The Megyn Kelly Show
The Megyn Kelly Show
April 10, 2026

Melania Talks Epstein, and New Tyler Robinson Letter Revealed, Plus New TMZ Nancy Guthrie Notes

Quick Read

Megyn Kelly dissects Melania Trump's unexpected Epstein remarks, the unraveling Iran-Israel ceasefire over Lebanon, new evidence in the Tyler Robinson murder case, and critical missteps in the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation.
Melania Trump's unprompted Epstein denial created more controversy, potentially reacting to old news or attempting distraction.
Israel's refusal to cease bombing Lebanon allegedly sabotaged a broader Iran ceasefire, keeping the Strait of Hormuz closed.
The Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation is plagued by alleged law enforcement incompetence and conflicting ransom notes, leaving the family without closure.

Summary

Megyn Kelly opens by scrutinizing Melania Trump's unprompted public statement denying close ties to Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, questioning its timing and strategic wisdom. She then pivots to the volatile Iran-Israel ceasefire, alleging Israel's refusal to include Lebanon derailed the peace efforts and kept the Strait of Hormuz closed. Updates on the Tyler Robinson murder trial reveal a newly unsealed letter to his 'trans lover' and a controversial commencement speaker at UVU. The episode concludes with an in-depth look at the Nancy Guthrie kidnapping, detailing conflicting ransom notes, the FBI's assessment of their legitimacy, and severe criticisms of the Pima County Sheriff's Department for alleged incompetence and misjudgment, leaving Savannah Guthrie in a state of unresolved grief.
This episode offers a critical, opinionated lens on high-profile political and criminal events, highlighting potential misjudgments by public figures and law enforcement. It exposes the complexities of international diplomacy, the personal toll of public scandals, and the frustrations of stalled criminal investigations, providing listeners with a detailed, albeit biased, understanding of these unfolding narratives.

Takeaways

  • Melania Trump's public statement denying Epstein ties was a 'PR blunder' that reignited a dormant story, potentially in response to a retracted Daily Beast article or as a distraction from Iran.
  • The initial Iran-Pakistan ceasefire deal, which included Lebanon, was allegedly sabotaged by Israel's continued bombing, leading to the Strait of Hormuz remaining closed.
  • New evidence in the Tyler Robinson murder trial includes a formal letter to his 'trans lover' and a controversial UVU commencement speaker who previously smeared the victim.
  • The Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation faces criticism for inexperienced initial responders and a 'rush to judgment' that treated it as a search and rescue, not a criminal case.
  • The FBI reportedly believed the first two ransom notes in the Guthrie case were legitimate, but the family did not pay, possibly due to a failed attempt to trace the Bitcoin address.
  • A second 'ransom note writer' has sent multiple, increasingly desperate notes to TMZ, demanding Bitcoin for information, but is largely dismissed as a scammer by experts.

Insights

1Melania Trump's Unprompted Epstein Denial Backfires

Melania Trump made an unexpected public statement vehemently denying close ties to Jeffrey Epstein and Ghislaine Maxwell, and discrediting claims Epstein introduced her to Donald Trump. She also called for public congressional testimony from Epstein's victims. Megyn Kelly frames this as a significant PR misstep, noting that the Epstein story concerning Melania had largely faded from public discourse. The host speculates the statement might have been a pre-emptive response to a retracted Daily Beast article that alleged her 'very involved' with Epstein and even claimed to know when she first had sex with Donald Trump. Melania's legal team successfully forced retractions from the Daily Beast and James Carville regarding defamatory statements.

Melania's public remarks at the White House (), her explicit denials (, ), the Daily Beast's retracted article and podcast comments by Michael Wolf (), Michael Wolf's specific allegations (), and legal actions taken by Melania's team ().

2Israel's Actions Allegedly Derail Iran Ceasefire, Strait of Hormuz Remains Closed

A ceasefire brokered by Pakistan, initially understood to include Lebanon, was allegedly undermined by Israel's continued bombing campaigns in Beirut. Megyn Kelly asserts that the US initially agreed to Lebanon's inclusion but reversed its position after a call between President Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu. This 'bloodthirsty' stance by Netanyahu, refusing to 'lowkey it' in Lebanon, is presented as the primary reason for the ceasefire's failure in the region. Consequently, the Strait of Hormuz remains effectively closed, with minimal shipping traffic, signaling severe economic fallout.

Pakistani Prime Minister's initial ceasefire announcement mentioning Lebanon (), CBS News reporting Trump changed position after call with Netanyahu (), Netanyahu's public statements of 'full force ahead' (), and data showing minimal traffic through the Strait of Hormuz (, ).

