Quick Read

Police bodycam footage captures the immediate aftermath and initial interrogations of two suspects in Santa Fe, New Mexico, following the discovery of a young woman's decapitated body and a bloody sword in a detached garage.
Police found 21-year-old Grace Jennings decapitated in a garage, with a bloody sword nearby.
Suspects Kiara McCully and Isaac Apodaka, both ex-partners of the victim, offered conflicting and evasive statements.
Incriminating text messages between Kiara and Isaac detailed a premeditated murder, discussing weapons, disposal, and a 'black market' for killings.

Summary

In Santa Fe, New Mexico, officers responded to a report of a stabbing, discovering 21-year-old Grace Jennings dead and nearly decapitated in a detached garage, with a bloody sword nearby. The homeowner's daughter, 20-year-old Kiara McCully, and her ex-fiancé, 25-year-old Isaac Apodaka, were identified as suspects. Isaac initially claimed Kiara confessed to the murder, but his story quickly unraveled during interrogation as text messages between him and Kiara revealed a detailed conspiracy to kill Grace, discussing methods, weapon choice (a sword named 'Zer'), disposal, and a 'black market' ranking system for killings. Kiara, in her interrogation, claimed memory loss, multiple personalities (Abby, Jinx, Jess), and a history of anger towards Grace, suggesting Isaac encouraged her to commit the murder for 'ranking up' in a mysterious 'Ghost' organization. Kiara eventually accepted a plea deal for aggravated second-degree murder and conspiracy, agreeing to testify against Isaac, who refused a deal and is awaiting trial.
This case highlights the complexities of police investigations, especially when suspects offer conflicting narratives and claim mental health issues. The discovery of incriminating text messages provides a stark example of how digital evidence can quickly dismantle fabricated alibis and expose premeditated violence, even when suspects attempt to explain away explicit murder plots as jokes or unrelated conversations.

Takeaways

  • Officers responding to a stabbing report found 21-year-old Grace Jennings deceased and nearly decapitated in a garage.
  • A bloody sword was found near the victim's body.
  • Suspects Kiara McCully and Isaac Apodaka were identified; both had previously dated the victim, Grace.
  • Isaac initially told police Kiara confessed to the murder, stating 'I just did it' with blood on her hands.
  • Text messages between Isaac and Kiara revealed a detailed conspiracy to kill Grace, including discussions of weapons, disposal, and a 'black market' system.
  • Kiara claimed memory loss and multiple personalities, suggesting Isaac coerced her into the murder for a 'ranking up' in a 'Ghost' organization.
  • Kiara accepted a plea deal for aggravated second-degree murder and conspiracy, agreeing to testify against Isaac, who faces trial.

Insights

1Discovery of Decapitated Victim and Bloody Weapon

Police responded to a report of a stabbing and found 21-year-old Grace Jennings dead in a detached garage, her body nearly decapitated. A bloody sword was discovered lying near her.

Officers entered the garage after reports of a stabbing and found Grace Jennings. An officer stated, 'we got one down' and later, 'we got him.' The narrator confirmed Grace was 'dead and nearly decapitated, lying near a bloody sword.'

2Suspects' Conflicting Accounts and Relationship with Victim

Kiara McCully, the homeowner's daughter, and her ex-fiancé Isaac Apodaka were identified as suspects. Both had previously dated the victim, Grace Jennings. Isaac initially claimed Kiara confessed to the murder upon his entry into the garage, while Kiara later claimed memory loss and multiple personalities.

Police identified Kiara McCully () and Isaac Apodaka (). Isaac stated Kiara told him 'I just did it' with a smile (, ). Isaac also confirmed both he and Kiara had dated Grace in the past (, ). Kiara later claimed a 'chunk missing' from her memory and attributed actions to different personalities (, ).

3Incriminating Text Messages Exposing Murder Conspiracy

During Isaac's interrogation, text messages between him and Kiara were uncovered, explicitly detailing a plan to kill Grace. The messages discussed using a 'dagger' or 'Zer' (the sword), how to stab the throat, the desired speed of death ('instant'), and how to dispose of the 'mess' ('burn it'). They also referenced a 'black market' and 'ranking up' for killings.

Texts from Isaac's phone included: 'Stab her? I don't know.' (), 'dagger because it's blunt' (), 'just going to stab the throat' (), 'Instant or will it take long?' (), 'What do we do about the mess? We burn it and I'll buy new blankets in bed.' (, ). Isaac later admitted Kiara was 'messaging me on planning on how to kill her' (). Kiara also mentioned Isaac telling her 'just do it and you're gonna just just kill her. Then you'll get ranked up' ().

4Kiara's Plea Deal and Agreement to Testify

Kiara McCully accepted a plea deal, pleading guilty to aggravated second-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder. This agreement requires her to testify against Isaac Apodaka, and she faces 30 years in prison.

The narrator states: 'Kiara accepted a deal and pleaded guilty to aggravated second-degree murder and conspiracy to commit murder and an agreement that requires her to testify against Isaac. Under the deal, the now 22-year-old will face 30 years behind bars.'

Quotes

"

"We're being told that the girlfriend's in the garage. That's where she apparently killed the other 41."

Officer
"

"Once inside, officers find who they would later identify as 21-year-old Grace Jennings, dead and nearly decapitated, lying near a bloody sword."

Narrator
"

"I walked into the garage and when I walked in the garage, she goes, 'Oh, I just did it.'"

Isaac Apodaka
"

"She told you that? Very calmly and everything, blood on her hands."

Isaac Apodaka
"

"SHE'S DECEASED. ARE YOU SERIOUS? OH MY GOD. NO. NO."

Grace's Mother
"

"Kiara was messaging me on planning on how to kill her."

Isaac Apodaka
"

"I'm partially hopeful for her to be dead, but I'm also like confused."

Kiara McCully
"

"I have dreams about it all the time and I'm like, I wonder what this would look like in my brain."

Kiara McCully
"

"He kept trying to tell me just do it and you're gonna just just kill her. Then you'll get ranked up."

Kiara McCully
"

"I'm guessing I'm not getting it back. Um, probably not. We have to collect it as evidence. It was $200. Damn. Where'd you get her from? Amazon. Amazing."

Kiara McCully & Detective

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes