Why Nancy Guthrie suspect went silent, what is next for Sheriff Nanos - day 88 since disappearance
YouTube · Y1TDO33_nko
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖The Nancy Guthrie disappearance case is at a standstill 88 days in, with no suspects or major breakthroughs.
- ❖The theory that Nancy Guthrie is deceased and the Bitcoin ransom was a cover-up is gaining traction among experts.
- ❖Pima County Sheriff Nanos is under fire for allegedly lying under oath and failing to provide sworn statements to the Board of Supervisors, potentially leading to his removal.
- ❖The Sheriff's leadership is described as 'toxic,' leading to a mass exodus of experienced officers and poor relationships with other law enforcement agencies.
- ❖Volunteer search efforts by groups like the CA United Cinjun Navy are being ignored by the Sheriff's department, attributed to ego and a 'we can do it ourselves' mentality.
- ❖Despite the leadership issues, the on-the-ground investigators are working diligently, but the department's internal climate affects morale.
Insights
1Nancy Guthrie Case Stalled with Cover-Up Theory
After 88 days, the Nancy Guthrie disappearance case has no significant developments or suspects. Retired Lieutenant Bob Kger, aligning with FBI profiler theories, believes Nancy is likely deceased and the low-value Bitcoin ransom was a cover-up to mislead investigators, suggesting the perpetrators went silent early on.
Host's source close to investigation reports 'dead ends' (). Bob Kger states 'nothing new' (). Kger's opinion: Nancy is 'probably deceased' (), and the ransom was a 'cover up' due to its small amount (). FBI profilers suggest the suspect knew Nancy ().
2Sheriff Nanos Faces Removal for Alleged Misconduct
Pima County Sheriff Nanos is facing potential removal from office by the Board of Supervisors for failing to provide sworn statements as required and for allegedly lying under oath about multiple past suspensions during a deposition. This conduct, according to Bob Kger, demonstrates a failure of leadership and ethical breaches.
Sheriff's responses to Board of Supervisors were not sworn (). Bob Kger states Sheriff 'lied under oath' about 'multiple suspensions back in El Paso' () and 'absolutely failed as a leader' (). This violation of statute gives the Board the 'ability to remove him' ().
3Toxic Leadership and Hindered Cooperation in Pima County Sheriff's Department
Sheriff Nanos's leadership style is characterized as 'toxic,' leading to a significant loss of experienced personnel who left for other agencies, often taking demotions. His alleged ego also results in poor relationships with federal and local law enforcement, hindering crucial inter-agency cooperation and the acceptance of external help for cases like Nancy Guthrie's.
Morale was 'in the tank' before the Guthrie case (). Hundreds of years of experience 'walked away' due to 'leadership' (). Sheriff has 'very poor relationships with most local law enforcement agencies, horrible relationships with the feds' (). Emails revealed experienced homicide/cold case supervisors were moved out ().
4Sheriff's Ego Blocks Volunteer Search Efforts
The Pima County Sheriff's department has not engaged with the CA United Cinjun Navy, a volunteer search organization, despite their offer to conduct desert searches for Nancy Guthrie. Bob Kger attributes this lack of cooperation to the Sheriff's ego and a 'this is my county, I don't need help' mentality, even though such efforts could yield valuable evidence for various cases.
CA United Cinjun Navy's proposal for searching received 'no response from the sheriff' (). Bob Kger states 'it can't hurt' to engage them () and blames 'ego' for the lack of cooperation, similar to how the FBI was 'pushed off early on' ().
Lessons
- Pima County residents should monitor the Board of Supervisors' actions regarding Sheriff Nanos's alleged misconduct and demand accountability for ethical breaches.
- Advocate for increased inter-agency cooperation in high-profile cases by contacting local officials, emphasizing that solving cases should transcend departmental egos.
- Support and promote volunteer search organizations, as their efforts can provide crucial leads and closure, even if not directly related to the primary case.
Notable Moments
Bob Kger's strong condemnation of Sheriff Nanos's conduct, including lying under oath and fostering a toxic environment.
This provides a direct, experienced insider's perspective on the severe leadership issues within the Pima County Sheriff's Department, framing the context for the stalled investigation and lack of external cooperation.
The revelation that the Sheriff's department ignored offers from the CA United Cinjun Navy to conduct desert searches.
This highlights a critical missed opportunity for potentially advancing the Nancy Guthrie case or other cold cases, underscoring the negative impact of the department's insular approach.
Quotes
"I think that the folks who did this quickly pivoted... he's probably deceased probably passed away at this point and once that happened I think it changed their plans and you know calling them good bad guys they just went silent on it and started focusing on something else."
"If the answer is eight and you say never, that's a flatout lie. That was in a lawsuit. There is no way to come back from that. He should be on a Brady list through our our uh county attorney's office."
"Most officers leave their agency for one reason and that's leadership. Um and and it's toxic. It is that that's the the best way to put it within the department."
"It doesn't matter who gets that. Whether it's the Cinjun Navy, the FBI, ATF, an alien crashing and finding her. It doesn't matter. However we get there, however they get there, that's what's most important."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
New ransom note claims to know where Nancy Guthrie is — but is it real? Day 65 in the search
"A new ransom note surfaces on the day Savannah Guthrie returns to work, raising questions about its authenticity and the ongoing, politically fraught investigation into Nancy Guthrie's disappearance."
Breaking: Location of Blood Inside Nancy Guthrie's Home Revealed | Nancy Guthrie Missing Update
"New forensic details reveal Nancy Guthrie's blood was found inside her home's front entrance, extending outside, indicating a stationary bleeding event, while Sheriff Nanos faces a no-confidence vote for his handling of the investigation."
Nancy Guthrie Detective Reveals Chilling New Theory
"Investigators in the Nancy Guthrie disappearance are leveraging cutting-edge genetic genealogy and advanced surveillance tech, revealing new theories about a targeted crime and the suspect's amateur yet elusive tactics."
Jealous Cop Threatens to Burn Ex-Boyfriend's House Down
"An award-winning police officer's career ends after she breaks into her ex-boyfriend's home, smashes his door, threatens arson, and resists arrest, all captured on bodycam footage."