3Tyler Robinson Murder Trial: New Letter and UVU Controversy

Newly unsealed search warrants in the Tyler Robinson murder trial revealed a letter from Robinson to his 'trans lover' (Luna), detailing his intent to 'take out Charlie Kirk' and expressing love. The host notes the letter's formal tone, which mirrors previous text messages, suggesting it reflects Robinson's unique communication style. Evidence seized from his home includes various weapons, electronics, and clothing matching the alleged shooter. Separately, UVU faced criticism for inviting Sharon McMahon, a speaker who allegedly smeared Charlie Kirk post-mortem, as its commencement speaker, despite the university's alleged failure to secure the campus during the assassination.

Unsealed search warrants and affidavit via Postmillennial (), the full text of Tyler Robinson's letter (), list of seized items from Robinson's home (), and Sharon McMahon's alleged defamatory social media posts about Charlie Kirk ().

4Nancy Guthrie Kidnapping: Investigation Failures and Unresolved Grief

The Nancy Guthrie kidnapping investigation continues to be mired in confusion and alleged incompetence. Two distinct sets of ransom notes emerged: the first two, sent to the family, were deemed 'legit' by the FBI (according to Harvey Levin), but the family did not pay the ransom, possibly due to a failed FBI attempt to trace the Bitcoin address. A second 'ransom note writer' has sent multiple, increasingly persistent and vague notes to TMZ, demanding Bitcoin for information, but is largely dismissed as a scammer. Critics, including a source close to the investigation, allege the Pima County Sheriff's Department made critical mistakes, including deploying inexperienced homicide detectives and initially treating the case as a 'search and rescue' rather than a criminal matter, leading to a 'cold case' with 'no leads.' Savannah Guthrie returned to work, expressing deep disappointment with God and the 'uniquely cruel injury of not knowing' her mother's fate.

Harvey Levin's reporting on two sets of notes (), FBI's belief in the legitimacy of the first two notes (, ), Harvey's speculation on why ransom wasn't paid (), details of the second note writer's communications (), Brian Entin's report on inexperienced initial responders () and 'rush to judgment' (), Sheriff Nanos's defensive statements (), and Savannah Guthrie's emotional Easter message ().

5Homeland Security Spouse Scandal: Brian Gnome's 'Bimbo Fetish' and Identity Crisis

Brian Gnome, husband of former Homeland Security chief Christy Gnome, was exposed by the Daily Mail for openly engaging with 'bimbo fetish' women, paying thousands for 'saucy talk and picture exchanges.' Recordings reveal him professing love and subservience to one dominatrix, Rilin Riley, stating she was 'so much better than his wife' and that he didn't think his family 'stands a chance' compared to her. He used the alias 'Jason Jackson' but made payments under his real name, and admitted to wanting to be referred to by the pseudonym 'Crystal.' The host predicts Brian Gnome will 'transition' within a year, leading to separation and divorce, and notes Christy Gnome's current government position is in jeopardy due to staff hemorrhaging and administrative leave for her team.

Daily Mail report on Brian Gnome's activities (), details of his interactions with 'bimbo fetish' women (), his use of the alias 'Jason Jackson' and pseudonym 'Crystal' (, ), recorded phone conversations (, ), and reports of Christy Gnome's staff issues and precarious government position ().

Quotes

"

"The lies linking me with the disgraceful Jeffrey Epstein need to end today."

Melania Trump
"

"I call on Congress to provide the women who have been victimized by Epstein with a public hearing specifically centered around the survivors."

Melania Trump
"

"He is bloodthirsty. And then yesterday, Trump gave an interview saying to NBC saying he's gonna lowkey it. All right. I talked to BB. He's gonna lowkey it in Lebanon. And immediately after that, BB came out to the cameras and said, 'Full force ahead.'"

Megyn Kelly
"

"I had the opportunity to take out Charlie Kirk and I took it. I don't know if I will or have succeeded, but I had hoped to make it home to you. I wish we could have lived in a world where this did not feel necessary."

Tyler Robinson (from letter)
"

"I don't give a [expletive]. Not even if you got recognized. I don't care. You know what I want? To be seen with you. Yeah. Mhm. I don't give a [expletive] about anything else. Yeah. It's time we'd be seen together. You told me you loved me, didn't you? I do love you."

Brian Gnome (from recording)
"

"I believe the two notes that we received that we responded to, I tend to believe those are real."

Savannah Guthrie
"

"This grievous and uniquely cruel injury of not knowing, of uncertainty and confusion, and answers withheld."

Savannah Guthrie
"

"This sergeant's been the supervisor of homicide for over two years. And in that time, he solved some pretty significant, very high-profile cases for this area... But you cannot attack my department. Attack the sheriff, but you will not get by with attacking my department."

Sheriff Nanos

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes