Sheriff Attacks Ace Reporter & Admits Cams Are a Bust | Nancy Guthrie Missing Day 17
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Pima County Sheriff admitted to multiple Nest cameras at Nancy Guthrie's home, but video from inside is currently unextractable.
- ❖The mysterious blue shirt found at the scene was a Border Patrol K9 team's scent item, left behind after a search.
- ❖DNA from a glove found two miles away yielded no CODIS hit, while critical DNA from inside the home is still awaiting analysis.
- ❖The FBI is utilizing Parsons Corporation's BlueFly Bluetooth and Wi-Fi search technology to track Nancy Guthrie's pacemaker signal.
- ❖The Sheriff issued conflicting statements on clearing the Guthrie family as suspects, with the FBI refusing to confirm their 'cleared' status.
- ❖The FBI is actively working with Walmart to identify the purchaser of the suspect's backpack using SKU numbers and surveillance footage.
Insights
1Nest Camera Footage Unobtainable
The Pima County Sheriff finally confirmed the presence of multiple Nest cameras inside Nancy Guthrie's home, corroborating earlier reporting. However, video footage from these cameras cannot be extracted, at least not yet, due to a lack of subscription and the cameras overwriting themselves.
Sheriff Nanos admitted to multiple Nest cameras; Google Nest indicated no subscription and data overwrites. (, )
2Sheriff's Public Attack on Reporter Brian Enton
Pima County Sheriff Chris Nanos used an interview with reporter Brian Enton to criticize Enton and NewsNation for a graphic that listed the Sheriff's Department's investigative missteps. Banfield frames this as an uncalled-for attack on a highly respected journalist.
Sheriff Nanos confronted Brian Enton about a NewsNation graphic detailing 'Pima County Sheriff's Department investigation mistakes,' which included points like 'Delayed FBI assistance' and 'Crime scene released quickly.' (, , )
3Pacemaker Tracking Technology Deployed
Investigators are actively attempting to locate Nancy Guthrie's pacemaker using Parsons Corporation's BlueFly Bluetooth and Wi-Fi search technology. This system can detect electronic signals from up to 1,000 feet, even if Nancy is deceased, as pacemakers continue to emit signals for years.
The Sheriff's statement confirmed efforts to locate the pacemaker, working with manufacturers and experts. Parsons Corporation confirmed their BlueFly technology was deployed on February 3rd for helicopter and ground searches. (, )
4Walmart Backpack as a Key Investigative Lead
The FBI is collaborating with Walmart management to identify the individual who purchased the distinctive backpack seen on the perpetrator in the doorbell video. This is considered a strong lead due to SKU numbers and potential cluster purchasing patterns by criminals.
Investigators are working with Walmart to identify the purchaser of the backpack, which is believed to be exclusively or primarily sold there, using SKU numbers and purchase records. ()
5Conflicting Statements on Guthrie Family Suspect Status
The Pima County Sheriff issued contradictory statements regarding whether Nancy Guthrie's family (siblings and spouses) had been 'cleared' as suspects. While initially definitive, later statements softened this to 'not been identified as suspects,' with the FBI declining to confirm any 'cleared' status.
Sheriff Nanos initially stated the family was 'cleared' but later changed language to 'has not been identified as suspects.' The FBI spokesperson stated, 'The FBI doesn't have anything to add to that,' when asked to confirm the family's elimination as suspects. (, )
6FBI Canvassing Gun Shops with Photos, Sheriff Denies
The FBI is actively visiting gun shops with lists of 40 names and photos, asking if any individuals purchased weapons in the last year, specifically looking for matches to the suspect's facial hair. Despite this, Sheriff Nanos publicly denied this activity, claiming it was 'not true.'
A gun shop employee confirmed the FBI showed him three pages of photos and names, asking about gun purchases. Sheriff Nanos, when asked by a Fox reporter about the 40 people at gun stores, stated, 'That's not true.' (, , )
7DNA Evidence Prioritization and Limitations
DNA from a glove found two miles from the home was submitted to CODIS and yielded no match. However, DNA evidence found inside Nancy Guthrie's home, considered more critical, is still undergoing analysis and has not yet been submitted to CODIS. The host explains the differences between CODIS, familial DNA, and investigative genetic genealogy, noting the challenges of 'touch DNA' found in a home.
Sheriff's statement confirmed no CODIS hit for glove DNA. Subsequent statement clarified house DNA is 'being analyzed' and 'further testing needs to be done.' Host explains CODIS only provides direct hits, not partial or familial matches, and the variability of DNA quality. (, , )
Bottom Line
The Pima County Sheriff's Department's low homicide rate (14 per year) suggests a potential lack of extensive 'muscle memory' and experience in handling complex, high-profile homicide investigations compared to larger metropolitan areas.
This limited experience could contribute to the perceived missteps, communication issues, and slower pace of the investigation, impacting public confidence and the efficiency of evidence processing.
Agencies in areas with lower crime rates could benefit from pre-established protocols for rapid, high-level inter-agency support (e.g., FBI, state resources) for major cases, ensuring immediate access to specialized expertise and resources to compensate for internal experience gaps.
The sheriff's public denial of FBI activities (like canvassing gun shops with suspect photos) that are confirmed by other sources indicates a significant disconnect or lack of transparency between the local department and federal agencies, or a deliberate attempt to control the narrative.
This creates confusion for the public and media, undermines the credibility of official statements, and could potentially hinder the investigation by fostering distrust among agencies or sources.
Law enforcement agencies should establish a unified command and a single, consistent public information officer for high-profile multi-agency investigations to prevent conflicting statements and maintain public trust and investigative integrity.
Lessons
- If you have any information regarding Nancy Guthrie's disappearance, call the FBI directly at 1-800-CALL-FBI or submit tips online at tips.fbi.gov.
- Avoid ordering food or services to Nancy Guthrie's home, as this disrupts the crime scene and wastes law enforcement resources.
- Be aware that 'crowdsourcing' information in true crime cases can be effective, but always verify official sources and submit tips through proper channels like the FBI.
Notable Moments
A blue L.L.Bean shirt found on Nancy Guthrie's front walk was identified as an item used by the U.S. Border Patrol's elite K9 team for a scent search, then left behind.
This resolved a public mystery surrounding a puzzling piece of evidence at the crime scene, but also raised questions about proper evidence handling by law enforcement.
A business card from Arizona's Adult Protective Services was found in Nancy Guthrie's door days after her disappearance, left by an agent who was unaware of the ongoing abduction investigation.
This highlights a lack of coordination or awareness among different government agencies, leading to an inappropriate action at an active crime scene and fueling public speculation.
A landscaper and a pizza delivery driver were allowed onto Nancy Guthrie's property on separate occasions, despite it being an active investigation site.
These incidents underscore potential lapses in crime scene security or management, causing public and media frustration over the handling of the investigation.
Quotes
"Don't attack Brian Enton. That guy's reporting is impeccable. His standards are impeccable."
"That shirt was used by United States Border Patrol and it was left behind by United States Border Patrol. Once we were notified, we retrieved it and verified it was left by USB."
"At this point in the investigation, the Guthrie family, including siblings and spouses, has not been identified as suspects."
"That's not true. We haven't narrowed it down to anything other than we have certain pieces of evidence that we're looking at to try to find this individual."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes

Nancy Guthrie Mystery: Will They Ever Find Her... Or Catch the Person Who Took Her?
"An in-depth analysis of the Nancy Guthrie disappearance reveals internal police department frustrations, command-level missteps, and the painstaking 'grind phase' of a complex investigation."

Was Sheriff Lying or Clueless as Feds & Mystery SUVs Swarmed Nancy Guthrie’s House?
"Federal prosecutors and FBI agents swarmed Nancy Guthrie's property, signaling a major escalation in the missing person case, while the local sheriff's department faced intense criticism for contradictory statements and perceived mishandling."

SAVANNAH GUTHRIE'S MOM MISSING: DAY 62
"New Google video evidence reveals a suspect casing Nancy Guthrie's home weeks before her disappearance, while experts detail advanced digital forensics and debunk widespread conspiracy theories."

Bombshell Details & Clues from Savannah, Police Source Reveals Inside Detail | Nancy Guthrie Case
"Savannah Guthrie reveals new details about her mother's disappearance, while a police source admits the investigation has no leads, prompting former cold case investigator Paul Holes to offer a contrarian theory of staged abduction masking a potential homicide."