LIVE TAX THE RICH Protest Outside NY Gov’s Office
YouTube · h2sPrF3GrtI
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Over 1 million New Yorkers are at risk of losing healthcare coverage, including 500,000 on the Essential Plan, primarily due to federal cuts and Governor Hochul's inaction.
- ❖The New York state budget is over a month late, with Governor Hochul accused of unilaterally delaying the process to aid her negotiations and avoid taxing the wealthy.
- ❖Protesters advocate for specific tax measures like the Corporate Fair Share Act, a pied-à-terre tax on luxury second homes, and a hedge fund tax to generate billions in revenue.
- ❖Arguments that taxing the rich will cause them to flee New York are dismissed as 'fear-mongering,' with evidence from a New Jersey study suggesting otherwise; instead, working-class New Yorkers are leaving due to affordability issues.
- ❖The movement criticizes Governor Hochul for prioritizing billionaires and large corporations, contrasting her stance with other city and state leaders who support taxing the rich to fund public services and address the affordability crisis.
Insights
1Impending Healthcare Crisis Due to Federal Cuts and State Inaction
Over one million New Yorkers face the imminent threat of losing their healthcare coverage, with 500,000 on the Essential Plan at risk by July 1st. This crisis is attributed to federal cuts, specifically the 'one big beautiful bill,' and Governor Kathy Hochul's perceived inaction in filling the resulting budget gap. The cuts are projected to severely impact hospitals, potentially leading to curtailed services like maternity and psychiatric care, and even closures.
Zaz, an arrested protester, stated, 'Over a million New Yorkers are at risk of losing their health care because of the one big beautiful bill... 500,000 New Yorkers on the essential plan will lose their coverage on May 1st if lawmakers don't act.' (, , ). Analysis from the Greater New York Hospital Association estimates $8 billion in annual cuts to New York's hospitals and health systems ().
2Governor Hochul Accused of Budget Stalling and Prioritizing Billionaires
The New York state budget is significantly delayed, over a month past its due date, which has also stalled the New York City budget. Critics allege that Governor Hochul is intentionally prolonging the budget process to aid her negotiations and avoid implementing taxes on the wealthy. She is accused of siding with billionaires and large corporations, who are benefiting from federal tax cuts, rather than addressing the needs of working-class New Yorkers.
A protester stated, 'right now the New York state budget is over a month late and Kathy Hokll is unilaterally holding up the budget process' (). Later, it was noted, 'Kathy Hokll when asked about this had said, "What incentives do I have to rush the bill given that these delays can help with my negotiations?"' (). Batul Assan, co-chair of the Tax the Rich campaign, highlighted that Hochul met with Citadel CEO Ken Griffin, a billionaire, instead of engaging with protesters ().
3Proposed Tax Measures and Rebuttal to 'Rich Flight' Concerns
Advocates are pushing for several tax measures to generate revenue, including the Corporate Fair Share Act to tax profitable corporations (expected to raise $1.7 billion), a pied-à-terre tax on luxury second homes, and a Pass-Through Entity (PTE) tax on hedge fund handouts. They dismiss concerns that these taxes would cause wealthy individuals to flee New York, citing a New Jersey study that showed no significant exodus after an income tax increase. Instead, they argue that working-class New Yorkers are the ones being forced out by the affordability crisis.
Senator Kristen Gonzalez introduced the Corporate Fair Share Act, stating it would raise '$1.7 billion' (, ). Regarding the 'rich flight' argument, Zaz countered, 'the reality is that the billionaires... they're not the ones getting pushed out of New York City... an excellent study... found is that um basically none of the rich people left.' (, ). Assembly Member Diana Moreno added, 'it is working families that are leaving the state, not millionaires and billionaires.' ().
Lessons
- Contact Governor Kathy Hochul and state legislators to demand action on the state budget and support for 'tax the rich' policies to fund healthcare and other essential services.
- Participate in local 'Tax the Rich' rallies and organizing efforts, such as canvassing and protests, to exert public pressure on elected officials.
- Support political candidates endorsed by organizations like New York City DSA who advocate for progressive tax reforms and an affordability agenda for working people.
Notable Moments
Zaz, an arrested protester, shares a personal story about needing gender-affirming surgery and the impact of healthcare cuts on others facing similar needs.
This personal testimony humanizes the impact of healthcare policy, illustrating how abstract budget decisions directly affect individuals' lives and access to critical medical care, including gender-affirming procedures.
Roshan Sher, a community organizer for DRUM (Desis Rising Up and Moving), highlights the struggles of South Asian immigrant working-class people, emphasizing that healthcare cuts could lead to death for those needing regular medication and supervision.
This moment underscores the severe, life-or-death implications of healthcare cuts for vulnerable communities, connecting economic policy directly to the survival and well-being of marginalized populations.
Speakers repeatedly challenge Governor Hochul with the chant, 'Kathy, which side are you on?'
This recurring chant encapsulates the central theme of the protest: forcing Governor Hochul to choose between the interests of wealthy donors and the needs of working-class New Yorkers, framing the issue as a moral and political imperative.
Quotes
"In a state with more billionaires than any other, over a million New Yorkers are at risk of losing their health care because of the one big beautiful bill, which is objectively the biggest erosion of our nation's healthcare in our history."
"If you paid a dollar of federal taxes, which literally everyone here and every New Yorker I speak to has, you paid more than these corporations."
"We are tired of our tax dollars going to war and genocide instead of education and healthcare."
"Our governor who has failed to deliver a budget that works for working-class people in New York. A budget that is allowing Trump's cuts to hit black and brown New Yorkers most with cuts to Medicaid and to SNAP. It is disgusting."
"If you don't tax the rich, if you don't actually serve your people, we will only for dying. We will count our day when we will die. That's true. That's fact."
"You don't have to sell out to corporate donors in order to win and in fact what people want is someone who's going to fight for the dignity of working people."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes

Moral Monday at BLM Plaza. Cleo Fields Sounds Alarm on Louisiana & Gary Chambers Pushes Turnout
"Activists and faith leaders gathered at Moral Monday to denounce 'policy violence' in various forms, from war and budget cuts to voter suppression and healthcare denial, urging sustained mobilization against a 'hijacked' democracy."

Met Gala, Muppets and Meltdowns
"The hosts unleash a fiery critique on conservative Christian hypocrisy, MAGA's fear-based reactions to multiculturalism, and the moral bankruptcy of billionaires like Jeff Bezos, calling for a boycott of the Met Gala."

Trump Snubs Democrats. Governors Cancel Annual Meeting. McIver Confronts DHS. GOP Targets Bad Bunny
"This episode dissects partisan political maneuvers, an intense congressional confrontation over ICE abuses, conservative outrage at a Super Bowl halftime show, and critical health disparities impacting Black Americans, culminating in a call for targeted legislative action."

IHIP News: 🚨 Trump RESTARTS War While Sons CASH IN?! The Corruption So OBVIOUS Even MAGA Sees It!
"This episode exposes how a fundamental misunderstanding of wealth, coupled with deep-seated political corruption and a failing Democratic communication strategy, fuels public disillusionment and empowers authoritarian figures."