Dad Kills Twin Baby Girl While Mom is At Work
YouTube · vqK7LL0LGwI
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Andrew Cameer called 911 after his four-month-old twin daughter, Evelyn, stopped breathing, claiming she fell off a changing table.
- ❖Evelyn sustained significant internal trauma to her brain, spinal column, and liver, injuries inconsistent with an accidental fall.
- ❖Detectives noted inconsistencies in Andrew's story and a hole in a bedroom door, which Andrew attributed to a past 'night tear'.
- ❖Andrew admitted to being 'petrified' to hold his babies and feeling 'overwhelmed' by parenthood.
- ❖Danielle Rudy, the twins' mother, initially defended Andrew, stating he would walk away if overwhelmed and was not violent.
- ❖A month after Andrew's arrest, Danielle described their relationship as emotionally and mentally abusive, with Andrew being manipulative and having mentioned not knowing his own strength.
- ❖Andrew was charged with aggravated murder and felonious assault for injuries to Evelyn's twin sister, who suffered broken ribs.
- ❖Andrew pleaded guilty to involuntary manslaughter, felonious assault, and obstruction of justice, receiving a sentence of 19 to 24.5 years.
- ❖Danielle pleaded guilty to two child endangering charges and received a 5-year sentence.
Insights
1Inconsistent Account and Medical Evidence Contradict Accidental Fall
Andrew Cameer's initial explanation of his four-month-old daughter Evelyn falling off a changing table was quickly challenged by detectives and medical professionals. Evelyn's injuries, including severe trauma to her brain, spinal column, and liver, were deemed inconsistent with a simple accidental fall, suggesting a more violent cause.
Andrew's varying accounts of the fall, combined with the autopsy revealing 'significant internal trauma to her brain, spinal column, and liver, and that those injuries were not consistent with an accidental fall.'
2Unacknowledged Stress and Past Aggression
Andrew expressed being overwhelmed by parenthood and admitted to a past incident where he punched a door during a 'night tear' or argument. This revealed a history of uncontrolled anger, which detectives suspected might have contributed to Evelyn's injuries, despite Andrew's denials of shaking her.
Andrew stating, 'This has been the longest year and the the roughest year of my entire life' [] and admitting, 'I woke up one time with a night tear and I punched the door in my bedroom.' []
3Mother's Initial Defense Shifts to Revelation of Abuse
Danielle Rudy initially defended Andrew, asserting he was not violent and would typically walk away if stressed. However, after Andrew's arrest and further reflection, she revealed their relationship was emotionally and mentally abusive, characterized by manipulation and Andrew's admission of not knowing his own strength, suggesting a pattern of behavior that could escalate to physical harm.
Danielle initially stated, 'He's never been rough. He's never been' [] and 'I 100% believe he would say something' if he hurt their daughter []. Later, she described the relationship as 'emotionally and mentally abusive' [], and Andrew 'definitely had me under his thumb' [], also mentioning he 'didn't really know his own strength' over the years [].
4Dual Convictions for Child Abuse and Endangerment
Both Andrew and Danielle faced legal consequences for their roles in the twins' suffering. Andrew was convicted for Evelyn's death and injuries to her twin, while Danielle was convicted for child endangering, indicating her failure to protect her children despite being aware of Andrew's volatile tendencies and the abusive nature of their relationship.
Andrew pleaded guilty to 'involuntary manslaughter, felonious assault, and obstruction of justice' and was sentenced to '19 to 24 and a half years in prison.' Danielle 'pleaded guilty to two child endangering charges' and is 'serving a 5-year sentence.'
Lessons
- Recognize the signs of emotional and mental abuse in relationships, as they can escalate and impact the safety of children.
- Seek help and support when feeling overwhelmed by parental responsibilities to prevent potential harm to children.
- Be vigilant about inconsistencies in explanations for child injuries and trust medical professionals' assessments over anecdotal accounts.
Quotes
"I don't want to hurt my babies. I love them so much."
"She's going to die. She's going to die. Right. So then I essentially by either some sort of negligence or something I've killed my child."
"It doesn't make sense to me that a three-foot fall on the carpet is going to is going to hurt someone that bad, right?"
"If I look back in hindsight and through the therapy I've been through now, it was emotionally and mentally abusive."
"He had mentioned he had said that over the years... he didn't really know his own strength."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
Drunk Dad Leaves Toddler in Fiery Car to Burn Alive
"A blackout drunk father, Nicholas Stammen, caused the horrific death of his 2-year-old daughter, Lilliana, by leaving her strapped in her car seat as his vehicle burned after a drunk driving crash, claiming he had no memory of the events."
LIVE | Kouri Richins Sentencing Memo. So much new info. It's time for prison.
"The Kouri Richins sentencing memo reveals chilling new details, including children's fears and Corey's calculated malice, while a major education software provider, Canvas, pays a ransom after a widespread data breach."
Gen Z Prosecutor Corners Lying Husband with FACTS
"A doctor's meticulously planned attempt to murder his wife on her birthday hike is thwarted by her desperate screams and the timely intervention of two nurses, leading to a dramatic court trial and his eventual conviction."
2 More Duggars from "19 Kids & Counting" Arrested for Crimes Against Children
"Uncover the shocking truth behind the Duggar family's wholesome facade, revealing a multi-generational pattern of child abuse, cover-ups, and the insidious influence of a fundamentalist religious organization."