Oreos, lamenting shrinkflation and a broader cultural decay, while also celebrating the unique charm of hotel bars and the unexpected delights of Utah's Maverick gas stations.
Double Stuffed Oreos are a casualty of 'shrinkflation,' sparking a debate on corporate integrity and cultural decline.
The hosts share personal histories of financial 'dirtbaggery,' including strategic bill avoidance and the non-existence of debtor's prison.
Utah's Maverick gas stations are lauded for their custom soda mixes and clean facilities, offering a unique regional experience.

Summary

In this episode, Kevin Ryan and H. Foley dive into a range of everyday observations and personal anecdotes, starting with a passionate rant about the alleged shrinkflation of Double Stuffed Oreos, which they frame as a symptom of societal decline. They discuss past financial 'dirtbaggery,' including avoiding bills and the concept of 'debtor's prison.' The conversation shifts to the unexpected appeal of local hotel bars as hangout spots and the discovery of Maverick gas stations in Utah, praised for their custom soda mixes and clean facilities, contrasting them with familiar East Coast staples like Wawa and Sheets. The hosts also share nostalgic memories of childhood snacks, family dynamics, and the evolution of convenience stores, all delivered with their characteristic comedic takes on what constitutes 'garbage' behavior.
This episode offers a relatable and humorous lens through which to view common consumer frustrations, the evolution of personal finance, and the nostalgic pull of childhood experiences. It highlights how seemingly trivial changes, like a cookie's cream filling, can spark broader cultural commentary, while also celebrating the hidden gems of local establishments and the quirks of regional culture.

Takeaways

  • The perceived reduction in Double Stuffed Oreo cream filling is a sign of 'shrinkflation' and cultural decline.
  • Financial 'dirtbaggery,' like delaying bill payments, is a learned behavior with minimal credit impact unless it involves loans.
  • Hotel bars can be surprisingly good local hangout spots, offering clean environments and unique social dynamics.
  • Utah's Maverick gas stations are praised for their extensive custom soda bar options, influenced by local culture.
  • Nostalgia for specific childhood snacks (Chewy Chips Ahoy, Soft Batch cookies) and regional stores (Wawa, Sheets) is a strong theme.

Insights

1The Oreo Shrinkflation Problem

The hosts express dismay over the perceived reduction in cream filling in Double Stuffed Oreos, attributing it to 'shrinkflation' and a broader cultural decline. One host suggests the 'double stuff' and 'creme' spellings are legal loopholes to reduce content without false advertising.

A picture of a 'double stuffed' Oreo showing minimal filling is presented. Online reports confirm consumer complaints about smaller cookies and less cream. The host states, 'That is a double stuffed Oreo... When we were kids, those things, it was double that.'

2The Art of Financial 'Dirtbaggery'

The hosts discuss strategies for delaying bill payments without credit score repercussions, noting that only money-lending institutions report to credit bureaus. They share personal anecdotes about growing up with parents who strategically avoided opening bills.

One host states, 'You can go crazy long without paying it... It will... only ding your credit if they front you money.' Another recalls, 'I was at a very young age when I realized how not good the money sitch was by how highly stacked the unopen mail was.'

3The Unexpected Appeal of Hotel Bars

Despite initial skepticism, the hosts agree that local hotel bars, particularly those in establishments like Hilton, can be excellent, clean, and affordable hangout spots, offering a unique atmosphere and diverse clientele compared to traditional bars.

One host remarks, 'I love that. Because dude, everyone... they throw a [expletive] chicken Caesar at you. Turn your day around. There's chicks in there coming in and out. Business guys. That's a popping spot.' They recall a 'great' hotel bar in Rochester.

4Maverick: Utah's Premier Gas Station Experience

The hosts discover and praise Maverick gas stations in Utah, highlighting their clean facilities, extensive made-to-order food options, and unique custom soda bar. The custom soda mixes are attributed to the local Mormon culture's abstinence from alcohol, leading to creative non-alcoholic drink concoctions.

Upon seeing pictures, hosts exclaim, 'Whoa, that's sweet. That place looks [expletive] sick.' They detail custom drinks like 'Midnight Overlook Coke Zero Coconut Syrup. Hazel Creamer' and note, 'These Mormons have figured. They are [expletive] locked in when it comes to the Nutty Ridge...'

Lessons

  • Re-evaluate your perception of 'Double Stuffed' Oreos; examine the cream filling to observe potential shrinkflation.
  • Consider the financial implications of bill payments: understand which services report to credit bureaus versus those that don't, but pay your bills.
  • Explore local hotel bars as a potential clean, affordable, and interesting alternative to traditional nightlife spots.
  • If traveling through Utah, seek out Maverick gas stations for their unique custom soda bar and food offerings.
  • Reflect on childhood food nostalgia and how corporate changes to beloved products can evoke broader feelings about cultural shifts.

Quotes

"

"We are in decline. We are in decay. Culturally, we're jammed up."

H. Foley
"

"If you can't trust Oreo, it's like, where are we at? Just [expletive] pull the trigger. What are we doing?"

H. Foley
"

"These Mormons have figured. They are [expletive] locked in when it comes to the Nutty Ridge, the Bunk House Brew, the Red Rocket Velvet, the Red Mesa Ripple."

H. Foley

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

Mile High Club w/ Mark Normand! | Are You Garbage Comedy Podcast w/ Kevin Ryan & H. Foley
Are You Garbage? Comedy PodcastMar 22, 2026

Mile High Club w/ Mark Normand! | Are You Garbage Comedy Podcast w/ Kevin Ryan & H. Foley

"Comedian Mark Normand joins the 'Are You Garbage?' hosts to dissect what truly defines 'classy' versus 'trashy' behavior, from self-checkout theft to the perils of owning a vintage car and the unexpected realities of cruise ship life."

ComedyPersonal AnecdotesConsumer Behavior+2
Elijah Wood Eats His Last Meal
Last MealsMar 26, 2026

Elijah Wood Eats His Last Meal

"Elijah Wood reflects on his unconventional career path, the philosophy behind his genre film production company, and the profound influence of his mother's humility lessons, all while sharing his ultimate last meal."

Acting CareerLord of the RingsCelebrity Lifestyle+2
Picking Your Nose Is Cool | The Basement Yard #549
The Basement YardApr 6, 2026

Picking Your Nose Is Cool | The Basement Yard #549

"The hosts dive into a hilariously unfiltered discussion on everything from the social etiquette of nose-picking to childhood athletic prowess, revealing their unique and often gross personal habits and nostalgic memories."

Childhood MemoriesFood HabitsSocial Norms+2
STILL SIPPIN W/ POUR MINDS, KARLOUS MILLER & MONEYBAG MAFIA | 85 SOUTH SHOW
85 SouthApr 3, 2026

STILL SIPPIN W/ POUR MINDS, KARLOUS MILLER & MONEYBAG MAFIA | 85 SOUTH SHOW

"The 85 South Show hosts and guests Poor Minds and Moneybag Mafia engage in a hilariously unfiltered discussion covering relationship dynamics, unexpected business ventures, and the pervasive influence of TikTok, all while sharing their unique perspectives on life's absurdities."

Podcasting industryEntrepreneurshipAnimal facts