The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show
February 3, 2026

Shock New Details About Guthrie Kidnapping, and Lemon's Absurd Kimmel Appearance, with Lowry & Cooke

Quick Read

Megyn Kelly and her guests dissect the latest details in the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping, expose the legal absurdity of Don Lemon's church protest defense, and critique the cluelessness of celebrity activism on immigration.
Nancy Guthrie's kidnapping involves blood evidence, forced entry, and critical pacemaker data, with authorities expressing dire concern over her medication needs.
Don Lemon's church protest indictment highlights media double standards regarding First Amendment protections, particularly when compared to how Jan 6 journalists were treated.
Celebrity 'activism' on 'stolen land' and immigration is critiqued for its superficiality and lack of practical commitment, as exemplified by Billie Eilish and Jack Antinoff.

Summary

Megyn Kelly and her guests, former FBI agent James Fitzgerald, Las Vegas Police Lieutenant Randy Sutton, Rich Lowry, and Charlie Cook, analyze three major news stories. They provide an in-depth update on the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping, detailing critical evidence like blood, forced entry, pacemaker data, and the sheriff's urgent plea regarding her medication. The discussion highlights the multi-agency investigation, victimology, and potential motives like ransom or revenge, considering the proximity to the Mexican border. The episode then pivots to a sharp critique of Don Lemon's indictment for his church protest, arguing that his First Amendment defense is a misapplication of the law and exposing inconsistencies in media commentary. Finally, they lambast celebrity activism, specifically Billie Eilish's 'no one is illegal on stolen land' comment, contrasting it with the Tongva tribe's response, and mock Jack Antinoff's inability to explain his 'ice out' pin. The segment concludes with a condemnation of a federal judge's 'activist' ruling blocking the reversal of temporary protected status for Haitians.
This episode provides critical updates on a high-stakes kidnapping, revealing the complexities of modern forensic investigations and the human element of such crises. It also offers a pointed critique of media double standards, judicial overreach, and the superficiality of celebrity activism, prompting listeners to critically evaluate public discourse on legal principles, civil rights, and immigration policy.

Takeaways

  • Nancy Guthrie's kidnapping involved signs of forced entry and blood evidence, with her DNA confirmed at the scene but no other profiles found yet.
  • Nancy's pacemaker stopped syncing with her Apple Watch around 2 AM, providing a critical timeline for investigators.
  • The sheriff expressed dire concern over Nancy's need for medication, stating it could be fatal if not received within 24 hours.
  • Don Lemon's indictment for protesting in a church is criticized as a clear violation of the FACE Act, with his First Amendment defense deemed a misapplication of journalistic protections.
  • The hosts highlight 'The View' host Ana Navarro's inconsistent stance on grand jury indictments, praising them for Trump but condemning them for Don Lemon.
  • A federal judge's ruling blocking the reversal of temporary protected status for Haitians is labeled as judicial activism, overstepping presidential authority on immigration.
  • Billie Eilish's Grammy speech declaring 'no one is illegal on stolen land' is met with a statement from the Tongva tribe, ancestral owners of her mansion's land, who noted she had not contacted them directly.
  • Musician Jack Antinoff was unable to articulate the meaning behind his 'ice out' pin, illustrating a perceived superficiality in celebrity activism.

Insights

1Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping: Critical Evidence and Deteriorating Outlook

The investigation into Nancy Guthrie's kidnapping uncovered significant evidence, including blood inside her Arizona home and leading to the driveway, suggesting forced entry and injury. Her DNA was confirmed at the scene, but no other profiles were found initially. Crucially, her pacemaker stopped syncing with her Apple Watch around 2 AM, providing a precise timeline. The Pima County Sheriff expressed increasing urgency, warning that Nancy's life is at risk without specific medication within 24 hours. Extensive search efforts using ground teams, drones, and aircraft in the immediate area yielded no results, indicating she was likely taken from the vicinity.

