6 True Creepy High School Stalker Stories

The narrator was initially unnerved by Andrew, a special needs student who constantly watched and followed her. This 'stalking' was later revealed to be Andrew's attempt to protect her from the school janitor. The janitor, a former military private, sought revenge on the narrator's father, a military police officer who had arrested him years prior for assaulting a female officer.

Andrew was observed watching the narrator everywhere, even following her home. He later intervened violently, attacking the janitor who was lurking in a hedge. The janitor's motive was revealed to be a vendetta against the narrator's father, who had ensured his dishonorable discharge from the military.

A young, attractive teacher faced a relentless and escalating obsession from a senior student named 'Billy.' Despite the teacher's strict boundaries and attempts to avoid being alone with her, Billy's behavior progressed from lingering after class and asking unnecessary questions to leaving typed love letters, then threats, and finally, crotchless panties with her initial in his desk. The situation culminated in a public outburst at prom where Billy declared her love for the teacher and then charged him with a knife.

The teacher implemented an open-door policy and had a colleague present after class. Billy left typed notes on his car, and later, a pair of crotchless panties with her initial in his locked desk. At prom, she publicly rejected her boyfriend and confessed her love for the teacher before attempting to attack him with a cake knife.

A group of high school friends suspected their straight-laced friend, Samantha, had a 'sugar daddy' providing her with gifts. Their investigation led them to believe it was their science teacher, Mr. Kurswell, who exhibited suspicious behavior. However, they discovered Samantha was a kleptomaniac shoplifting the 'gifts' and that Mr. Kurswell was secretly in a gay relationship, which he and his wife had concealed for years due to societal pressures.

Samantha displayed new shoes, clothes, and jewelry, claiming they were from an older 'Mr. X.' Friends observed Mr. Kurswell making secretive phone calls and quickly closing his laptop. Following Samantha to another town's mall, the narrator witnessed her shoplifting. Later, the group found Mr. Kurswell in the same mall, holding hands with another man, who then explained his concealed life.

An alternative theater group staged a horror play and decided on a late-night rehearsal. The rest of the cast orchestrated an elaborate prank, making the narrator and her boyfriend believe a serial killer (the janitor) was picking off their friends. In a state of terror, the boyfriend brutally assaulted the janitor with a metal pipe, crippling him, only to discover it was all a joke. This event ruined multiple lives, leading to legal charges, expulsions, and lasting trauma.

Actors disappeared, screams were heard, and fake blood was used to convince the narrator and her boyfriend of a real threat. The boyfriend, Clyde, attacked the janitor, Mr. Williams, with a metal bar, causing severe, permanent injuries to his legs. The other cast members then emerged, yelling 'Surprise!'

A high school YouTuber, proud of his 'few thousand' subscribers, attracted the unwanted attention of a younger, socially awkward film student named Rick. Rick's obsession escalated from persistent video ideas and notes to secretly filming the YouTuber around school. After a physical confrontation and Rick's departure, the stalking resumed years later when Rick tracked the YouTuber to his college house and filmed him through his living room window, culminating in leaving a steaming turd on his driveway.

Rick left notes with video ideas and posted videos titled 'Famous YouTuber works hard for his fans,' containing clips of the narrator filmed secretly. Years later, Rick uploaded a series of videos showing the narrator inside his college house through a window, ending with a shot of a turd on the driveway.