Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Matthew Mercer's go-to struggle meal is a creamy ramen with canned chicken, thickened with half a can of water instead of a full one, and spiced with cayenne.
- ❖Keith Habersberger's 'Leftover Toddler Breakfast Sandwich' combines chicken apple sausage, cheesy eggs, and peanut butter rye toast with honey.
- ❖Trixie Mattel's preferred struggle meal is a vegetarian alphabet soup paired with a mayonnaise-crusted sourdough grilled cheese.
- ❖Ben Ebbrell of Sorted Food shared a three-ingredient 'Can't Be Asked' curry: minced lamb, tinned tomatoes, and Bombay mix stewed together.
- ❖Max Miller's ultimate broke meal involved ordering a $2 coffee at a diner to get free saltine crackers, peanut butter, and jelly packets.
- ❖Rhett McLaughlin's inventive, yet poorly received, struggle meal consists of Ritz crackers melted with cheese into a disc, topped with a heavily doctored mackerel salad.
Insights
1Matthew Mercer's Creamy Ramen with Canned Chicken
Matthew Mercer's struggle meal combines Campbell's cream of chicken soup, ramen noodles (beef flavor packet), and canned chicken breast. He advises using only half a can of water for a thicker, saucier consistency, and draining the chicken. Cayenne pepper and garlic flavoring are added for taste. This recipe is designed to be cost-effective, shelf-stable, and yield multiple servings.
He begins with 'kumiff chicken soup,' adds 'ramen noodles,' 'canned chicken breast,' and 'cayenne pepper' for spice. He specifies 'a little over half' a can of water for thickness and mentions it 'will feed you for the entire day if you pace it out properly'.
2Keith Habersberger's Leftover Toddler Breakfast Sandwich
Keith Habersberger's struggle meal is a 'Leftover Toddler Breakfast Sandwich,' which is a mashup of chicken apple sausage, cheesy eggs, and peanut butter rye toast with honey. The hosts interpret this as a busy parent's method of consuming child's leftovers, combining disparate flavors into one meal.
Keith describes it as 'leftover toddler breakfast sandwich' with 'chicken apple sausage link, some cheesy eggs on peanut butter rye toast with a little bit of honey'. The host notes, 'Is that what dads are doing? Is that what it's like to be a dad is you just take whatever is left on your toddler's plate and eat it.'
3Trixie Mattel's 'Luxurious' Grilled Cheese and Soup
Trixie Mattel's struggle meal consists of vegetarian alphabet soup (or minestrone) and a grilled cheese sandwich made with sourdough bread, cheddar cheese, and mayonnaise on the outside for crispiness. The hosts found this meal to be surprisingly 'luxurious' and highly satisfying, rating it very positively.
Trixie requests 'vegetable vegetarian alphabet soup' and a 'fresh lovely grilled cheese. Sourdough. You do the mayo thing and then you do um cheddar that can melt. Crisp crisp.' The host calls it an 'adult struggle meal' and rates it '9.1', stating, 'this will end your struggle.'
4Ben Ebbrell's Three-Ingredient 'Can't Be Asked' Curry
Ben Ebbrell of Sorted Food shared a simple curry recipe from his book 'Can't Be Asked,' designed for minimal effort. It combines minced lamb, tinned tomatoes, and Bombay mix (an Indian snack blend) with water, stewed into a curry. The Bombay mix provides lentils, thickening agents, and spices, making it a complete, flavorful dish with minimal effort.
Ben describes his meal as 'minced lamb, tin tomatoes, and a bag of Bombay mix. Mix it together with some water, stew it down, and you have yourself an incredible curry. You've got all the lentils, all the thickening agent, all the spices, all the salt, the lamb, the lamb fat, and the tomato.' The host rates it a '10'.
5Max Miller's Diner Crackers and Coffee Strategy
Max Miller's struggle meal from his broke New York City days involved buying a $2 cup of coffee at a diner to gain access to free saltine crackers, peanut butter, and jam packets. He would then assemble 'half a dozen little peanut butter and jelly sandwiches on saltine crackers for free.'
