Spoiled Mom Thinks She Can Get Away With Murder
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖On July 11, 2019, a welfare check for 72-year-old William Dubois was initiated after a neighbor reported unusual silence and a loud 'boom' days prior.
- ❖Officers discovered a strong odor of decomposition and William's new red Ford Focus missing from his residence.
- ❖William Dubois' body was found in his bathroom, displaying 27 separate injuries consistent with blunt force trauma.
- ❖The missing car's built-in tracker led police to Taylor Elkins, the granddaughter of the neighbor who called 911.
- ❖Elkins provided multiple false alibis and invented fictional accomplices (Shawn, Joseph Rogers) to deflect blame.
- ❖CCTV footage confirmed Elkins driving the victim's car, and strands of her hair were found clenched in William's hands.
- ❖Elkins eventually confessed to another inmate that she killed William with a hammer after he refused to lend her money.
- ❖She received a sentence of over 40 years in prison for first-degree murder after accepting a plea deal.
Insights
1Initial Misdirection by Neighbor's Perception
Neighbors and the landlord initially suspected Denton Stringer, the man who called for the welfare check, due to his known 'family issues' and frequent arguments. This perception initially diverted police attention, despite Stringer's crucial report of a loud noise.
Christy Joe Wait, a business owner, stated she would have pointed at Denton first for causing trouble (). The landlord, Bob, immediately thought of Denton when police called about a tenant ().
2The Critical Role of Vehicle Tracking Technology
William's new Ford Focus was equipped with a tracker accessible via his estranged wife Susan Dubois's phone app. This technology proved instrumental in quickly locating the stolen vehicle and identifying Taylor Elkins as a primary suspect.
William's son informed officers about the car's tracker (). Susan Dubois used the app to locate the car in a residential neighborhood ().
3Perpetrator's Elaborate Deception and Shifting Narratives
Taylor Elkins constructed multiple false alibis, invented fictional accomplices (Shawn, Joseph Rogers), and feigned ignorance about the victim and the crime. Her stories consistently shifted and contradicted known facts, demonstrating a calculated effort to deflect blame.
Elkins claimed she got the car from 'Shawn,' a user she didn't know well, had no contact info for, and who was later confirmed to be in jail (, ). She later introduced 'Joseph Rogers' as the killer, claiming she only knocked on the door ().
4Forensic Evidence as Undeniable Proof
Despite Elkins' persistent denials and fabricated stories, the discovery of her hair clenched in the victim's hands provided irrefutable physical evidence directly linking her to the struggle and murder, overcoming her attempts at deception.
Investigators found strands of hair clenched in William's hands, matching Taylor's color and texture ().
5Inmate Confession Reveals True Motive and Method
While Elkins never confessed to detectives, she admitted the truth to another inmate while in custody. She revealed she went to William's home to borrow money, and when he refused, she became angry and attacked him with a hammer.
The narrator states, 'while in custody, she admitted the truth to another inmate. She said she had gone to William's home planning to borrow money. When he told her he didn't have any, she got angry. In that moment, she grabbed a hammer and attacked him.' ()
Lessons
- Report unusual activity or disappearances promptly, as initial neighbor vigilance can be crucial in initiating investigations.
- For law enforcement, maintain skepticism towards initial suspect profiling and be prepared for suspects to construct elaborate, shifting alibis.
- Consider implementing or utilizing vehicle tracking technology for valuable assets, as it can be a critical tool in locating stolen property and identifying suspects in violent crimes.
- Prioritize the collection and analysis of all physical evidence, no matter how small, as it can provide irrefutable proof to counter suspect deception.
- Be aware that individuals may attempt to blame others or create fictional accomplices; persistent, evidence-based interrogation is essential to unraveling such lies.
Notable Moments
Officers detect the 'smell of death' at William Dubois's house, confirming suspicions of foul play despite no obvious signs of forced entry.
This moment transforms a routine welfare check into a potential homicide investigation, guiding the officers' subsequent actions and search for evidence.
The detective confronts Taylor Elkins with the fact that her alleged accomplice 'Shawn' was in jail, completely collapsing her primary alibi.
This direct confrontation exposes Elkins's deception and significantly increases pressure on her, marking a critical turning point in the interrogation.
The detective directly informs Taylor Elkins that William Dubois was 'beat to death' and that she was driving his car, intensifying the interrogation.
This direct and forceful revelation shatters Elkins's pretense of ignorance about the victim's fate and her connection to the crime, pushing her closer to a confession.
The revelation that Taylor Elkins's listed address was the same as her grandfather Denton Stringer's, directly linking her to the immediate vicinity of the crime scene.
This connection immediately links the initial suspect (Denton) to the person found with the victim's car (Taylor), establishing a familial relationship that adds another layer of suspicion and motive.
Quotes
"You're driving the car from a man who's been beat to death. And I don't know that you ain't got something to do with it."
"So, if he's in jail, how do you give you the car?"
"You're a rude, cold, heartless murderer. That's what you are."
"She said she had gone to William's home planning to borrow money. When he told her he didn't have any, she got angry. In that moment, she grabbed a hammer and attacked him."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
5 Most Wicked Murder Cases Caught On Bodycam
"Bodycam footage provides an unfiltered, real-time look into five brutal murder investigations, exposing the immediate aftermath of horrific crimes and the initial interactions with suspects and witnesses."
Cheating Fire Chief Murders Wife Hours Before Divorce
"A decorated fire chief, just hours before his divorce was finalized, murdered his wife to avoid financial ruin, then meticulously crafted a false narrative of her sudden medical death."
Military Wife Has Lover Kill Husband in Brutal Conspiracy
"A decorated Army Sergeant's murder on New Year's Eve unravels into a shocking conspiracy involving his wife and her lover, meticulously planned for life insurance money and a new life."
The Blue River Murder | Full Episode
"A mother of three vanishes during a blizzard in a small Colorado town, only to be found brutally murdered, leading investigators to uncover a web of secrets and a husband's dark past."