Law enforcement sources reported blood inside Nancy Guthrie's home and a trail leading to the driveway, with signs of forced entry. DNA results confirmed the blood belonged to Nancy. Her pacemaker stopped syncing with her Apple Watch around 2 AM. Sheriff Chris Nanos issued a public plea, stating Nancy's medication is vital and could be fatal if not received within 24 hours. Search and rescue teams, including drones and helicopters with forward-looking infrared, found no trace of her in the surrounding area.

2Kidnapping Investigation: Focus on Insiders, Technology, and Potential Motives

The multi-agency investigation, involving local police, FBI, and Border Patrol, is leveraging advanced technology like cell tower triangulation, surveillance cameras, and license plate readers. Investigators are meticulously examining Nancy's 'victimology,' including her low-risk lifestyle and connections, and interviewing all individuals who had access to her home. The removal of a doorbell camera at her residence suggests a planned abduction. Given the proximity to the Mexican border, the possibility of a ransom-driven kidnapping, or even revenge related to her daughter Savannah Guthrie's high-profile career, is being considered, despite the sheriff's public denial of a ransom demand.

FBI is utilizing cell phone tower data to identify phones in the area around 2 AM. Surveillance cameras, including a doorbell camera, were either non-operational or removed. Victimology involves interviewing family, friends, and service personnel (plumbers, maids, delivery people) who had access to the home. The location is 65 miles from the Mexican border, where kidnappings are more common. The sheriff publicly denied a ransom demand, but this could be a strategic misdirection.

3Don Lemon's Indictment: First Amendment Misapplied in Church Protest

Don Lemon's indictment for his involvement in a church protest is framed as a clear violation of the FACE Act, not a protected journalistic act. The hosts and guests argue that the First Amendment does not grant journalists immunity from laws applicable to all citizens, especially when actively participating in disruption and ignoring explicit requests to leave private property. They highlight the hypocrisy of media figures and politicians who selectively apply First Amendment defenses based on political alignment, contrasting Lemon's case with the treatment of journalists involved in the January 6 Capitol events.

Don Lemon continued to interview people and make comments like 'trauma's part of it' after being explicitly told to leave the church by the pastor. 'The View' host Ana Navarro showed inconsistent views on grand juries, validating them for Trump's indictment but dismissing them for Lemon's. Julian Castro selectively quoted the First Amendment, omitting religious protections. The FACE Act protects religious services from disruption, and the federal government intervened because local authorities did not pursue trespassing charges.

4Judicial Overreach: Judge Blocks Trump's Haitian TPS Reversal

A federal judge blocked the Trump administration's attempt to reverse temporary protected status (TPS) for Haitians, citing 'hostility to non-white immigrants' and arguing against the immediate termination based on economic and social impacts. This ruling is criticized as judicial activism, as the president legally holds the authority to grant and revoke TPS based on their judgment of public interest, without needing to justify it based on the judge's preferred criteria. The decision is seen as part of a pattern where judges treat executive actions as a 'one-way ratchet,' allowing progressive policies but blocking conservative reversals.

Judge Angela Anna Reyes's ruling blocked the Trump administration from ending TPS for Haitians. Her opinion cited 'hostility to non-white immigrants' and focused on the economic and healthcare impacts of termination, which are not explicitly legal criteria for TPS decisions. This judge previously reversed a Trump policy on transgender military service, also citing 'animus.' The Supreme Court has historically treated such presidential decisions on immigration as non-justiciable, meaning judges do not second-guess the president's judgment.

5Celebrity Activism: Billie Eilish's 'Stolen Land' Comment Met with Tribal Response

Billie Eilish's Grammy speech, where she declared 'no one is illegal on stolen land' and used an expletive against ICE, drew criticism for its superficiality and hypocrisy. The Tongva tribe, recognized as the indigenous people of the land where Eilish's multi-million dollar mansion is located, issued a statement appreciating her comments but pointedly noting that she had not contacted them directly regarding her property. This incident, along with musician Jack Antinoff's inability to explain his 'ice out' pin, highlights a perceived trend of celebrity activism that lacks genuine engagement or understanding of complex issues, often reducing profound concepts like national sovereignty to simplistic slogans.

