Brian Tyler Cohen
Brian Tyler Cohen
February 22, 2026

“Full scale panic!” Supreme Courts drop NIGHTMARE news for Trump

Quick Read

State Supreme Courts in Utah and Virginia have delivered significant setbacks to Republican efforts to redraw electoral maps, fueling what hosts describe as 'full-scale panic' within the party, while a critical Supreme Court decision on the Voting Rights Act looms.
Utah's Supreme Court blocked Republicans from fracturing Salt Lake City into multiple districts, likely creating a new Democratic seat.
Virginia's Supreme Court rejected Republican attempts to halt a ballot initiative that could add four Democratic districts.
A critical U.S. Supreme Court decision on the *Klay* case could gut the Voting Rights Act, enabling widespread minority vote suppression.

Summary

State Supreme Courts in Utah and Virginia recently rejected Republican attempts to manipulate electoral maps, with Utah's court upholding a decision to create a Salt Lake City-centric district likely to elect a Democrat, and Virginia's court allowing a ballot initiative to proceed that could add four Democratic districts. These legal losses, coupled with a similar defeat in New York, are framed by the hosts as evidence of Republican desperation and 'full-scale panic' due to their perceived unpopularity. The discussion also highlights the upcoming *Klay* case before the U.S. Supreme Court, which could potentially gut Section Two of the Voting Rights Act, leading to widespread obliteration of minority voting rights and a new round of Republican gerrymandering, particularly in the South and West.
These state-level court decisions directly impact the balance of power in upcoming elections by preventing partisan gerrymandering, potentially shifting several districts towards Democrats. The looming *Klay* case at the U.S. Supreme Court represents an existential threat to the Voting Rights Act, with the potential to fundamentally reshape American democracy by allowing states to severely restrict minority voting rights and entrench Republican majorities for decades.

Takeaways

  • The Utah Supreme Court upheld a lower court's decision to redraw the state map, preventing Republicans from fracturing the Salt Lake City area and likely creating a new Democratic district.
  • The Virginia Supreme Court rejected Republican attempts to block a ballot initiative aimed at redrawing the map, which could add four Democratic districts.
  • Republicans are described as being in 'full-scale panic' due to these and other legal setbacks in redistricting efforts across multiple states.
  • The upcoming U.S. Supreme Court decision in the *Klay* case, concerning Section Two of the Voting Rights Act, is highlighted as potentially the most significant case impacting 2026 elections, with the power to 'obliterate minority voting rights.'
  • The hosts argue that Republican reliance on legal maneuvers and gerrymandering stems from their fundamental unpopularity and lack of a compelling agenda.

Insights

1Utah Supreme Court Blocks Republican Gerrymandering

The Utah Supreme Court rejected Republican attempts to overturn a state court's redrawing of the electoral map. This decision prevents the fracturing of the Salt Lake City area into four districts, instead mandating a Salt Lake City-centric district, which is expected to elect a Democrat. Republicans had exhausted state-level appeals and are now considering a federal appeal, which the guest believes is unlikely to succeed.

Republicans went all the way to the Utah Supreme Court to try to undo that state court's redrawing of the Utah map. As you recall, Republicans in that state fractured the Salt Lake City area into, I think, four different districts. And a state court said, 'Nope, you can't do that. You got to draw a district that is Salt Lake uh city centric.' ... the Supreme Court slammed the door on the last effort that Republicans will have to try to get the state supreme court to overturn that.

2Virginia Supreme Court Upholds Redistricting Initiative

The Virginia Supreme Court once again ruled against Republican efforts to block a ballot initiative aimed at redrawing the state's electoral map. This initiative is projected to add four new districts favorable to Democrats. Despite a lower court in Tazwell County granting Republicans preliminary relief, the state Supreme Court is expected to overturn it, having previously indicated its support for the initiative.

In Virginia, you know, after they Republicans tried to block the Virginia legislature from moving forward with uh a ballot initiative there to redraw the map that would add another four districts for Democrats. They got a a trial court in a very conservative county, Caswell County, uh to say that uh that map would be uh that effort would be stalled. The state supreme court said, 'Nope, not doing that.' ... that case will also now go up to the Virginia Supreme Court and we will see what it does. But my prediction, state supreme court has already said it wants this ballot initiative to go forward once and it's going to say that again.

3Impending U.S. Supreme Court Decision on Voting Rights Act (Klay Case)

A decision is imminent from the U.S. Supreme Court in the *Klay* case, which concerns Section Two of the Voting Rights Act. The guest warns that if the Supreme Court rules in favor of Republicans, it could entirely gut Section Two, allowing Republican-controlled states (especially in the South and West) to redraw maps that 'obliterate minority voting rights.' This outcome would be a 'catastrophe for democracy' and could trigger a new round of gerrymandering, fundamentally impacting future elections.

We may very well be days, hours, weeks away from a decision from the Supreme Court uh in the Cala case. And that is that is section two of the Voting Rights Act. ... if the Trump administration, if Republicans are able to convince the Supreme Court to gut in its entirety, overturn in its entirety section two of the Voting Rights Act, then it will allow Republican states predominantly in the South, but also in the in the West to redraw their maps and and really just obliterate uh minority voting rights. And it will be a catastrophe for democracy.

Lessons

  • Subscribe to the Brian Tyler Cohen YouTube channel and hit the bell icon to receive alerts for new content and analysis on political and legal developments.
  • Subscribe to Democracy Docket, the news outlet founded by guest Mark Elias, to support their work in voting rights litigation and media coverage.
  • Watch the specific video discussing the *Klay* case and its implications for Section Two of the Voting Rights Act to be fully informed on this critical issue.

Notable Moments

Republicans are described as being in 'full-scale panic' over recent legal setbacks in redistricting.

This framing highlights the perceived desperation and strategic challenges faced by the Republican Party in maintaining electoral advantages through gerrymandering.

The guest, Mark Elias, emphasizes that there are 'no Republican moderates,' challenging the common media narrative.

This statement offers a strong opinion on the political landscape, suggesting that any perceived moderation from Republicans is temporary or superficial, and their underlying agenda remains consistent with the broader party goals.

Quotes

"

"Republicans are in full-scale panic. That's what's going on in Utah."

Mark Elias
"

"Republicans are out of their minds about what to do. Donald Trump is a drag on their efforts. They are in full-scale panic."

Mark Elias
"

"We need to stop falling for the idea that there are Republican moderates. Okay? There are no Republican moderates."

Mark Elias
"

"If the Trump administration, if Republicans are able to convince the Supreme Court to gut in its entirety, overturn in its entirety section two of the Voting Rights Act, then it will allow Republican states predominantly in the South, but also in the in the West to redraw their maps and and really just obliterate uh minority voting rights. And it will be a catastrophe for democracy."

Mark Elias

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes