Prime Crime: Missing Florida Woman Found Murdered in Georgia Landfill

Quick Read

A well-loved Florida widow vanished, leading investigators through a meticulous forensic search, cell phone data, and a massive landfill excavation to uncover her contractor's deadly secret and secure a murder conviction.
Contractor Cory Bindram murdered Susan Malden over a $12,000 renovation dispute.
Digital evidence, including deleted phone data and a Life360 app, tracked Bindram's movements and lies.
Malden's remains were found in a Georgia landfill after a 7,600-ton search, confirming blunt force trauma and strangulation.

Summary

Susan Malden, a 65-year-old British widow living in Fleming Island, Florida, was reported missing on October 24th, 2019, after her friend Phyllis Yates found her home in disarray and her car still in the garage. Investigators quickly focused on her contractor, Cory Bindram, with whom Malden had a contentious dispute over an unfinished $12,000 renovation and an unreturned payment. Evidence at Malden's home, including blood spatter and signs of cleanup, indicated foul play. A cadaver dog alerted to human decomposition on a bag from Bindram's storage unit. Cell phone data showed Bindram deleted communications with Malden and turned off his Life360 app during a critical period on the day of her disappearance. Landfill records revealed Bindram dumped 300 lbs of material, significantly more than the 120 lbs of concrete he claimed, aligning with Malden's weight plus the concrete. This led to an unprecedented search of the Chester Island landfill in Folkston, Georgia, where, after nine days and sifting through 7,600 tons of garbage, Malden's jawbone and remains were found in contractor bags matching those Bindram purchased. DNA on Malden's fingernail included an unknown male profile, which the defense used to argue reasonable doubt. However, testimony from Bindram's ex-wife about his drug use and suspicious behavior, and an inmate's account of Bindram confessing to strangling Malden and feeling her hyoid bone break, solidified the prosecution's case. Bindram was convicted of first-degree murder, burglary, and tampering with evidence, receiving a sentence of life without parole.
This case demonstrates the critical role of meticulous forensic investigation, digital evidence (cell phone data, tracking apps, surveillance footage), and the perseverance of law enforcement in solving complex 'no body' murder cases. It highlights the dangers of financial disputes escalating into violence and underscores the importance of vetting individuals, especially contractors, who gain access to one's home and personal life.

Takeaways

  • Susan Malden, 65, went missing after a dispute with her contractor, Cory Bindram, over an unfinished bathroom renovation and an unpaid $12,000.
  • Investigators found blood evidence and signs of cleanup in Malden's home, indicating a violent struggle.
  • Bindram's phone data showed deleted communications with Malden and a suspicious hour-long period where his Life360 app was turned off on the day of her disappearance.
  • Landfill records revealed Bindram dumped 300 lbs of material, significantly more than the 120 lbs of concrete he claimed, leading investigators to suspect Malden's body was included.
  • A 9-day, 7,600-ton search of the Chester Island landfill in Georgia led to the discovery of Malden's jawbone and remains in contractor bags matching those Bindram purchased.
  • An inmate testified Bindram confessed to strangling Malden and feeling her hyoid bone break, a detail not publicly released.
  • Despite defense arguments about foreign DNA on Malden's fingernail, Bindram was convicted of first-degree murder and sentenced to life without parole.

Insights

1Digital Footprint and Deception

Cory Bindram's attempts to conceal his actions were undermined by his digital footprint. He deleted phone data related to Susan Malden and, critically, turned off his Life360 app for an hour on the day of her disappearance, specifically when he visited the landfill. This digital 'disappearance' was a major red flag for investigators, linking his movements to the crime.

Bindram deleted data off his phone associated with the time frame of Malden's disappearance. His Life360 app was turned off from AM for about an hour on the day Malden disappeared, coinciding with his visit to the Rosemary Hill Landfill.

2Landfill Weight Discrepancy as Key Evidence

A crucial piece of evidence came from landfill records. Bindram's truck weighed 300 lbs less upon leaving the landfill than when he entered. He claimed to have only dumped 120 lbs of concrete. The difference, approximately 180 lbs, precisely matched Susan Malden's known weight plus the concrete, strongly suggesting he disposed of her body there.

Bindram's truck entered the landfill weighing 300 lbs and left 300 lbs lighter. He admitted to dumping 120 lbs of concrete. Malden's recent doctor's appointment provided her weight, which, combined with the concrete, equaled the 300 lb discrepancy.

3Unprecedented Landfill Search and Recovery

The investigation culminated in an extraordinary 9-day search of the Chester Island landfill, sifting through 7,600 tons of garbage. This effort, described as unprecedented for a successful human remains recovery, eventually located Malden's jawbone and, subsequently, her body in contractor bags matching those Bindram purchased.

Law enforcement went through approximately 7,600 tons of garbage. After 9 days, they found a piece of her lower jawbone, confirmed by dental records, and later, the rest of her remains inside contractor bags with a logo matching Bindram's purchases.

4Confession and Forensic Confirmation

An inmate, Thomas Smith, testified that Bindram confessed to strangling Malden, stating he 'yoked her out' and felt 'something break.' This detail was highly significant as forensic pathologists later confirmed Malden's hyoid bone was fractured, consistent with strangulation, a fact not publicly disclosed prior to the inmate's testimony.

Thomas Smith, an inmate, stated Bindram told him he 'yoked her out' and felt 'something break.' The forensic pathologist determined Malden died from blunt force trauma and strangulation, specifically noting a fractured hyoid bone 'at or near death,' consistent with strangulation.

Lessons

  • Always thoroughly vet contractors or any service providers you allow into your home, checking references, licenses, and online reviews.
  • Maintain meticulous records of financial transactions and communications with contractors, especially regarding payments and project timelines.
  • Be wary of individuals who exhibit suspicious behavior, make inappropriate advances, or attempt to borrow money, particularly if they are in a position of trust.
  • Consider using personal safety apps like Life360 with trusted family members, but be aware that perpetrators may attempt to disable them.
  • If involved in a dispute with a contractor, document everything and involve law enforcement or legal counsel early if you feel threatened or suspect fraud.

Quotes

"

"She was adamant if something did happen to Susan, Corey definitely had something to do with it."

Phyllis Yates's friend
"

"When we found the blood in her home, I mean, that left no doubt in my mind at that point that something horrible had happened inside that home to Susan, and Cory was a number one person of interest."

Sergeant Calhoun
"

"No matter what you try to do, you are tracked in all different kinds of ways. And nowadays, almost everyone in everything has a surveillance camera."

Host
"

"He said it felt weird cuz he said he felt something break."

Thomas Smith (recalling Bindram's confession)
"

"My biggest takeaway from the Susan Malden investigation is you never know who you're dealing with on a day-to-day basis. And it's always important to try to vet individuals that you're allowing into your home."

Sergeant Calhoun

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes