You Should Know Podcast
You Should Know Podcast
March 2, 2026

WE BECAME WWE SUPERSTARS! -You Should Know Podcast- Episode 206

Quick Read

The hosts recount their surreal experience interviewing WWE superstars at the WWE headquarters, blending their signature chaotic banter with genuine insights from wrestling legends on career longevity, character development, and fan engagement.
The hosts secured exclusive interviews with WWE superstars at their headquarters, a dream come true for wrestling fans.
Wrestlers like Drew McIntyre and CM Punk shared candid insights on career development, fan connection, and overcoming adversity.
The episode is packed with the hosts' signature chaotic humor, including a bizarre geography debate and a failed riddle challenge.

Summary

The episode opens with hosts Payton and Cam sharing chaotic personal anecdotes, including a bizarre debate about East Coast geography, Payton's unusual habit of sleeping with windows open in New York City, and embarrassing encounters with Ronnie 2K and Mark Henry. The core of the episode revolves around their trip to WWE headquarters to interview top superstars for the WWE 2K26 game. They discuss the surreal experience of meeting their childhood idols and extract valuable career insights from Blake Monroe, Drew McIntyre, Paul Heyman, Jacob Fatu, Iyo Sky, and CM Punk, covering topics from in-ring intensity and promo skills to navigating the demanding travel schedule and building a lasting legacy. The hosts reflect on the blend of personal passion and professional opportunity this unique partnership represents.
This episode offers a rare, unfiltered look into the world of WWE through the eyes of two non-traditional interviewers, providing both humorous behind-the-scenes stories and direct career advice from wrestling's elite. It highlights the intersection of personal branding, media partnerships, and the dedication required to succeed in a high-stakes entertainment industry, offering insights applicable to content creators and professionals alike.

Takeaways

  • The hosts secured a major partnership with WWE for interviews related to the WWE 2K26 game.
  • Payton and Cam experienced significant personal 'fails' during their trip, including being unrecognized by a mentor and a celebrity's disgusted reaction.
  • WWE superstars shared insights on character development, promo skills, and the physical/mental demands of professional wrestling.
  • Paul Heyman emphasized strategic, unemotional decision-making for career longevity and maximizing profit.
  • Several wrestlers highlighted the importance of connecting with the audience and continuously improving their craft.
  • The hosts debated U.S. geography, Payton's unusual sleeping habits, and Cam's urgent need for anti-diarrhea medication.

Insights

1The Journey to WWE Championship and Responsibility

Drew McIntyre detailed his challenging path to becoming WWE Champion, including winning the title during the pandemic in an empty arena. He felt a profound responsibility to provide an escape for fans during an unpredictable time, which overshadowed his personal enjoyment of the achievement. He emphasized that continuous improvement in promos, matches, and physical conditioning was key to finally securing the championship with live fans present.

Drew McIntyre's account of his championship reigns and the years of effort and setbacks leading to his current success.

2Importance of Standing Out in Professional Wrestling

Drew McIntyre advised aspiring wrestlers to find their 'it factor' beyond just physical prowess. He stressed the need to put in extra effort in character, in-ring ability, and overall presence to captivate an audience and turn heads, even if one doesn't fit the traditional 'superstar' mold.

McIntyre's advice: 'Figure out what's going to take you to the next level because it took me long enough to do it... figure it out.'

3Paul Heyman's Strategic, Long-Term Vision

Paul Heyman articulated his approach to the wrestling business, focusing on strategic, unemotional decision-making to maximize benefits for himself and the talent he manages. He emphasized understanding audience desires not just for the current event but for future Wrestlemanias, planning years in advance to transcend the current landscape.

Heyman's statement: 'I don't let emotions play into that. I'm investing in companies that maximize profit for their shareholders.' and his planning for Wrestlemania 2028.

4Overcoming Language Barriers in Promos

Iyo Sky identified promos as the hardest aspect of wrestling to master due to her language barrier. She highlighted the challenge of memorizing lines, conveying emotion, and speaking in a second language, but also found inspiration in being a role model for others learning English, demonstrating that authenticity can transcend linguistic perfection.

Iyo Sky's explanation: 'Promo makes me so nervous. Also I have to remember about the line... and I have to speak in second language that is so hardest part.'

5CM Punk's Fight for Authenticity and Legacy

CM Punk described his first WWE 2K cover as a 'fight' with management, while his current cover was a recognition of his undeniable status. He emphasized that his current run is about seizing opportunities, creating memorable moments, and telling emotional stories, rather than solely focusing on legacy, as 'we all die' and will eventually be 'reduced to just a dude who wrestled.'

Punk's comparison of his two 2K covers and his philosophy on legacy: 'I just want to tell the best stories. I want to make people emotional about the things I do.'

Bottom Line

The podcast hosts, despite being non-wrestling media, gained unique access to WWE superstars, highlighting the value of an established, authentic online personality even outside a niche.

So What?

This demonstrates that major brands are increasingly open to diverse media partnerships, prioritizing reach and genuine connection over strict industry alignment.

Impact

Content creators in any niche can leverage their unique voice and audience to secure unexpected brand collaborations, expanding their reach and offering fresh perspectives to established industries.

Drew McIntyre's 'stop playing the wrestler, be the wrestler' advice applies broadly to personal branding and professional presence, emphasizing authenticity over performance.

So What?

Many professionals struggle with 'imposter syndrome' or trying to fit a mold. This insight suggests that embracing one's true self, even with flaws, can lead to deeper engagement and success.

Impact

Individuals can focus on developing their authentic voice and presence in their respective fields, rather than mimicking perceived 'successful' personas, to build stronger, more resonant connections.

Key Concepts

Stop Playing the Wrestler, Be the Wrestler

Drew McIntyre, reflecting on advice from The Undertaker, explains that true connection with an audience comes from authentic self-expression rather than merely performing a character. This means being present, knowing who you are, and allowing that genuine self to come through in your performance, rather than just 'doing the moves.'

Strategic Emotional Detachment

Paul Heyman advocates for making business decisions based purely on analytical assessment and maximizing profit, rather than emotional attachment. He applies this to talent management and long-term strategic planning in the wrestling industry, viewing emotions as a hindrance to optimal outcomes.

Adversity Defines Character

Paul Heyman posits that facing and overcoming adversity is crucial for any top act to prove themselves. He uses Roman Reigns and CM Punk as examples, suggesting that their struggles and eventual triumphs solidified their authentic characters and earned audience acknowledgment.

Lessons

  • Prioritize authenticity in your public persona; as Drew McIntyre advises, 'stop playing the wrestler, be the wrestler' to foster genuine connection.
  • Continuously seek self-improvement in all aspects of your craft, from technical skills to communication, as exemplified by top WWE talent like Drew McIntyre and Iyo Sky.
  • Embrace unexpected opportunities for collaboration, even if they seem outside your traditional niche, as the hosts did with WWE, to expand your brand and reach new audiences.

Notable Moments

Payton's bizarre geography lesson where he claimed New Jersey is part of New York and that East Coast states should be one 'territory.'

This segment showcased the hosts' signature comedic, often uninformed, banter that defines their podcast's entertainment value, contrasting sharply with the professional interviews later.

Payton's awkward encounters with Ronnie 2K and Mark Henry, where Ronnie looked 'disgusted' and Mark Henry, a former mentor, didn't recognize him.

These moments provided humorous, self-deprecating insight into the hosts' 'imposter syndrome' and the sometimes-harsh reality of celebrity interactions, grounding their extraordinary WWE access with relatable human experiences.

Cam's urgent need for anti-diarrhea medication before the WWE interviews, which Payton had to purchase for him at a bodega.

A highly specific and humorous anecdote that highlights the hosts' willingness to share personal, embarrassing moments, reinforcing their authentic and unscripted podcast style.

Payton's revelation that he sleeps with his windows and balcony door open, even in a New York City high-rise, for 'natural air' and 'brown noise.'

This quirky habit further illustrates Payton's unconventional personality and provides a comedic point of contention with Cam, showcasing their dynamic.

The hosts' failed attempt to solve a bridge riddle, demonstrating their comedic struggle with logical puzzles.

This segment served as a lighthearted interlude, emphasizing the entertainment-first nature of the podcast before diving into the more serious interviews.

Quotes

"

"I'm not a good guy. I'm not a bad guy. I say exactly how I feel. Tell the truth and people don't like the truth a lot."

Drew McIntyre
"

"I don't let emotions play into that. I'm investing in companies that maximize profit for their shareholders."

Paul Heyman
"

"When I'm dead, I don't think anyone I'll be reduced to just, oh, he's a dude who wrestled."

CM Punk
"

"I just want to tell the best stories. I want to make people emotional about the things I do."

CM Punk

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes