Roland Martin Unfiltered
Roland Martin Unfiltered
April 1, 2026

Terence Crutcher Case Heads to Jury. SCOTUS Race Case. Senators Press 2020 Election Truth

Quick Read

This episode dissects critical legal battles against qualified immunity and racial bias in jury selection, exposes political maneuvers to undermine voting rights, and reveals the economic impact of anti-DEI policies on Black women entrepreneurs, alongside an inspiring story of a homeless-to-Oprah-featured jewelry designer.
A federal appeals court denied qualified immunity for the officer who killed Terence Crutcher, allowing his family's civil suit to proceed after a decade.
Trump's executive order limiting mail-in voting is deemed unconstitutional and part of a broader effort to rig elections, with judicial nominees refusing to acknowledge basic facts about 2020.
Anti-DEI policies caused significant revenue losses for Black women-owned businesses, prompting a call for internal economic ecosystems and legal defense funds.

Summary

The episode covers several pressing issues impacting Black America, starting with a significant legal victory for the Terence Crutcher family, as an appeals court denied qualified immunity to the officer who killed him, allowing a civil lawsuit to proceed. It then critiques former President Trump's executive order to limit mail-in voting, framing it as an unconstitutional attempt to rig elections, and highlights the alarming refusal of Trump's judicial nominees to acknowledge the 2020 election results or the January 6th Capitol attack. The discussion moves to a Supreme Court case challenging racial discrimination in jury selection in Mississippi, emphasizing the systemic nature of such bias. A new report by the Aramenta Project details the severe financial impact of anti-DEI policies on Black women-owned businesses, prompting a call for collective economic action and legal defense. Finally, the episode features Leah Valencia, founder of Valencia Key Jewelry, who shares her journey from homelessness to entrepreneurial success, emphasizing her brand's mission of inspiration and community giving.
These discussions highlight persistent systemic challenges in the U.S. legal and political systems, particularly concerning racial justice and democratic integrity. The detailed report on anti-DEI policies provides concrete evidence of economic harm to Black women, underscoring the need for collective action and legal defense in the face of targeted attacks. The emphasis on local elections, especially for District Attorneys and Attorneys General, reveals crucial levers for change often overlooked, while the entrepreneurial success story offers a powerful narrative of resilience and community reinvestment.

Takeaways

  • The 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled against qualified immunity for Betty Shelby, the officer who killed Terence Crutcher, allowing his family's civil lawsuit to advance.
  • Trump's executive order to limit mail-in voting is criticized as unconstitutional and a transparent attempt to suppress votes, facing immediate legal challenges.
  • Trump's judicial nominees demonstrated a lack of independence by refusing to affirm Joe Biden won the 2020 election or that the Capitol was attacked on January 6th.
  • The Supreme Court heard arguments in a Mississippi death penalty case, Pitchfor v. Kaine, regarding racial discrimination in jury selection by a prosecutor with a history of such misconduct.
  • A report by the Aramenta Project found 53% of Black women entrepreneurs lost contracts/clients and 70% lost $100,000+ in revenue due to anti-DEI policies.
  • Black business leaders are responding to anti-DEI attacks by building internal economic ecosystems, fostering inter-business collaboration, and establishing legal defense funds.
  • The role of State Attorneys General is highlighted as critical in challenging federal overreach and protecting civil rights, with Democratic AGs successfully filing numerous lawsuits.
  • Leah Valencia, founder of Valencia Key Jewelry, shared her inspiring journey from homelessness to creating an Oprah-featured brand, emphasizing giving back to her community.

Insights

110th Circuit Denies Qualified Immunity in Terence Crutcher Case

After a decade, the U.S. 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that Betty Shelby, the white police officer who killed unarmed Terence Crutcher in 2016, is not entitled to qualified immunity. This decision revives the Crutcher family's wrongful death lawsuit against Shelby personally, allowing the case to proceed to trial and potentially expose a 'corrupt cover-up' by the city of Tulsa.

The family attorney, Deario Solomon Simmons, stated, 'Our case was dismissed. It was revived yesterday by the 10th circuit and a powerful opinion and we are excited about this opportunity to finally get some justice for the Crutcher family.' The host clarifies the suit is against Shelby personally, not the city, which was dismissed from the case.

2Trump's Executive Order on Mail-in Voting Deemed Unconstitutional

Former President Trump signed an executive order attempting to limit mail-in voting by directing the postal service to only send ballots to an 'approved list of voters' and requiring individual barcodes on envelopes. This order is widely considered unconstitutional and is expected to be immediately challenged in court, as it contradicts existing voting procedures and is seen as an attempt to suppress votes.

Host Roland Martin stated, 'This fool has now signed an executive order limiting mail and voting... it's unconstitutional order.' Political law attorney Nicole Robinson added, 'Just like most of his executive orders they have been challenged in the court and we have to remember that he's actually not winning right now.'

