Ep 608 - WrestleMania (feat. Cody Rhodes)
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Dusty Rhodes's 'common man' plumber persona was a crafted narrative; his father was a successful non-union plumber.
- ❖Wrestling catchphrases and moves are 'owned' by whoever 'gets them over' and makes them famous, like Hulk Hogan's 'Hulkup.'
- ❖Cody Rhodes developed an unexpected loyalty to the Philadelphia Eagles after their crowd passionately supported him during a match.
- ❖The 'nepo baby' label is embraced by Rhodes as 'bringing glory to the house' of his wrestling family.
- ❖Wrestling training has evolved from self-driven passion (OVW) to structured, multi-faceted performance centers (NXT) focusing on agility and recovery.
- ❖The WWE wellness policy since 2007 has shifted the industry away from a pure bodybuilding aesthetic towards more diverse body types and athleticism, reducing 'juicing.'
- ❖Cody Rhodes maintains an 'I don't know him' stance on Pat McAfee's involvement in WrestleMania, viewing it as an interesting, perhaps out-of-place, celebrity insertion.
Insights
1The 'American Dream' Persona vs. Reality
Cody Rhodes reveals that his father, Dusty Rhodes, known as 'The American Dream' and 'the plumber's son,' crafted a narrative of humble beginnings. While his grandfather was a plumber, he was a successful non-union plumber, not 'down on their luck' as the wrestling lore suggested. This highlights the intentional construction of wrestling personas for audience connection.
My dad was like his pride and joy. You see all these pictures of him in like full-blown brand new cowboy outfits... they weren't super super rich or anything like that, but it's funny to hear the the story as it's told later in my dad's career because, you know, I'm the common man. Dad, you know, dad was a plumber. I came up on the streets.
2The 'Getting Over' Rule in Wrestling
In wrestling, credit for a move or catchphrase goes to 'whoever got it over,' meaning whoever made it famous and widely recognized, rather than its original creator. This principle allows for adaptation and popularization within the industry.
More wrestling the rule is whoever got it over, whoever made it famous it becomes theirs... Prime example, Hulk Hogan's Hulkup. Every wrestling baby face pretty much used to do the hit you. Nope, not anymore. And they'd start coming back... he made it such a big thing, the Hulk up was so the fingerpoint that nobody else could do it anymore.
3Evolution of Wrestling Training and Wellness
Cody contrasts his early training at OVW, which involved self-driven passion and peer learning, with the modern WWE NXT Performance Center. The current system is highly structured, offering agility training, multiple rings (including padded ones for high spots), recovery suites, and top coaches like Shawn Michaels. The WWE's wellness policy, implemented since 2007, has also shifted the focus from bodybuilding and 'juicing' to overall athleticism and diverse body types.
Today it's all They've got it all mapped out really well. They've got exactly what you mentioned. They've got agility. They've got multiple rings... They've got Shawn Michaels... The system they have down down there with the performance center now is designed for the NIL athlete... the bodybuilding aspect of it, because since 2007, they've the wellness policy is there.
4The Nuance of Celebrity Integration in Wrestling
Cody Rhodes expresses a nuanced, somewhat critical view of Pat McAfee's involvement in a WrestleMania storyline, particularly when it intersects with established, deep-seated rivalries like his own with Randy Orton. He suggests McAfee's approach, including wearing shades and referencing the 'Attitude Era' (nearly 30 years old), feels out of sync with the current, thriving era of wrestling. This highlights the challenge of integrating external celebrities without disrupting existing narratives or disrespecting the contemporary product.
Randy Orton, who I'm wrestling at Wrestlemania, we have like almost two decades of history... and then we inserted uh Pat McAfee... everyone around Pat McAfee his orbit probably someone needs to say no every now and then... looking up and he's wearing shades... It's a different era of wrestling. It was like watching a guy at a bar do like a stone cold impression... I heard him talk about the attitude era and I'm thinking oh man I don't think he knows almost 30 years ago almost so love it and it was the most prolific era in the business until the last four years. So, if you're part of the last four years, you kind of feel like, why are we talking about this?
Bottom Line
The 'Springsteen' phenomenon describes individuals who intentionally portray themselves as more working-class or humble than their actual background, often to connect with a broader audience or maintain a certain image.
