Am I The Ally? | Reading Reddit Stories

YouTube · UXzrjxriu94

Quick Read

This Pride episode dives into wild Reddit stories, from a man unknowingly dating his hookup's daughter to a gay man accused of fathering a child, revealing unexpected twists and social commentary.
Navigating identity and relationships can lead to hilariously awkward or deeply problematic situations.
The expectation for gay individuals to 'disclose' their sexuality to avoid others' embarrassment is a recurring social friction.
Toxic masculinity and homophobia can drive individuals to self-destructive accusations, even against gay friends.

Summary

The Smosh team, joined by Chance and Jared Goldstein, celebrates Pride by reading a series of Reddit stories centered around LGBTQ+ themes and unexpected social dilemmas. Stories include a man who accidentally dated the daughter of a man he hooked up with, a gay man criticized for not disclosing his sexuality to flirting women in a professional setting, a boss's awkward reaction to an employee coming out that leads to a surprising family connection, a woman oblivious to a school nurse's persistent flirting, and a homophobic husband who blames his gay friend for his child's red hair. The episode concludes with a humorous tale of a company-wide meeting interrupted by a 'poop' emergency.
This episode highlights the diverse and often complex social dynamics surrounding LGBTQ+ identity, relationships, and workplace interactions. It underscores the importance of empathy, challenges preconceived notions about sexuality, and exposes the absurdity of certain biases, all while providing comedic relief through relatable (and sometimes outrageous) human experiences.

Takeaways

  • A man's past hookup with an older bisexual man leads to an incredibly awkward encounter when he later dates the man's daughter, who is then told to break up with him so her father can pursue the OP.
  • A gay man is labeled an 'asshole' by women for not disclosing his sexuality while they flirted with him in a professional setting, sparking debate on disclosure obligations.
  • A boss's initially awkward, business-focused reaction to an employee coming out as gay ultimately leads to the employee becoming engaged to the boss's brother.
  • A doctor's obliviousness to a school nurse's obvious flirting during a visit for her niece's injury highlights how easily romantic cues can be missed.
  • A homophobic husband destroys his marriage by accusing his gay friend of fathering his red-headed daughter, demonstrating extreme narcissism and a lack of understanding of genetics.

Insights

1The Unforeseen Consequences of Past Hookups

A Reddit user recounts hooking up with an older bisexual man, only to later discover he is the father of a woman he starts dating. The situation escalates when the father comes out to his family and tells his daughter to break up with the OP so he can pursue him, leading to accusations of 'turning him gay' and a dramatic breakup.

The story details the initial hookup, the subsequent dating of the daughter, the park encounter where the OP meets the father, and the daughter's furious reaction after her father's confession and attempt to pursue the OP. The hosts emphasize the impossibility of the relationship continuing.

2No Obligation to Disclose Sexuality in Professional Settings

A gay man delivering work for his father is flirted with by several women at an office. He doesn't disclose his sexuality, leading the women to call him an 'asshole' for 'embarrassing' them. The hosts and Reddit comments affirm that he had no obligation to disclose his sexual orientation, especially in a professional context.

The OP states he doesn't 'actively mentioning it or broadcasting it because it's literally nobody's business' (). His father defends him, stating he 'had no obligation to disclose I was gay' (). Comments reinforce that his sexuality is 'nobody else's business unless you choose to share the information' ().

3Awkward Coming Out Leads to Unexpected Family Connection

A boss reacts awkwardly when an employee comes out as gay, initially asking about marketing demographics and marriage plans. While criticized for his 'assholeish' responses, a follow-up conversation, prompted by Reddit advice, leads the boss to introduce the employee to his adopted brother, who also recently came out. They eventually become engaged.

The OP's initial responses included asking 'if he had any insights in marketing to that demographic' () and 'if he was getting married and needed time off' (). The update reveals that after a follow-up conversation, the OP connected the employee (H) with his adopted brother (Jay), and 'I never imagined they would start dating and become engaged' ().

