Quick Read

This episode reconstructs three harrowing true crime cases where victims' loved ones experienced chilling premonitions, revealing patterns of manipulation, betrayal, and the relentless pursuit of justice against perpetrators who often hide in plain sight.
Loved ones often sense danger before official confirmation.
Perpetrators frequently employ elaborate cover-ups and gaslighting.
Unwavering family advocacy is crucial in complex investigations.

Summary

“Bad Premonitions” explores three distinct murder investigations, each marked by early warnings and the profound impact on victims' families. The first case details the murder of Jesse Bardwell by her manipulative boyfriend, Jason Low, who isolated her, lied to police, and disposed of her body, eventually confessing to "criminal negligence" before being convicted. The second focuses on Michaela Mayavi, whose husband, Frank Buyers, murdered her amidst their divorce, faked her disappearance with a fabricated story and texts, and attempted to clean up the crime scene before her body was found in a culvert. The final segment covers the unsolved murder of aspiring music producer Kevin Harris, whose family and new investigators believe he was set up by someone he knew, possibly a "wannabe rapper" he had "dissed," highlighting the dangers of the music industry and the challenges of cold cases. Across all narratives, the episode emphasizes the deep intuition of loved ones and the tireless efforts of law enforcement and families to uncover the truth and seek accountability.
These cases underscore the critical importance of recognizing red flags in relationships, the devastating consequences of domestic violence and betrayal, and the persistent challenges faced by law enforcement in solving complex murders, especially when perpetrators actively mislead investigations. It highlights the enduring grief of families and their unwavering commitment to justice, often becoming advocates themselves.

Takeaways

  • Jesse Bardwell's controlling boyfriend, Jason Low, murdered her, hid her body, and fabricated stories before a plea deal secured a 50-year sentence.
  • Michaela Mayavi was murdered by her husband, Frank Buyers, who staged her disappearance and attempted to clean the crime scene, eventually pleading guilty to life without parole.
  • Aspiring music producer Kevin Harris's murder remains unsolved, with investigators suspecting a setup by an acquaintance in the competitive music industry.

Insights

1Jesse Bardwell's Isolation and Murder by Jason Low

Jesse Bardwell's move to Texas with Jason Low quickly led to her isolation, with Jason controlling her communication and fabricating stories about her whereabouts. Her father's premonition and subsequent investigation uncovered Jason's lies about her car and led to the discovery of Jesse's body, crudely disposed of after being kept in Jason's car for days.

Jason's lies about Jesse's car (sold weeks prior), cocaine in apartment, smell of decaying flesh and blood in his Audi, Jesse's body wrapped in materials from the house they housesat, Jason's admission of "criminal negligence" to a friend, and his continued texting/sexting other women.

2Michaela Mayavi's Homicide by Frank Buyers

Michaela Mayavi was murdered by her husband, Frank Buyers, amidst their impending divorce, after she told him she was "done." Frank concocted a false narrative of her leaving with another man, used her phone to send misleading texts, and attempted to clean the crime scene before her body was found in a culvert.

Frank's fabricated story of a "bald man in a white truck," his claim of an "open marriage" denied by family, empty shell casings and a recently fired gun in Michaela's home, Michaela's mother's premonition of a "tin horn," security camera images showing Michaela's last moments at Frank's house, Frank's purchase of cleaning supplies, Michaela's blood on Frank's boots, and Frank's manipulation of her phone.

3Kevin Harris's Unsolved Music Industry Murder

Aspiring music producer Kevin Harris, known as "Track Bully," was ambushed and murdered in his car, a case that remains unsolved despite new FBI involvement. Investigators believe he was an intended target, likely set up by someone he knew, possibly due to "dissing" peers or being blamed for something missing in the competitive hip-hop scene.

Kevin's clean reputation, ruling out gang-related mistaken identity (he rolled down his window), his increasing "cocky" social media presence and "dissing" of peers, his unease and questions about "bulletproof windows" before his death, a military recruiter letter suggesting he planned to leave town, and the identification of Desmond Carter as a key suspect who was supposed to meet Kevin that night and had "bad blood" with him.

Lessons

  • Pay attention to and trust your instincts or "bad feelings" about a loved one's safety, especially when communication patterns abruptly change or they become isolated.
  • Recognize red flags in relationships, such as controlling behavior, isolation from family/friends, and a partner's consistent dishonesty or infidelity.
  • If you suspect domestic abuse or manipulation, document everything, seek help from trusted individuals or authorities, and create a safety plan to leave the situation.
  • For families of victims, persistent advocacy and collaboration with law enforcement can be crucial in cold cases or complex investigations.

Quotes

"

"I had that nightmare and I felt it. She was not on this earth anymore."

Gary Bardwell
"

"He's about as cruel of a individual as I've dealt with, and I've been doing this a long time."

Prosecutor Wes Wyn
"

"I wanted to leave that night and go and arrest Frank, but I knew um it's better to move thoroughly than to act quick."

Lieutenant Dakota Black
"

"He thought he was smarter than everyone, but he was outsmarted, right? Yes. I think he was surprised."

Lieutenant Dakota Black
"

"My naive, loving son probably just could have been possibly sleeping with the enemy. And I had no idea."

Catherine Harris
"

"There's no difference between that and dissing someone in the streets."

Music Journalist Raman Duke

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes