Twisted New Clues in ‘Poison Mom’ Alleged Murder Plot
YouTube · 1ZQ0-ZFeJMc
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Gudrun Coogle is charged with first-degree murder for her daughter Lila's death and two counts of attempted murder for Mia and Richard, all linked to poisoned wine at a 2025 Thanksgiving dinner.
- ❖The poison, acetonitrile, converts to deadly cyanide in the body; Richard's blood showed toxic cyanide levels (level 10), while 0.2-5 is considered toxic.
- ❖Gudrun's daughter Mia tasted the wine, found it 'off,' and spit it out, while Lila and Richard continued to drink it.
- ❖Before the dinner, Gudrun allegedly searched 'What happens if I accidentally ingest acetonitrile?' on her phone.
- ❖Gudrun provided conflicting accounts to police, initially suggesting the wine might have been near rat poison or that a 2-year-old put poison in it.
- ❖She is also charged with the 2007 murder of Misha Schmidt, who died from acetonitrile poisoning on her property, where a life insurance policy was taken out five days before his death.
- ❖Authorities in Wisconsin are revisiting the 2017 death of Gudrun's ex-husband, Elroy Lund Jr., due to the new charges.
- ❖Gudrun changed her name from Linda Jean Casper to Gudrun Linda Jean Casper Lininger Kugel in 2004.
- ❖Her defense is seeking pre-trial release, citing her need to breastfeed her 3-year-old and existing medical conditions, arguing the evidence is circumstantial.
- ❖The father of the deceased daughter, Travis Peterson, expressed shock, stating he still loves the 'woman that I was with' but believes the woman in court 'deserves to die'.
Insights
1Acetonitrile as a Signature Poison
The chemical acetonitrile, which metabolizes into cyanide, is the alleged murder weapon in the 2025 Thanksgiving dinner poisoning and the 2007 death of Misha Schmidt. This commonality suggests a deliberate and repeated method used by Gudrun Coogle across multiple alleged crimes.
Lila Livas and Richard consumed acetonitrile, leading to Lila's death and Richard's hospitalization with 'level 10' cyanide. Schmidt's autopsy in 2007 also showed acetonitrile poisoning with a level of 300.
2Suspicious Pre-Crime Behavior and Inconsistent Explanations
Gudrun's alleged actions and statements before and after the Thanksgiving dinner raise significant suspicion, including her search history and contradictory explanations for the poison's presence.
Police found Gudrun searched 'What happens if I accidentally ingest acetonitrile?' before the dinner. She told authorities the wine was stored near barn chemicals like rat poison, then later claimed a 2-year-old put the poison in the wine. She also asked Lila's father about life insurance after Lila's death.
3Multi-Decade Pattern of Alleged Homicides
The current charges are part of a broader pattern of suspicious deaths linked to Gudrun Coogle, spanning from 2007 to 2025, with authorities now revisiting a third death.
Gudrun is charged with Lila's murder (2025) and Misha Schmidt's murder (2007). Authorities in Wisconsin are also re-examining the 2017 death of her ex-husband, Elroy Lund Jr., who was 28 years older than her.
4Legal Challenges of Circumstantial Poisoning Cases
Prosecuting poison-based murders often relies on circumstantial evidence, which can be strengthened by patterns of behavior and multiple victims, but also presents challenges for the defense.
Criminal defense attorney Jason Saint Aubin explains that direct evidence (seeing the poison poured) is rare in such cases, making circumstantial evidence crucial. The defense will likely challenge the context of search history and argue for accidental contamination given multiple people and an open wine bottle.
Notable Moments
Gudrun's defense team files a motion for pre-trial release, citing her need to breastfeed her 3-year-old child and existing medical conditions.
This unusual request for release, based on personal circumstances, highlights the defense's strategy to argue against her detention despite severe murder charges.
Travis Peterson, Lila's biological father, describes Gudrun's demeanor at Lila's funeral as 'wooden' and emotionally detached, like 'hugging a plank of wood'.
This observation from a close family member suggests a lack of normal grief, adding to the suspicious circumstances surrounding Lila's death before Gudrun's arrest.
Gudrun allegedly asked Travis Peterson about life insurance policies for Lila after her death, before her arrest.
This inquiry about financial gain immediately after a suspicious death is a strong piece of circumstantial evidence suggesting a potential motive for the alleged crime.
Quotes
"I still love the woman that I was with. I still love the woman that bore me my child. The woman that's down in that courthouse right now deserves to die."
"In almost every one of these cases, you have what we call circumstantial evidence. Um circumstantial evidence is just a fancy term for things you don't see, but are likely potentially true."
"One of the articles had a number to the Hendersonville Police. Another article, it said something about maybe this was a life insurance scheme. And I go through the text that Linda and I had been exchanging back and forth and one of them was she was asking about a life insurance that my mom and dad had put on Lila."
"I don't know what to believe anymore. This is not the woman I was with. This is not the woman that I still love to this day. The one the woman who bore me our child and was just wonderful."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
The Root Beer Float Murder | Full Episode + Post Mortem
"A seemingly natural death of a husband is unmasked as a calculated poisoning plot by his wife and stepdaughter, revealed only after an unrelated burglary exposes a trail of incriminating text messages."
CELESTE, 13, AUTOPSY: SKELETONIZED, MISSING LEFT EYE, D4VD WHINES
"A 13-year-old girl, Celeste Rivas, was found partially skeletonized with a missing left eye, traces of meth and MDMA, and fatal stab wounds, while the accused musician David Anthony Burke (D4VD) complains about jail conditions."
Schizophrenic Man Allegedly Murders Two Friends With Swords
"A man with a history of erratic behavior and mental illness is accused of brutally murdering two friends with swords, leading to a complex investigation and a plea of not guilty by reason of insanity."
True-crime cases with recent developments | 48 Hours Full Episodes
"This episode reconstructs four complex true-crime cases, detailing the harrowing searches for missing persons, the challenges of prosecuting murders without bodies, and the enduring quest for justice in cold cases spanning decades."