NOW THIS WHAT THEY CALL MUSIC | ENGLISH MAJORS | SEASON 3 | EP 05
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Modern music is often criticized for being too short (under 3 minutes) to maximize streaming plays, leading to repetitive structures.
- ❖The rise of short-form content platforms like TikTok has shifted dancing from prolonged movement to brief, choreographed "routines."
- ❖The concept of "offbeat" rapping is a point of contention, with some arguing it's a new style requiring "trained ears," while others see it as a decline in quality.
- ❖The "no pen, no pad" trend in rap, popularized by artists like Lil Wayne, is viewed as a misinterpretation of Jay-Z's original method of memorizing written lyrics.
- ❖Artist promotion has evolved from focusing on music releases to requiring constant "antics" and engagement with streamers to stay relevant.
- ❖Political roles like "Labor Commissioner" suffer from low voter engagement due to generic titles and a lack of clear communication about their direct impact.
- ❖The phrase "good and nice" is humorously proposed as a universally effective marketing slogan for any product or service.
Insights
1Generational Divide in Music Standards
The hosts highlight a significant gap in how different generations perceive musical quality, particularly regarding rhythm and song structure. Older listeners prioritize being "on beat" and longer, more substantial songs, while younger audiences are more accepting of "offbeat" flows and shorter tracks, often justifying it as a new style that requires "trained ears."
For this generation to not even care whether a [expletive] on beat or offbeat is just strange to me... Cuz when we was coming up, even if you was freestyling with your homeboy, if a [expletive] was off beat, you got to [expletive] hold on now. () You gotta train your ears. Take like three times. You gotta listen to the bit like like it might like now like I I definitely understand that music back in the day was was so was so good that it didn't take all that but you just listen to it maybe three times. ()
2The Economics of Short-Form Music and "Antics"
The hosts argue that contemporary music is intentionally made shorter (around 2-3 minutes) to maximize streaming revenue, as artists get paid per play. This trend also influences dance culture, shifting from prolonged, expressive dancing to short, routine-based movements suitable for platforms like TikTok. Artists are also pressured to engage in constant "antics" for visibility, often at the expense of musical depth.
The songs got to be three minutes cuz they got to maximize how many plays they can get... you get three plays and now you double up and now you get more plays cuz they got to hear it back. () It make for it make for tick tockable music, I guess. Like it it effective the dances. Ain't even no dances. Nobody dance for prolonged periods of time, man. [expletive] do little routines. () Now, man, you got to be out 24/7. You got to be antics. It's more antics than music. ()
3Rebranding Obscure Political Roles for Voter Engagement
A candidate for Georgia Labor Commissioner highlights the public's lack of awareness about her office's functions. The hosts suggest that generic, formal titles for political roles contribute to voter invisibility. They propose rebranding these roles with more direct, relatable names (e.g., "Job Getter") and communicating their impact in a way that directly addresses common public concerns (e.g., employment and worker rights).
Why do you think roles like labor commissioner are so invisible to voters? And how can we get people to pay attention before they're directly impacted? () Maybe call the [expletive] something else... Hey, what's up y'all? I'm the job getter. I get jobs. () If you not unemployed, you're not looking at unemployment. If you ain't never had to be on unemployment, then you don't know what it does for people. ()
Bottom Line
The phrase "good and nice" possesses universal marketing appeal, capable of rebranding and revitalizing any product or service, regardless of its original quality or market position.
This highlights the power of simple, positive, and memorable messaging in consumer perception, suggesting that emotional resonance can often outweigh detailed product descriptions.
Businesses, especially those with struggling brands or niche products, could explore extremely simplified, universally positive slogans to re-engage audiences and create unexpected virality.
The perception of a rapper's "no pen, no pad" freestyle ability is often a misinterpretation of a disciplined memorization technique, rather than pure improvisation.
This reveals a disconnect between public perception and the reality of artistic craft, where a perceived "natural talent" might actually be the result of rigorous mental practice.
Artists can leverage this perception gap, either by cultivating the illusion of effortless creation or by transparently sharing their unique creative processes to inspire a deeper appreciation for their work.
Opportunities
"Job Getter" Political Rebranding Service
A consulting service for political candidates in obscure roles (like Labor Commissioner) to rebrand their titles and public messaging with direct, relatable, and impactful language that clearly communicates their function and benefits to the average voter, focusing on immediate concerns like employment and worker rights.
"Good and Nice" Universal Slogan Campaign Agency
An advertising agency specializing in creating viral, simplistic marketing campaigns centered around the universally positive phrase "good and nice" for a diverse range of products, from beverages to cleaning supplies, capitalizing on its unexpected charm and memorability to boost brand recognition and sales.
Key Concepts
Train Your Ears
This model suggests that appreciating modern, unconventional music (e.g., offbeat rapping) requires listeners to "train their ears" to a different standard or quality, implying that what might initially sound "off" is simply a new artistic approach that demands multiple listens to fully grasp.
Antic Maniac
This model describes the modern artist's need to constantly engage in public "antics" and maintain a 24/7 online presence, often overshadowing their musical output, to stay relevant and visible in a saturated digital landscape.
Lessons
- When evaluating new music, consider listening multiple times to "train your ears" to different rhythmic and lyrical approaches before dismissing it as "offbeat."
- For public-facing roles, especially in politics, prioritize clear, direct, and benefit-oriented language in titles and communications to ensure voters understand the impact of the position.
- Recognize that an artist's perceived "freestyle" ability might stem from extensive memorization and practice rather than spontaneous creation, challenging the "no pen, no pad" myth.
Notable Moments
The hosts recount Trick Daddy's dramatic, yet comically flawed, entrance from the ceiling at a BET Awards show, highlighting the pressure for artists to create memorable live spectacles.
This illustrates the emphasis on visual "antics" and elaborate stagecraft in live performances, sometimes at the expense of smooth execution, as artists strive for viral moments.
The accidental discovery and subsequent comedic application of the phrase "good and nice" as a universally effective marketing slogan for various products.
This moment humorously underscores the power of simple, positive, and memorable branding, suggesting that emotional appeal can sometimes be more potent than complex messaging.
Quotes
"You too big for all that, man. Let's normalize saying that people again. Somewhere it became fat shaming and body shaming. No, it's the [expletive] truth."
"Now, man, you got to be out 24/7. You got to be antics. It's more antics than music."
"If you thought about it and you said it and it's recorded, it's written."
"You ain't got no hoes cuz you don't work. That's how you can help the labor commission. You got to get different. You got to think outside the box."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
Justin Timberlake Didn’t Want This Out
"A former diehard Justin Timberlake fan dissects his recent DUI bodycam footage, arguing that his celebrity privilege and refusal to 'eat it' made a minor incident appear worse."
Hell On Wheels: The Teen Who Killed Her Boyfriend and Friend
"A seemingly tragic early morning car crash that killed two young men, Dominic Russo and DaVon Flanigan, was revealed to be a deliberate act of aggravated murder by the 17-year-old driver, Mackenzie Sharilla, exposing a history of volatile behavior and a shocking lack of remorse."
STILL SIPPIN W/ POUR MINDS, KARLOUS MILLER & MONEYBAG MAFIA | 85 SOUTH SHOW
"The 85 South Show hosts and guests Poor Minds and Moneybag Mafia engage in a hilariously unfiltered discussion covering relationship dynamics, unexpected business ventures, and the pervasive influence of TikTok, all while sharing their unique perspectives on life's absurdities."
Tracy Morgan Claims He Is the King of New York and Started the Riverboat Brawl, Talks Reggie Dinkins
"Tracy Morgan delivers a masterclass in comedic chaos, claiming to be Jacques Cousteau's grandson, the 'King of New York,' and the instigator of the infamous Alabama riverboat brawl."