Go Deeper Than Netflix: Love Triangle, Manhunt, & Plastic Surgery | The Tragedy of Moriah Wilson

Moriah Wilson's brief romantic involvement with Colin Strickland, who was in an on-again, off-again relationship with Caitlyn Armstrong, created a volatile dynamic. Armstrong's discovery of their past affair and continued communication fueled an extreme rage, culminating in Wilson's murder. Colin's actions, such as hiding Mariah's number and lying about his plans, exacerbated the situation.

Colin and Mariah had a brief relationship in October 2021. Caitlyn learned of this romance in January 2022 and was 'physically shaking with anger,' telling a friend she wanted to kill Mariah. Colin hid Mariah's number under an alias and lied to Caitlyn about seeing Mariah on the night of the murder.

After being questioned and released due to a technical error, Caitlyn Armstrong immediately began an elaborate plan to evade capture. She sold her Jeep, flew to New York, then used her sister's passport to fly to Costa Rica, where she sought plastic surgery and adopted multiple aliases to create a new identity.

Armstrong sold her Jeep for $12,000 on May 13, 2022, one day after her initial questioning. She flew from Texas to New York, then used her sister Christy's passport to board a one-way flight to San Jose, Costa Rica, on May 18. In Costa Rica, she underwent lip fillers, rhinoplasty, and a brow lift, and used aliases like Allison Paige, Beth Martin, and Ari Martin.

Despite Armstrong's attempts to cover her tracks, investigators amassed compelling evidence. Surveillance footage placed her vehicle near the crime scene, and ballistic evidence linked the murder weapon to a gun Colin Strickland had purchased for her. Her flight and subsequent actions further solidified her guilt.

A 2012 black Jeep Grand Cherokee, matching Armstrong's vehicle, was captured on security camera near Wilson's friend's house shortly after Colin dropped Wilson off. Ballistic evidence linked the murder weapon to a 9mm handgun purchased by Colin for Caitlyn in January. Armstrong's flight from the country and subsequent plastic surgery were seen as strong indicators of guilt.

Even while in custody awaiting trial, Armstrong made another desperate attempt to escape during a doctor's appointment, demonstrating her persistent refusal to face justice. This attempt, combined with strong witness testimony and forensic evidence, led to a swift guilty verdict and a lengthy prison sentence.

On October 11, 2023, Armstrong attempted to escape custody during a doctor's appointment, seen on video trying to jump a fence and then running again. She was wearing thermal pants and had been working out intensely. Her best friend testified that Caitlyn had said, 'I would kill her' if Colin ended up with another woman. The jury reached a guilty verdict within two hours, sentencing her to 90 years in prison.