Billie Eilish stated, 'No one is illegal on stolen land' and 'f ICE' at the Grammys. The Tongva tribe, indigenous to the Los Angeles basin, issued a statement acknowledging Eilish's comments but noting she had not reached out to them regarding her mansion on their ancestral land. Jack Antinoff, also wearing an 'ice out' pin, was unable to articulate its meaning when questioned by a reporter.

Bottom Line

The Pima County Sheriff's perceived 'inconsistent messaging' regarding the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping might be a deliberate investigative tactic to either solicit a ransom demand or mislead the perpetrators, rather than genuine confusion.

So What?

Such strategic communication from law enforcement can be crucial in high-stakes cases, aiming to control information flow to influence the actions of criminals or protect the victim, even if it appears contradictory to the public.

Impact

Analyzing public statements from law enforcement in real-time for subtle shifts or inconsistencies could offer insights into their strategic objectives in ongoing investigations.

The high-profile status of Savannah Guthrie, Nancy's daughter, could paradoxically act as a deterrent for kidnappers due to the intense media scrutiny and massive law enforcement resources it mobilizes, rather than solely an attraction for a higher ransom.

So What?

While fame often implies wealth and potential for ransom, the 'heat' generated by a celebrity connection can make a crime significantly riskier and harder to execute or escape from, potentially complicating a kidnapper's calculus.

Impact

This suggests that in certain high-profile cases, publicizing the victim's connections might serve a dual purpose: soliciting public help and increasing pressure on perpetrators.

The First Amendment is often selectively invoked as a 'magic invisibility cloak' by some journalists and activists, implying immunity from general laws, a claim consistently rejected by legal precedent and enforcement agencies (e.g., DOJ's stance on Jan 6 journalists).

So What?

This selective interpretation undermines the principle of equal application of law and creates a double standard, where certain groups or causes are perceived to be above legal accountability under the guise of 'journalism' or 'protest.'

Impact

Educating the public and media on the precise scope and limitations of First Amendment protections, particularly regarding private property and active participation in criminal acts, is essential to foster a more consistent legal understanding.

Key Concepts

Victimology

The study of a victim's characteristics and circumstances to understand crime patterns and motives. Applied in the Guthrie case to analyze her low-risk profile, physical condition, and social connections to identify potential perpetrators.

One-Way Ratchet Effect

The observation that executive actions, once taken, are often difficult to reverse, especially when judges interpret them as creating irreversible facts on the ground. Discussed in the context of judicial rulings that prevent a new administration from reversing previous executive orders on immigration.

Lessons

  • If you have any information, no matter how seemingly irrelevant, regarding the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping, immediately call 911 to assist law enforcement.
  • Homeowners should invest in robust security systems, including doorbell cameras with reliable cloud backup, and ensure they are operational and contracts are current, as physical removal of devices can hinder investigations.
  • When evaluating legal cases involving public figures and free speech, critically examine the specific legal statutes (e.g., FACE Act) and precedents, rather than relying on broad, politically motivated interpretations of the First Amendment.

Notable Moments

Sheriff Nanos issues a direct, urgent plea to Nancy Guthrie's captors, emphasizing her critical need for medication and stating, 'no questions asked' if she is released.

This moment underscores the dire medical situation and the authorities' primary concern for Nancy's life, highlighting the human stakes of the kidnapping.

Ana Navarro of 'The View' offers starkly contradictory opinions on grand jury indictments, praising them as impartial for Donald Trump but dismissing them as politically motivated for Don Lemon.

This illustrates a perceived double standard and political bias within media commentary, undermining the credibility of legal analysis and the impartiality of the justice system.

Billie Eilish declares 'no one is illegal on stolen land' at the Grammys, followed by the Tongva tribe issuing a statement acknowledging her comments but noting she hasn't contacted them about her mansion on their ancestral land.

Musician Jack Antinoff, wearing an 'ice out' pin, struggles to articulate its meaning when questioned by a reporter, responding with vague statements about 'everything that's going on.'

This moment exemplifies a perceived trend of celebrities adopting political symbols without a clear understanding of their implications, suggesting a superficial engagement with social issues.

Quotes

"

"If she's alive right now, her meds are vital. I can't stress that enough. The family tells us if she doesn't have those meds, it can become fatal."

Sheriff Chris Nanos
"

"We believe in prayer. We believe in voices raised in unison, in love, in hope. We believe in goodness. We believe in humanity. Above all, we believe in him. We need you. Bring her home."

Savannah Guthrie (via Instagram post)
"

"These are not people with a political agenda. These are regular New Yorkers. Donald Trump finally won a popular vote yesterday. The grand jury voted to indict him."

Ana Navarro
"

"The First Amendment is not this special badge you get to hold up as a member of the press that makes you immune from laws that are applicable to everyone else in the United States. That's just not how it works."

Rich Lowry
"

"The notion that Don Lemon is presumptively the victim here, I think is absurd."

Charlie Cook
"

"You don't have a magic invisibility cloak just because you declare yourself a journalist while you are participating in a crime."

Megyn Kelly
"

"Her answer turned 352,959 lawful immigrants into unlawful ones overnight. She complains of strains to our economy. Her answer, turn employed lawful immigrants who contribute billions in taxes into the legally unemployable. She complains of strains to our healthcare system. Her answer, turn the insured into the uninsured. This approach is many things. In the public interest is not one of them."

Judge Angela Anna Reyes (quoted)
"

"I mean, this is terrible... it's just for every reason you could imagine, I would think, but um yeah, I'm a bit speechless trying to even talk about it."

Jack Antinoff

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

Nancy Guthrie Mystery: Kidnapped to Mexico? The Truth About Eerie Google Searches
Drop Dead Serious with Ashleigh BanfieldFeb 19, 2026

Nancy Guthrie Mystery: Kidnapped to Mexico? The Truth About Eerie Google Searches

"Federal authorities are now engaging with Mexican officials in the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping case, contradicting earlier statements from the local sheriff, while new investigative leads emerge from a gun holster purchase and Google search data is clarified."

Law EnforcementFBIPima County Sheriff+2
rump’s DOJ arrests journalists Don Lemon, Georgia Fort
Roland Martin UnfilteredJan 31, 2026

rump’s DOJ arrests journalists Don Lemon, Georgia Fort

"Federal agents arrested prominent journalists Don Lemon and Georgia Fort for covering a church protest, sparking widespread condemnation and raising critical questions about First Amendment rights and the weaponization of the Justice Department."

First AmendmentJournalist ArrestsDepartment of Justice+2
Anti-ICE Agitators and Don Lemon Disrupt MN Church Service, with Michael Knowles and Matt Walsh
The Megyn Kelly ShowJan 19, 2026

Anti-ICE Agitators and Don Lemon Disrupt MN Church Service, with Michael Knowles and Matt Walsh

"Megyn Kelly and guests Michael Knowles and Matt Walsh vehemently condemn anti-ICE activists and Don Lemon for disrupting a Minneapolis church service, framing it as an act of terrorism and a symptom of broader societal and historical indoctrination."

Church disruptionDon LemonSlavery history
SAVANNAH GUTHRIE'S MOM MISSING: DAY 66
Crime Stories with Nancy GraceApr 7, 2026

SAVANNAH GUTHRIE'S MOM MISSING: DAY 66

"On day 66 of Nancy Guthrie's disappearance, investigators grapple with two distinct sets of Bitcoin ransom notes, digital tracing challenges, and potential physical evidence like shoe coverings, as new, dubious claims emerge from a 'hyena' seeking payment for information."

KidnappingRansom DemandsBitcoin+2