This behavior, observed in figures like Dusty Rhodes, reveals a strategic use of narrative to build relatability and appeal, even if it deviates from personal reality.
Marketers and public figures can leverage this understanding to craft authentic (or perceived as authentic) narratives that resonate with target demographics, recognizing the power of a 'common man' story.
Cody Rhodes embraces the 'nepo baby' label, reframing it as bringing 'glory to the house' of his wrestling family, rather than a sign of unearned privilege.
This contrarian perspective challenges the negative connotation of nepotism, suggesting that inherited opportunities can be used to elevate a family legacy through hard work and success.
Individuals from established families in any industry can adopt this mindset to transform perceived disadvantages into a source of pride and motivation, focusing on contribution rather than origin.
Lessons
- When crafting a public persona, understand the power of narrative to connect with an audience, even if it requires simplifying or adjusting personal history.
- To succeed in a competitive field like entertainment, focus on 'getting your act over' – making your unique contribution famous and memorable, rather than just being the originator.
- For those managing talent, recognize the importance of structured development and wellness programs (like NXT's Performance Center) to cultivate well-rounded athletes and performers.
- When integrating external celebrities into an established brand or narrative, ensure their presence aligns with the current identity and history of the brand to avoid alienating core audiences.
Notable Moments
Cody Rhodes recounts his father, Dusty Rhodes, using the 'Big Fish' movie analogy to describe how many of his larger-than-life stories turned out to have elements of truth after his passing.
This illustrates the blend of reality and myth-making inherent in wrestling personas and family legacies, where stories grow and evolve but retain a core authenticity.
Cody describes the 'super old man thing' he does at the beach: arriving early to secure chairs, placing items on them to mark territory, and engaging in conversations about mundane topics like tides with older men.
This humorous anecdote highlights the universal desire for small moments of peace and control, especially for parents of young children, and the unexpected ways people find community in shared, simple routines.
Quotes
"My dad was like his pride and joy. You see all these pictures of him in like full-blown brand new cowboy outfits and like the red wagon and everything. I mean, they weren't super super rich or anything like that, but it's funny to hear the the story as it's told later in my dad's career because, you know, I'm the common man. Dad, you know, dad was a plumber. I came up on the streets."
"Wrestling has more than one royal family, and it's all about, you know, the Harts, the McMahon's, the Guerrero, and finally getting a little, hey, the roads are here, dude. You know, we're going to run this score up. [ __ ] yeah. That's what I'm talking about. I I think that's awesome. You hear people like It's like, dude, tell your dad to do better, man."
"I'm just gonna stick with the I don't know him but this is my as u is I heard him again getting my ass kicked I heard him talk about the attitude era and I'm thinking oh man I don't think he knows almost 30 years ago almost so love it and it was the most prolific era in the business until the last four years. So, if you're part of the last four years, you kind of feel like, why are we talking about this?"
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes

Seth Rollins On WWE, CM Punk Beef, Bad Bunny, Ronda Rousey, The Rock, Logan Paul I CLUB SHAY SHAY
"WWE superstar Seth Rollins details his arduous journey from backyard wrestling to global fame, offering candid insights into the industry's evolution, the psychology of character work, and navigating complex personal and professional relationships."

Game 2 of the That's Baseball World Classic Yug Off | The Yak 3-13-26
"Barstool's 'That's Baseball World Classic Yug Off' continues with Game 2, featuring controversial referee calls, unexpected halftime entertainment, and a dramatic, beer-fueled showdown."

The Pat McAfee Show Live | Monday April 13th 2026
"This episode dives into the unique, phone-free experience of the Masters, the dramatic NBA power struggles involving Giannis Antetokounmpo and the 65-game rule, and the evolving landscape of the NFL with international expansion and draft-day trades."

Unc & Ocho IN TEARS at Gary Owen detailing his HOUSTON TWERK wedding for the ages! | Nightcap
"Comedian Gary Owen recounts his unconventional Houston wedding, his unique path from the Navy to stand-up, and his surprising success as a white comedian on BET."