3Judicial Nominees Evade Questions on 2020 Election and Jan 6th

During Senate confirmation hearings, several of Trump's judicial nominees repeatedly refused to directly state that Joe Biden won the 2020 presidential election or that the U.S. Capitol was attacked on January 6, 2021. Their evasive, 'canned' responses, citing constitutional processes without affirming facts, were criticized by senators as demonstrating a lack of independence and impartiality essential for a federal judge.

Senator Blumenthal pressed a nominee, 'Who won the 2020 election?' The nominee responded, 'Under our constitution, the electoral college... votes for the president and then that is certified by Congress.' Senator Sheldon Whitehouse expressed amazement at the 'Orwellian' denial of reality, stating it 'fundamentally show[s] a complete lack of independence and backbone and impartiality.'

4Supreme Court Hears Case on Racial Bias in Jury Selection

The Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Pitchfor v. Kaine, a Mississippi death penalty case where the defendant, Terry Pitchfor, claims his constitutional rights were violated due to racial discrimination in jury selection. The same prosecutor and judge involved in Pitchfor's 2006 trial were also implicated in a 2019 Supreme Court decision that overturned another inmate's conviction for similar misconduct, highlighting a pattern of excluding Black jurors in a county that is 40% Black.

The host noted, 'The fact that the same prosecutor, the same judge in this previous case are being challenged here.' Attorney Nicole Robinson added, 'If the court accepts this so-called ridiculous race-neutral argument... then the right to a fair jury is just meaningless.'

5Anti-DEI Policies Devastate Black Women-Owned Businesses

A new report, 'The Ultimate Overcomers: Black Women in Business in the Anti-DEI Era' by New Strategies and the Aramenta Project, reveals the severe economic impact of anti-DEI policies. The study found 53% of Black women entrepreneurs lost contracts/clients, 70% reported losses of $100,000 or more in revenue, and 68% experienced revenue declines that delayed or canceled business growth plans.

Nick Colbert Johnson, founder of B Collective and the Aramenta Project, stated, 'We are looking at the last year and this very intentional impact on DEI. We know that that is code and it is very specific for a particular demographic... black people particularly black women.' Dr. Avis Jones-Deaver added, 'Collectively, this elite group of business owners earned some $1.7 billion in revenue prior to the onset of these actions.'

6Black Business Leaders Build Internal Economic Resilience

In response to anti-DEI attacks, Black women business owners are actively building internal economic ecosystems. This involves intentionally doing business with one another, providing loans, aggregating market strategies, and pursuing acquisitions of existing Black-owned businesses to create a 'both/and' strategy of fighting legal battles and fostering collective economic growth.

Nick Colbert Johnson detailed, 'We started doing business with one another. We started giving loans to one another. This was um what we are saying is the both strategy.' She also mentioned, 'We're in the process of doing a 52 million acquisition it to futureproof all of our professional service businesses.'

Bottom Line

The increasing importance of State Attorneys General (AGs) as a primary line of defense against federal government overreach and for protecting civil liberties, particularly when the federal executive branch is perceived as hostile.

So What?

This shifts the focus of political engagement to state-level elections for AGs, recognizing their significant power to file lawsuits and champion pro-consumer and pro-community policies, often using 'states' rights' arguments in an ironic twist.

Impact

Progressive movements should strategically invest in electing more diverse and progressive AGs at the state level to counteract federal actions and advance civil rights and economic justice agendas.

The 'chilling effect' of anti-DEI policies extends beyond direct executive orders, causing corporate America to cease doing business with diverse suppliers due to legal uncertainty, even if not explicitly mandated.

So What?

This indirect discrimination creates a 'prima facie case' for legal challenges, as businesses are losing opportunities solely based on their demographic affiliation, despite equal qualifications.

Impact

Organizations like the Aramenta Project are building legal defense funds and collecting data to pursue race discrimination claims, offering a proactive legal offensive against this subtle form of economic exclusion.

Opportunities

Black-Owned Business Acquisition Fund/Network

Establish a collective fund or network specifically for acquiring existing, cash-flow positive Black-owned businesses, particularly those whose owners are retiring or looking for succession plans. This avoids the high failure rate of startups and allows for immediate scaling and wealth retention within the community.

Source: Nick Colbert Johnson mentioned their group is 'in the process of doing a 52 million acquisition it to futureproof all of our professional service businesses.' Roland Martin also emphasized, 'You can buy something that's already existing that's again cash flow positive and then take it further.'

Community-Driven Affordable Housing Development

Leverage entrepreneurial success and community resources to fund and develop affordable housing projects in historically impoverished neighborhoods. This goes beyond charity, aiming for systemic change by cleaning up communities and providing stable living environments, potentially with integrated support services.

Source: Leah Valencia of Valencia Key Jewelry stated, 'I'm even working on a affordable housing um project in Philadelphia where I lived in poverty neighborhood of Philadelphia.'

Key Concepts

Qualified Immunity

A legal doctrine protecting government officials from liability in civil lawsuits unless their conduct violates clearly established statutory or constitutional rights, which the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled did not apply to Betty Shelby in the Terence Crutcher case.

Batson Challenge

A legal challenge to peremptory strikes in jury selection, arguing that a potential juror was excluded based on race, as established by the Supreme Court's 1986 decision in Batson v. Kentucky. The Pitchfor v. Kaine case highlights ongoing issues with this in Mississippi.

Economic Ecosystem (Black America)

The concept that economic activities within the Black community are interconnected, where government contracts, grants, and corporate DEI initiatives create a 'downflow' of resources that impact businesses, non-profits, employees, and families. Attacks on this ecosystem necessitate internal collective action and support.

White Backlash

The historical pattern in the U.S. where periods of Black success are consistently followed by significant white backlash, leading to efforts to undermine or dismantle Black progress. This model is applied to current anti-DEI movements and political attacks on voting rights.

Lessons

  • Support Black-owned businesses and intentionally 'circle the wagons' by directing spending power inward to build collective economic strength, especially in response to external attacks on DEI and minority enterprises.
  • Engage actively in local and state elections for positions like District Attorney and Attorney General, as these officials wield significant power in criminal justice reform and challenging federal overreach.
  • Educate yourself and others on the nuances of political and legal attacks (e.g., the difference between DEI jobs and DEI infrastructure) to effectively counter misinformation and mobilize informed action.

Building Black Economic Resilience Amidst Anti-DEI Backlash

1

**Quantify Harm & Build Data:** Conduct rigorous research to document the specific economic damages and 'chilling effects' of anti-DEI policies on Black-owned businesses, providing empirical evidence for legal and advocacy efforts.

2

**Foster Internal Economic Ecosystems:** Prioritize doing business with other Black-owned enterprises, sharing resources, and providing mutual support (e.g., inter-business loans, client referrals) to create a resilient, self-sustaining network.

3

**Proactive Legal Defense & Offense:** Establish legal defense funds and engage legal counsel to pursue race discrimination claims, leveraging documented damages to challenge discriminatory policies and practices in court.

Notable Moments

Trump's judicial nominees' refusal to acknowledge the 2020 election results or the January 6th Capitol attack during Senate hearings.

This demonstrated a profound lack of judicial independence, impartiality, and a willingness to deny objective facts, raising serious concerns about their fitness to serve on the federal bench for life and uphold the rule of law.

Quotes

"

"Qualified immunity does not appear in the constitution. Qualified immunity is not in the statute... Qualified immunity was something that was created by the courts back in the early 1980s and it's used as a shield to to protect cops that do wrongdoing so they cannot be held accountable."

Deario Solomon Simmons
"

"This man lies. This man cheats. This man steals. And that's exactly what he's trying to do with this next election."

Dr. Avis Jones-Deaver
"

"If you can't even sit here and say that Joe Biden won that election or that the capital was attacked, what's left? What's left if a hard case comes your way as a judge and let's say the Trump administration is bearing down on that? Why would we ever believe that you would give the litigants a fair hearing and a fair decision if the executive branch was leaning in on you when we can't get a reasonable answer out of any of you with the executive branch leaning in on you to give these ridiculous answers today?"

Senator Sheldon Whitehouse
"

"There's never been a period of black success that was not followed by white backlash."

Roland Martin

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

Trump Impact On Black America. SCOTUS Birthright Citizenship Case. Alabama College DEI probe
Roland Martin UnfilteredApr 1, 2026

Trump Impact On Black America. SCOTUS Birthright Citizenship Case. Alabama College DEI probe

"This episode dissects the multifaceted impacts of Trump-era policies on Black America, from economic destabilization and civil rights rollbacks to an inspiring narrative of an entrepreneur rebuilding her life and community."

US Supreme Court14th AmendmentBirthright Citizenship+2
Lemon LIVE at 5 | Is The FBI & Trump Administration Covering Up For The ICE Shooter?!
The Don Lemon ShowJan 8, 2026

Lemon LIVE at 5 | Is The FBI & Trump Administration Covering Up For The ICE Shooter?!

"Don Lemon and his guests dissect a controversial ICE shooting, alleging a Trump administration cover-up and highlighting a systemic failure in police accountability and due process."

ICE shootingTrump administrationCover-up+1
HOT TOPICS | WARNING: Donald Trump's Iran War Chaos Has Hit the Point of No Return!
The Don Lemon ShowApr 1, 2026

HOT TOPICS | WARNING: Donald Trump's Iran War Chaos Has Hit the Point of No Return!

"Don Lemon delivers a scathing critique of Donald Trump's recent actions, framing them as desperate, unconstitutional attempts to consolidate power, undermine democracy, and distract from economic and foreign policy failures, all while questioning his mental stability."

Donald TrumpElection IntegrityMail-in Voting+2
Warnock UNLOADS on Trump SAVE Act. Calls It a Power Grab to Block Voters
Roland Martin UnfilteredMar 22, 2026

Warnock UNLOADS on Trump SAVE Act. Calls It a Power Grab to Block Voters

"Senator Raphael Warnock vehemently opposes the 'SAVE Act,' framing it as a politically motivated voter suppression tactic that disproportionately disenfranchises eligible citizens under the false pretense of preventing non-existent voter fraud."

Voting RightsVoter SuppressionSAVE Act+2