4Obliviousness to Flirting: A Doctor and a Nurse's Story

A doctor, picking up her niece from school, is completely oblivious to the school nurse's persistent and increasingly direct flirting after the niece gets a minor injury. The doctor only realizes the nurse's intentions after posting on Reddit and receiving comments pointing out the obvious flirting, eventually leading to a date.

The nurse's comments include 'why I didn't say anything about this' (), 'I still owed her for not telling her my job' (), and 'she'd never be able to guess my line of work correctly because I look better than most of my colleagues' (). The update confirms, 'I was absolutely clueless during the whole interaction and missed the flirting part altogether' (), and 'We went on a date last night' ().

5Narcissism and Homophobia Destroy a Marriage

A man's extreme narcissism and ignorance of genetics lead him to accuse his gay friend of fathering his red-headed daughter, simply because she doesn't resemble him as much as his sons. This baseless accusation, fueled by homophobia, results in his wife filing for divorce and the OP having to take a paternity test to clear his name.

Robert 'kept going on about how his jeans would prevail' () and 'knows Chelsea isn't his' (). He points at the OP, yelling at him to 'get my ass outside' () despite the OP being gay with a male fiancé (). Danielle 'is filing for divorce' () due to Robert's accusations. The hosts note his 'stupid' and 'dangerous' behavior (, ).

Quotes

"

"Lo and behold, her daddy is the dude that was calling me daddy a few weeks back."

Reddit OP
"

"He knows I've been trying to kiss ass to avoid his beat down. I'm gay. I have a male fiance. I have pride stickers all over my car. Outside of work, I am a parrot of colorfulness."

Reddit OP
"

"My butt isn't trying to hurt anyone's feelings. And I like heard my butt fart and it was like cuz you know you feel shame for farting and for burping and like oh everyone's pissing everyone off and I'm gross. I went, 'My butt doesn't know.'"

Jared Goldstein

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

Tracy Morgan Claims He Is the King of New York and Started the Riverboat Brawl, Talks Reggie Dinkins
A Closer Look - Late Night with Seth MeyersApr 1, 2026

Tracy Morgan Claims He Is the King of New York and Started the Riverboat Brawl, Talks Reggie Dinkins

"Tracy Morgan delivers a masterclass in comedic chaos, claiming to be Jacques Cousteau's grandson, the 'King of New York,' and the instigator of the infamous Alabama riverboat brawl."

ComedyTracy MorganNew York City+2
LIVING SINGLE (1996) 4x4, 4x5 & 4x6 REACTION! | First Time Watch | Queen Latifah
CinePalsFeb 7, 2026

LIVING SINGLE (1996) 4x4, 4x5 & 4x6 REACTION! | First Time Watch | Queen Latifah

"CinePals reacts to three 'Living Single' episodes, covering Flavor magazine's corporate acquisition, Reene's controversial jury duty, Maxine's aggressive dating tactics, and Sinclair and Overton's disastrous compatibility test."

Living Single90s sitcom
Joe Rogan Experience #2513 - Dean Radin
The Joe Rogan ExperienceJun 11, 2026

Joe Rogan Experience #2513 - Dean Radin

"Dean Radin, a leading parapsychologist, reveals decades of scientific research into psychic phenomena, government programs like Stargate, and groundbreaking genetic studies suggesting a biological basis for intuition and consciousness, challenging materialistic views of reality."

ParapsychologyConsciousnessRemote Viewing+2
Squirm Happens || Uncomfortable Reddit Stories || Two Hot Takes Podcast
Two Hot TakesJun 11, 2026

Squirm Happens || Uncomfortable Reddit Stories || Two Hot Takes Podcast

"Hosts Sarah Sherman and the Two Hot Takes crew dive into a series of Reddit's most squirm-inducing stories, from a horror-themed doormat dispute to a boyfriend with a secret feeding kink and a partner who faked her husband's death."

Reddit StoriesNeighbor DisputesInfidelity+2