Jail insider says Mackenzie Shirilla not remorseful, wore lots of makeup, had a business behind bars
YouTube · _GguCah7spE
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Mackenzie Shirilla, convicted of murder, was observed by a fellow inmate, Kat Crowder, to be consistently unremorseful during her time in prison.
- ❖Shirilla maintained a 'put-together' appearance daily, wearing a full face of makeup, styled hair, and altered clothes, seemingly treating prison like a social environment.
- ❖She operated a 'prison hustle' customizing shoes, making jewelry from art kits, and altering clothes for other inmates, with transactions facilitated through her mother's Cash App.
- ❖Crowder noted a significant discrepancy between Shirilla's 'girly' and 'happy-go-lucky' prison demeanor and the 'hard-edged, tough' persona she adopted in the Netflix documentary 'The Crash.'
- ❖Shirilla's first appeal was rejected, and a second appeal was dismissed for being filed one day late, leading her to petition the Ohio Supreme Court, citing ineffective counsel.
- ❖Kat Crowder believes the crash was a split-second, impulsive decision during an argument, not a premeditated act, and that Shirilla remembers what happened but lives in delusion.
- ❖In prison, inmates generally avoid asking about others' crimes, but high-profile cases like Shirilla's are widely known through inmate communication and legal databases.
Insights
1Mackenzie Shirilla's Unremorseful Prison Demeanor
Kat Crowder, a former inmate, observed Mackenzie Shirilla daily in prison and noted a complete lack of remorse. Shirilla consistently appeared 'happy-go-lucky,' laughing, smiling, and socializing, never shedding a tear despite her life sentences for murder.
Crowder states, 'I just never saw her shed a tear. She was always very like happy-go-lucky and good spirits, laughing, smiling… She just did not portray somebody who had on her mind that she was serving life sentences for murdering two people.'
2The 'Prison Hustle' and Family Involvement
Shirilla engaged in a 'side business' within prison, customizing shoes, distressing baseball caps, and making jewelry from art kits. Inmates would pay for these services by having their outside contacts Cash App Shirilla's mother, who would then confirm receipt, indicating family involvement in illicit prison activities.
Crowder details, 'She was customizing shoes for people and like distressing baseball caps… she was telling me how she made it. Oh, I'll go make it. You can send it to like send the money to this Cash App. And the Cash App was her mother's Cash App.'
3Contrasting Personas: Prison vs. Netflix Documentary
Shirilla's appearance and demeanor in the Netflix documentary 'The Crash' were drastically different from her behavior in prison. In prison, she was 'bright and girly,' with a 'valley girl' voice. In the documentary, she adopted a 'tough girl act,' appearing 'smug, very dark,' with a different voice, suggesting a calculated public image.
Crowder describes her reaction to the documentary: 'When I saw her I was like, who who is this? This is not anybody that I've ever seen. From the way that she looked to like her demeanor 100% different than the person I was in there with. It almost came off as if she was trying to portray like this tough girl act in the documentary.'
4Ongoing Legal Appeals and Blame on Counsel
Shirilla's first appeal was rejected, and her second appeal was dismissed because it was filed one day late. She is now appealing to the Ohio Supreme Court, arguing that her lawyer provided ineffective assistance by failing to file the appeal on time and adequately present her medical condition and text messages during the trial.
The host explains, 'Her first appeal with the court of appeals was rejected... She then filed a second appeal... and it was rejected because it was filed 1 day late... she's now appealed to the Ohio Supreme Court trying to get them to accept the appeal, saying... her lawyer's fault, obviously.'
Bottom Line
Mackenzie Shirilla's family allegedly enabled her illicit 'prison hustle' by managing her Cash App for inmate transactions, highlighting a potential pattern of enabling behavior that extended beyond her pre-incarceration life.
This suggests a deeper family dynamic that may have contributed to Shirilla's lack of accountability and detachment from reality, both before and during her imprisonment.
Further investigation into the extent of family involvement in inmate 'hustles' could reveal systemic vulnerabilities in prison oversight and financial regulations for incarcerated individuals.
Opportunities
Inmate-Crafted Customization Service (Illicit Model)
Leveraging incarcerated individuals' artistic skills (e.g., jewelry making, shoe customization, clothing alteration) to create unique, personalized items. The business model, as observed with Mackenzie Shirilla, involves outside contacts handling financial transactions (e.g., Cash App) for items sold within the prison system.
Notable Moments
Kat Crowder's personal journey to prison for a high-speed chase, and her subsequent accountability and transformation, provides a stark contrast to Shirilla's perceived lack of remorse.
This personal narrative establishes Crowder's credibility as an observer of prison behavior and frames her perspective on Shirilla as someone who has experienced and reflected on her own poor choices.
The revelation that women's prisons, contrary to popular belief, often protect inmates who committed child crimes more than other prisoners.
This challenges common assumptions about prison hierarchies and inmate justice, highlighting unexpected dynamics within the correctional system.
Quotes
"She just did not portray somebody who had on her mind that she was serving life sentences for murdering two people."
"It almost came off as if she was trying to portray like this tough girl act in the documentary. Very smug, very dark, almost like just very strange."
"I think that she 100% remembers what happened that night. I think that she'll continue pushing that until it clicks in her mind like, oh, I'm I'm not going to get out anytime soon."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
True-crime cases with recent developments | 48 Hours Full Episodes
"This episode reconstructs four complex true-crime cases, detailing the harrowing searches for missing persons, the challenges of prosecuting murders without bodies, and the enduring quest for justice in cold cases spanning decades."
5 Most Wicked Murder Cases Caught On Bodycam
"Bodycam footage provides an unfiltered, real-time look into five brutal murder investigations, exposing the immediate aftermath of horrific crimes and the initial interactions with suspects and witnesses."
Mamá me golpeaba, busqué a papá y él me trajo a la cárcel | Yahana #Penitencia 196 #México
"Yahana recounts her harrowing journey from a childhood marred by domestic violence and parental abandonment to drug addiction and eventual incarceration, directly caused by her father's actions."
Hell On Wheels: Mackenzie Shirilla's Double Murder Crash
"A seemingly accidental car crash that killed two young men in Strongsville, Ohio, was meticulously uncovered by investigators to be a deliberate act of double murder by the 17-year-old driver, Mackenzie Shirilla, amidst a tumultuous relationship and a shocking lack of remorse."