Max recounts, 'I would go to a diner and order a cup of coffee... and then I would ask for a bunch of salt pans and the free little packets of peanut butter and jam'. The host confirms, 'He was only allowed to get the crackers cuz he'd bought the coffee.'
6Rhett McLaughlin's Mackerel Salad Ritz Disc
Rhett McLaughlin's struggle meal combines two components: Ritz crackers microwaved with shredded cheese to form a 'flimsy and a little bit crispy' disc, and a mackerel salad made from canned mackerel, mayonnaise, yellow mustard, brown mustard, jalapenos, and relish. The goal is to mask the mackerel flavor. The hosts found this combination to be largely unappetizing, particularly the pooling oil and strong mackerel taste.
Rhett describes 'Ritz cracker frisbee' with 'shredded cheese' and a 'mackerel salad' with 'canned mackerel, mayonnaise, mustard, two types of mustard... jalapenos... relish'. He explicitly states, 'you don't want it to taste like mackerel.' The host rates it a '2 out of 10', noting 'a puddle of oil' and 'it still tastes like mackerel.'
Lessons
- Experiment with thickening canned soups by using less water than recommended, as Matthew Mercer does, to create a richer, saucier base for other ingredients.
- Consider the 'mayonnaise crust' technique for grilled cheese sandwiches, as suggested by Trixie Mattel, for an extra crispy exterior.
- If you're looking for an extremely low-effort, flavorful meal, try Ben Ebbrell's three-ingredient curry using minced lamb, tinned tomatoes, and Bombay mix.
- Reframe your understanding of 'struggle meals' to include times of mental exhaustion, not just financial hardship, allowing for simpler, comforting food choices without guilt.
Notable Moments
Josh's anecdote about mistaking a Hasidic Jew's tefillin for a vlogging camera, leading to an awkward airplane encounter.
This humorous, self-deprecating story sets a lighthearted and candid tone early in the episode, showcasing the hosts' comedic style.
The hosts' extended, comedic bit about being 'gaslit' by the crew regarding the location of kitchen whisks, tying it back to the original play's definition.
This demonstrates the show's blend of cooking content with improvisational comedy and meta-commentary, engaging viewers with an ongoing gag.
Josh's deeply personal and depressing anecdote about eating peanut butter and jelly on saltines during a fever, sun poisoning, ant infestation, and parental absence.
Quotes
"The essence of a good struggle meal is something that you can just shake a couple different garlic flavoring to it and it makes it better."
"Beef plus chicken equals pork and that's what I believe."
"I kind of like the prompt being very open of like, hey, what's a meal when you're struggling mentally, when you're struggling financially. There's a lot of different kinds, man. And I kind of like letting that prompt be open cuz everyone kind of intuitively knows what a struggle meal is."
"It's never about the food, right? It's about the people. It's the people behind the food is what we want to say here at Mythical Kitchen."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes

Cheap vs Fancy Macaroni & Cheese
"This episode pits Dollar Tree against Whole Foods in a mac and cheese and broccoli salad showdown, revealing surprising results about ingredient cost versus taste and quality."

Battling for the Best Girl Dinner
"The Smosh team battles through a bracket of submitted 'girl dinners,' defining the viral trend as judgment-free, low-effort meals and ultimately crowning a sophisticated charcuterie-style combination as the champion."

Joseph Duggar & Wife Kendra Arrested? - H3 After Dark #28
"This episode unpacks the latest Duggar family legal troubles, the controversy surrounding Beyoncé's mom's gumbo, and a significant policy change for the H3 subreddit."

Trader Joe's vs. Aldi Cooking Challenge
"This episode pits Trader Joe's against Aldi in a head-to-head cooking challenge, revealing surprising differences in cost, ingredient quality, and taste for a Flamin' Hot Takis chicken sandwich and buffalo cauliflower."