Quick Read

Widespread public disapproval of ICE's actions, particularly the shooting of Renee Good, signals significant political trouble for the Trump administration, even among its traditional supporters.
Over 75% of registered voters saw the Renee Good shooting video; a majority (53-28) found ICE's force unjustified.
Disapproval of ICE's actions extends across the political spectrum, including 15% of Republicans.
The host argues this widespread negative reaction is a 'five alarm fire' for the Trump administration, not a mere distraction.

Summary

Recent polls indicate that over 75% of registered voters saw the video of ICE shooting Renee Good in Minneapolis, with a majority (53-28 margin) disapproving of the force used. This disapproval spans across political lines, including a notable percentage of Republicans. The host argues this widespread public awareness and negative reaction is detrimental to the Trump administration, especially as it continues to praise ICE agents. He criticizes the administration's approach to ICE, describing it as a 'fascist regime' empowering an 'untrained' agency and dismissing the idea that these events are mere distractions, instead calling them a 'five alarm fire' that exposes the administration's 'depravity'. The host also highlights Trump's history of unfulfilled promises to regular Americans, suggesting that people are 'waking up' to his 'scam artist' tactics.
This episode highlights how specific, highly visible events, like the ICE shooting video, can cut through typical political media consumption and shift public opinion across partisan divides. It suggests that even issues the administration might use as a 'distraction' can backfire if they are broadly unpopular, potentially impacting political support and future election outcomes.

Takeaways

  • A YouGov poll shows 75% of registered voters saw the video of ICE shooting Renee Good, with a Quinnipiac poll showing 82%.
  • 53% of Americans disapprove of the force used by the ICE agent, including 88% of Democrats, 58% of independents, and 15% of Republicans.
  • The host asserts that political news rarely breaks through to such a broad audience, making this widespread disapproval particularly damaging for the Trump administration.
  • The host characterizes ICE agents as 'untrained' and 'high school dropout goons' given 'cart blanche' by a 'fascist regime'.
  • The administration's support for ICE and its actions is framed as an 'aggressively unpopular' distraction that exposes its 'cruel, evil' nature.
  • Trump's history of unfulfilled promises (e.g., middle-class tax cuts, healthcare, infrastructure) is cited as evidence of his 'scam artist' approach.
  • Minnesota Lieutenant Governor Peggy Flanigan notes that disapproval of ICE's conduct, including detaining US citizens, is crossing political lines, even among Republicans and Trump voters.

Insights

1Widespread Public Awareness of ICE Incident

Two polls, YouGov and Quinnipiac, revealed that a significant majority of registered voters witnessed or heard about the video of ICE shooting Renee Good in Minneapolis. YouGov reported 75% saw the video and 19% heard about it, while Quinnipiac showed 82% had seen the footage.

YouGov poll: 75% saw the video, 19% heard about it. Quinnipiac poll: 82% saw the footage.

2Broad Disapproval of ICE's Use of Force

The majority of Americans who saw the video disapprove of the force used by the ICE agent. A 53-28 margin of Americans deemed the force unjustified. This disapproval was strong across party lines, including 88% of Democrats, 58% of independents, and 15% of Republicans.

53-28 margin of Americans say force was not justified. 88% of Democrats, 58% of independents, 15% of Republicans.

3Political Impact of Unpopular Distractions

The host argues that the Trump administration's strategy of using controversial ICE actions as a distraction from other issues (like the Epstein files) is failing because the 'distraction' itself is 'aggressively unpopular'. This makes it a counterproductive political move.

Host's analysis: 'it's not a great distraction when the distraction is also aggressively unpopular.'

4Cross-Partisan Concern Over ICE Conduct

Minnesota Lieutenant Governor Peggy Flanigan confirms that concern over ICE's actions, including detaining US citizens and legal observers, is extending beyond traditional Democratic voters. She cites examples of right-wing individuals and Republicans expressing strong disapproval, indicating a broader societal concern.

Peggy Flanigan: 'I have some family members, right, who are Republicans who are like, listen, this is crossing a line.' Also, a young man who was 'pretty right-wing' said, 'this isn't it.'

Lessons

  • Recognize that highly visible events, especially those captured on video, can significantly influence public opinion across political divides.
  • Understand that political strategies relying on 'distractions' can backfire if the distracting issue itself generates widespread public disapproval.
  • Be aware that public sentiment regarding law enforcement actions, particularly those perceived as excessive, can shift even traditional political allegiances.

Notable Moments

The host emphasizes the rarity of political news breaking through to over 80% of registered voters, highlighting the exceptional nature and political significance of the ICE video's reach.

This underscores the unique impact of the Renee Good video, suggesting it's not just another news cycle but a moment of broad public engagement that could have lasting political consequences.

The host's strong condemnation of ICE agents, describing them as 'high school dropout goons' and 'untrained' individuals 'cosplaying as soldiers' who 'shoot innocent Americans in the face'.

This highly charged language reflects the host's extreme disapproval and frames the issue as a systemic problem of unqualified personnel empowered by a problematic administration, rather than isolated incidents.

Quotes

"

"For over 80% of registered voters to have seen that video is a staggering statistic and again one that bodess especially poorly for this administration."

Brian Tyler Cohen
"

"Generally, if you're trying to distract somebody from something bad, it helps if the thing that you're distracting them with is not also bad."

Brian Tyler Cohen
"

"This is a fascist regime giving cart blanch to a rogue agency whose goal is to terrorize people across the United States with a bunch of high school dropout goons who took a break from playing Call of Duty to cosplay as soldiers and shoot innocent Americans in the face."

Brian Tyler Cohen
"

"I'm I'm pretty right-wing, but this this isn't it. Like, this isn't how you do it."

Young man quoted by Brian Tyler Cohen
"

"I have some family members, right, who are Republicans who are like, listen, this is crossing a line."

Peggy Flanigan

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes