The Rubin Report Podcast
The Rubin Report Podcast
March 27, 2026

Jimmy Kimmel’s Audience Shocked at How Cruel He Actually Is

Quick Read

The Rubin Report panel dissects the perceived elitism and hypocrisy of mainstream media and progressive figures, from Jimmy Kimmel's dismissal of a plumber-turned-senator to a streamer's tone-deaf trip to Cuba, highlighting a growing disconnect with working-class Americans and basic civics.
Jimmy Kimmel's joke about a plumber-turned-senator exemplifies elite contempt for labor, fueling resentment.
Progressive figures' 'humanitarian' trips to Cuba are framed as performative 'safaris amongst poor people,' ignoring real suffering.
A significant portion of college students lack basic civics knowledge, raising concerns about educational standards and societal understanding.

Summary

Dave Rubin, BA, and Nate Friedman discuss the cultural and political divide, starting with Jimmy Kimmel's 'joke' about newly confirmed DHS head Mark Wayne Mullen, a former plumber and MMA fighter. The panel frames Kimmel's comments as emblematic of the Democratic Party's elitist contempt for working-class professions, contrasting it with the praise given to figures like AOC for similar backgrounds. They criticize the partisan shift in late-night comedy, arguing it has become agenda-driven and unfunny. The conversation extends to a controversial trip to Cuba by streamer Hassan Piker and Code Pink, which the panel derides as a 'safari amongst poor people' that ignores the realities of communist oppression. Nate Friedman shares his experiences as a 'boots on the ground' journalist, including confronting pro-Khomeini vigil attendees in New York City, highlighting security concerns and the politicization of public spaces. The episode concludes with a segment on college students' alarming lack of basic civics knowledge, prompting a debate on the state of education and the perceived 'dumbness' of youth versus the anger of elites.
This episode exposes the deep cultural chasm between mainstream liberal elites and a significant portion of the American populace, particularly the working class and conservatives. It highlights how perceived media bias, political hypocrisy, and a disdain for practical experience contribute to societal polarization. Understanding these dynamics is critical for anyone seeking to bridge divides or comprehend the motivations behind contemporary political alignments, especially concerning issues like immigration, education, and the role of traditional media.

Takeaways

  • Mainstream media and late-night comedy are criticized for elitism and partisan agendas, alienating broad audiences.
  • The Democratic Party is accused of hypocrisy, praising working-class backgrounds for their own politicians while mocking them for opponents.
  • Streamers and activist groups visiting Cuba are seen as performative, ignoring the harsh realities of communism.
  • On-the-ground journalism reveals the politicization of public spaces and the security risks faced by those challenging narratives.
  • There's a concerning lack of basic civics knowledge among college students, reflecting broader educational failures.
  • The hosts argue that social media, despite its flaws, can foster skepticism and lead to more independent information gathering among young people.

Insights

1Elite Contempt for Working-Class Professions

Jimmy Kimmel's 'joke' mocking newly confirmed DHS head Mark Wayne Mullen for his background as a plumber and MMA fighter is presented as a prime example of the Democratic Party's pervasive elitism and contempt for people who work with their hands. This attitude is seen as a key reason why the party has lost its traditional working-class base.

Kimmel's segment () and BA's commentary: 'This kind of elitism, the contempt for labor for people who work with their hands for a living is utterly endemic to the Democratic party at every single level.'

2Hypocrisy in Valuing Professional Backgrounds

The panel highlights the hypocrisy of progressive elites who celebrate figures like AOC for her past as a bartender as a sign of being 'of the people,' but then dismiss a Republican like Mark Wayne Mullen for his background as a plumber, framing it as a disqualifier for public office. This double standard underscores a partisan bias in how 'working-class' credentials are perceived.

BA's comparison of AOC's bartender background to Mullen's plumbing experience () and the subsequent discussion about elite degrees vs. practical experience.

3Late-Night Comedy's Decline into Partisan Agenda

Vince Vaughn's observation that talk shows became 'agenda based' and 'stopped being funny' is echoed by the hosts. They argue that post-2016, shows like Colbert and Fallon shifted from entertainment to partisan political commentary, alienating audiences and contributing to cultural division.

Vince Vaughn's clip () and Nate Friedman's comment: 'Trump broke their brains. This was not the way it was before 2016.'

4Social Media Fosters Skepticism in News Consumption

BA posits that young people getting news from social media might not be 'the end of the world' because the informal nature of platforms like TikTok or independent creators encourages a 'built-in skepticism.' Users are more likely to question and verify information, unlike the passive consumption of highly produced, corporate media.

BA's theory on social media and skepticism () and Nate Friedman's agreement, citing 'rabbit holes' and 'boots on the ground journalism' with 'receipts.'

5The 'Safari Amongst Poor People' in Cuba

The trip to Cuba by streamer Hassan Piker and Code Pink is heavily criticized as a performative 'humanitarian mission' that devolved into 'mockery.' The hosts point out the stark contrast between the activists' privileged lifestyle (e.g., $1,500 Cartier glasses) and the extreme poverty of Cubans, who would 'trade places with the poorest American.' The activists' portrayal of Cuban resilience is seen as tone-deaf, ignoring that people 'party in the streets' because 'they have nothing else to do.'

Hassan Piker's stream clip (), BA's commentary on the 'safari amongst poor people' (), and the cost of Piker's glasses vs. average Cuban salary ().

6Politicization of Public Spaces and Security Concerns

Nate Friedman's video from a pro-Khomeini vigil in Washington Square Park illustrates the dangers faced by independent journalists and the lack of law and order. He describes being shoved and needing police escort, highlighting how public spaces can become hostile and controlled by specific ideological groups, often with security threats.

Nate Friedman's video () and his explanation of needing security and the police escorting him out of a public park.

7Alarming Lack of Civics Knowledge Among College Students

A viral video showing college students failing basic civics questions (e.g., who won the Civil War, year of 9/11, number of senators) underscores a severe problem in the education system. This ignorance is linked to the politicization of teaching, where even fifth-grade teachers bring political agendas into the classroom.

The college student civics quiz video () and Nate Friedman's observation that 'education needs a revamp' and 'most popular job of paid protesters... are teachers.'

Bottom Line

The informal nature of social media news consumption might inadvertently cultivate greater skepticism and critical thinking among young people compared to traditional, highly produced media.

So What?

This challenges the conventional wisdom that social media is solely a source of misinformation, suggesting it could also be a catalyst for independent verification and 'boots on the ground' information gathering.

Impact

Creators and platforms can lean into this inherent skepticism by providing tools and formats that encourage deeper investigation and fact-checking, rather than just curated content.

The 'white treatment' for Jews by the progressive left, where Jewish identity is dismissed or attacked if aligned with conservative views, signifies a shift in how identity politics are applied.

So What?

This suggests that identity is increasingly conditional on political alignment, and groups previously considered minorities can be 'othered' if they don't conform to progressive narratives.

Impact

This creates an opportunity for new coalitions and narratives that transcend traditional identity politics, uniting individuals based on shared values rather than prescribed group affiliations.

Lessons

  • Question credentialism: Evaluate individuals based on their practical experience and demonstrated competence rather than solely on academic degrees or elite affiliations.
  • Cultivate media skepticism: Approach late-night comedy and mainstream news with a critical eye, recognizing potential partisan agendas and elitist biases.
  • Support independent journalism: Seek out and support 'boots on the ground' journalists who provide unvarnished perspectives and 'show receipts,' especially from contested public spaces.
  • Advocate for civics education: Push for a depoliticized and robust civics curriculum in schools to ensure future generations understand fundamental historical and governmental facts.

Notable Moments

Jimmy Kimmel's 'joke' about Mark Wayne Mullen's plumber background.

It sparked the entire discussion on elite contempt for labor and media bias, serving as a central example of the panel's critique.

Hassan Piker's internet cutting out mid-sentence while praising Cuba's internet, during his live stream from the country.

This moment provided ironic, real-time evidence of Cuba's infrastructure failures, directly contradicting Piker's positive portrayal and highlighting the disconnect of his 'safari' experience.

The report of activists throwing food at Cuban children to make them dance for social media videos.

This incident is presented as a particularly egregious example of the 'safari amongst poor people' mentality, dehumanizing Cubans for content and illustrating extreme privilege.

Nate Friedman's confrontation at a pro-Khomeini vigil in Washington Square Park, leading to him being shoved and needing police escort.

It vividly demonstrates the challenges and dangers of independent reporting in highly politicized public spaces and raises questions about free speech and public safety.

Quotes

"

"This kind of elitism, the contempt for labor for people who work with their hands for a living is utterly endemic to the Democratic party at every single level. And it explains 90% of their policy agenda items, especially immigration."

BA
"

"They were going to evangelical people to what they thought. You know what I mean? And so people just rejected it because it didn't feel authentic. It felt like they had an agenda. It stopped being funny and it started feeling like I was in a class I didn't want to take."

Vince Vaughn
"

"They literally went on safari amongst poor people. Like that is just so delicious because that is the progressive move. That is the left today which is you know they're rich. They're unbelievably entitled and privileged. They would never dream of subjecting themselves to what they are enforcing on others with the policy that they prefer."

BA
"

"We have the privilege of being hated like our fellow Americans by the people who deserve everybody's condemnation and we should wear that with pride."

BA
"

"I am tot I love these kids so much. I just freaking love them. They're so beautiful and so high on life. They're not on Twitter. They're not on dating apps. They are out there living life to the fullest, getting drunk and getting laid. And I adore them. And the dumber they are, the more I love them."

BA

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes