Bulwark Takes
Bulwark Takes
January 7, 2026

Rioters Return to the Scene and Face Angry Counter-Protesters

Quick Read

A Bulwark reporter covers the stark contrast between pro-January 6th protesters, who claim the event was a 'fedsurrection' and a setup, and impassioned counter-protesters who view January 6th as a direct attack on American democracy.
Pro-January 6th attendees reiterated claims of a 'fedsurrection,' asserting they were set up by the government and the FBI.
Counter-protesters expressed outrage over the 'desecration' of the Capitol and the perceived lack of accountability for those involved.
Both sides voiced strong desires for 'accountability,' but directed at completely opposing targets and for fundamentally different reasons.

Summary

The Bulwark sent reporter Jared Holt to cover a gathering of approximately 100 pro-January 6th protesters and 30-50 counter-protesters near the Capitol on the five-year anniversary of the January 6th events. Pro-January 6th attendees, some of whom were previously arrested or pardoned, framed the day as a 'fedsurrection' and a government setup, expressing a desire for accountability from those they believe orchestrated it. They celebrated figures like Ashli Babbitt and claimed Trump promised 'everything will be okay' to 'J6 prisoners.' In stark contrast, counter-protesters, including long-time Capitol Hill residents, expressed horror, violation, and disillusionment, emphasizing the attack on democracy, the desecration of the Capitol, and the perceived lack of accountability for those involved, particularly after presidential pardons.
This report highlights the deeply polarized narratives surrounding the January 6th events, demonstrating how different groups interpret the same historical moment. It reveals the ongoing commitment of some to a 'fedsurrection' narrative and the profound emotional impact and fear experienced by those who view it as a violent assault on democratic institutions. The persistence of these clashing perspectives underscores the challenges in achieving national consensus and accountability for politically charged events.

Takeaways

  • Approximately 100 pro-January 6th protesters gathered, some of whom were previously arrested and pardoned.
  • 30-50 counter-protesters were present, described as 'punchier' than the pro-January 6th group.
  • Pro-January 6th attendees claimed the event was a 'fedsurrection,' an 'inside job,' and a setup by the FBI and Nancy Pelosi.
  • Many pro-January 6th individuals expressed solidarity with 'J6 prisoners' and belief in Trump's support.
  • Counter-protesters described January 6th as 'terrifying,' a 'violation of peaceful transfer of power,' and an 'attack on our police officers.'
  • Counter-protesters criticized the pardons of those involved and the perceived lack of justice and accountability for the events.

Insights

1Pro-January 6th Narrative: 'Fedsurrection' and Government Setup

Attendees who supported the January 6th actions consistently claimed the event was not an insurrection but a 'fedsurrection' or an 'inside job.' They alleged that the FBI and other government entities, including Nancy Pelosi, set them up, allowing them to enter the Capitol only to then prosecute them unfairly. Many expressed solidarity with those imprisoned, referring to them as 'J6ers' in 'gulags,' and believed they were fighting for Donald Trump and 'Ashli Babbitt.'

One attendee stated, 'We were set up... by the FBI... It was supposed to be a great day, but it was a horrible day.' Another claimed, 'It was an inside job... I think the government attacked the people.' A third mentioned, 'There were hundreds of undercover FBI agents dressed as Trump supporters there.' (, , )

2Counter-Protester Narrative: Attack on Democracy and Lack of Accountability

Counter-protesters expressed deep anger and heartbreak, viewing January 6th as a direct assault on American democracy and a terrifying personal experience. They condemned the actions of the pro-January 6th group as those of 'insurrectionists' and 'traitors,' particularly after presidential pardons. Many felt a profound sense of violation and disillusionment due to the perceived lack of justice and accountability for the events and those who incited them.

A Capitol Hill resident since '94 called January 6th 'the most terrifying time that I've ever spent in my own neighborhood,' citing the smashing of windows and attacks on police. Another stated, 'I saw a violation of a peaceful transfer of power that I had taken for granted.' Several expressed frustration that 'no justice got served, no justice got done.' (, , )

3Trump's Continued Influence and Support Among Pro-January 6th Group

Donald Trump remains a central figure for the pro-January 6th attendees, who believe he supports their cause and those imprisoned. One individual recounted a personal interaction where Trump signed a flag and told them to 'Tell them everything will be okay' to 'prisoners' in the 'DC gulag,' reinforcing their belief in his backing.

An attendee recounted, 'I stood in front of him Labor Day of 2023... And I asked him to sign this flag, and he did. And I said, 'What's one thing that you want to say to our prisoners when I go back to the DC gulag?' And he said to me, 'Tell them everything will be okay.'' ()

Notable Moments

A pro-January 6th protester, who claimed to have served one of the longest terms in the 'DC gulag,' detailed his experience and perspective on the death of Rosanne Boyland, attributing it to 'Officer Lila Morris' and alleging manipulation by 'evil politicians.'

This moment provides a specific, first-hand account from an individual who experienced imprisonment related to January 6th, offering a detailed, albeit biased, perspective on the events and their aftermath, including accusations against law enforcement and politicians.

A counter-protester invoked Vice President Pence's actions on January 6th, 2021, and compared the effort to rewrite the history of January 6th to Hitler's elevation of the Beer Hall Putsch to a national holiday.

This comparison highlights the deep concern among counter-protesters about the historical revisionism surrounding January 6th and their determination to prevent it from being normalized or celebrated, framing it as a critical moment for democratic integrity.

Quotes

"

"We were set up, you know. It was supposed to be an amazing day and we were set up by the FBI, you know. Other people pretended to be us and it was It was supposed to be a great day, but it was a horrible day."

Pro-January 6th protester
"

"I was in the gulags for many months. I'm one of those that was hunted down."

Pro-January 6th protester
"

"Our government set us up. They allowed us to walk in there and then they hunted us down like terrorists and prosecuted us in an unfair court system."

Pro-January 6th protester
"

"January 6th was the most terrifying time that I've ever spent in my own neighborhood. I had a daughter getting a Sweetgreen salad on Pennsylvania Avenue right near the Capitol. I had another kid across town, and I watched in utter horror as they smashed windows and attacked our police officers..."

Capitol Hill resident (counter-protester)
"

"I saw a violation of a peaceful transfer of power that I had taken for granted for a number of years and I saw a historical precedent that was set that if you look at other countries and democracies in the history of the world, um they usually are violated in the same way with demagogues..."

Counter-protester
"

"It's obscene that these people are here. It's obscene they got away with it and I had to do something."

Counter-protester
"

"Just honestly violated. Violated for one of the first times in my life. Like insane. Just cuz the fact that there was no repercussion whatsoever and there was just pardons. Pardons for every jackass. Like no justice got served, no justice got done..."

Counter-protester

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes