UT v. Kouri Richins - Trial Day 9 - Wild Recorded Calls and It's Bestie Day.
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Kouri Richins consulted a divorce attorney in May 2021, but ceased communication by January 2022, around the time she began other 'conversations'.
- ❖A returned retainer check of $5,200 to Kouri from the law firm was dated January 10, 2022.
- ❖A jail call from December 18, 2023, revealed Kouri discussing her divorce attorney, claiming Eric 'illegally transferred everything' and expressing annoyance at being portrayed negatively.
- ❖Neighbor Becky Lloyd testified that Kouri expressed feeling 'trapped' in her marriage and stated it 'would be better if he were dead' in December 2021.
- ❖The defense attempted to impeach Becky Lloyd by highlighting that she didn't mention the 'better off dead' comment in her first interview with a private investigator in April 2022, only in a second interview in March 2024.
- ❖Diner owner Gabriel Morren confirmed Kouri purchased a bagel sandwich and Greek omelette on Valentine's Day 2022, picked up at 9:07 AM, which the defense tried to frame as a potential source of food poisoning.
- ❖Friend Chelsea Barney testified that Kouri told her about taking out a $250,000 home equity line of credit in October 2020, leading to Eric cutting off her credit cards.
- ❖Text messages between Kouri and Chelsea Barney from October 14, 2020, show Kouri saying, 'If I die, Eric did it,' and expressing concern about Eric hiring a PI.
- ❖Chelsea Barney lost her life savings ($45,000 cash from tips) and was evicted from a house she believed she bought from Kouri, as Kouri never filed the deed and later used the property as collateral for another loan.
- ❖Text messages from June 6, 2022, show Kouri expressing relief and excitement over the medical examiner's report stating 'manner of death undetermined,' and misrepresenting the findings about fentanyl and Eric's lungs.
- ❖A recorded phone call from March 19, 2022, between Kouri, Chelsea Barney, and Eric's best friend Bryce Kudson, revealed Kouri's anger at Eric's family for challenging his estate, her claims of Eric not trusting her, and casual jokes about how she 'would have shot him in the head' if she intended to kill him.
- ❖Kouri's 'life story' from a Sedona retreat in February 2021 depicted a childhood marked by parental addiction (alcoholic father, compulsive gambler mother) and a lifelong 'chase for happiness' through marriage, children, and education.
- ❖Witness Ally Staking (another friend) testified that Eric jokingly told a group, including Kouri, that Kouri 'tried to poison him' on Valentine's Day, and everyone, including Kouri, laughed about it.
- ❖Ally Staking also revealed that Eric had hidden THC gummies in Kouri's suitcase on a trip to Hawaii in 2018, which Eric found 'hilarious' while Kouri was upset.
- ❖A photo from a gathering at Kouri's house on March 5, 2022 (two days after Eric's death), showed Kouri, Bryce Kudson, Chelsea Barney, and Eric's sister Amy, with Kudson allegedly removing his pants at some point during the evening.
Insights
1Kouri's Financial Maneuvers and Divorce Intentions
Testimony from divorce attorney Marie Bramwell established that Kouri consulted her in May 2021 for divorce, but communications ceased by January 2022. A returned retainer check of $5,200 on January 10, 2022, indicates Kouri did not proceed with the divorce. This timeline is crucial as it precedes Eric's death and coincides with other alleged schemes.
Marie Bramwell's testimony about Kouri's divorce consultation and the returned retainer check.
2The 'Better Off Dead' Comment and Hindsight
Neighbor Becky Lloyd testified that Kouri, in December 2021, expressed feeling 'trapped' in her marriage and stated it 'would be better if he were dead.' While initially seeming hyperbolic, Eric's subsequent death gives this statement significant weight. The defense attempted to discredit this by noting it wasn't in the first PI interview.
Becky Lloyd's testimony regarding Kouri's statement and the defense's cross-examination on prior interviews.
3Valentine's Day Sandwich and Alleged Poisoning
Diner owner Gabriel Morren confirmed Kouri ordered a bagel sandwich and Greek omelette, picked up at 9:07 AM on Valentine's Day 2022. This is central to the attempted murder charge. Later, friend Ally Staking testified that Eric jokingly told a group, including Kouri, that Kouri 'tried to poison him' with the sandwich, and everyone, including Kouri, laughed.
Gabriel Morren's testimony about the diner order and Ally Staking's testimony about Eric's 'joke'.
4Kouri's Financial Fraud Against Best Friend
Chelsea Barney, a close friend, testified about giving Kouri $45,000 (her life savings from tips) as a down payment for a house Kouri was selling her. Kouri never filed the deed, maintaining ownership, and later used the property as collateral for another $95,000 loan. Chelsea was eventually evicted from the home, losing her investment.
Chelsea Barney's testimony, including details about the $45,000 payment, the unfiled deed, and her subsequent eviction.
5The 'If I Die, Eric Did It' Text and HELOC Abuse
Text messages from October 14, 2020, between Kouri and Chelsea Barney were admitted, showing Kouri stating, 'If I die, Eric did it.' This was in the context of Kouri taking out a $250,000 home equity line of credit on Eric's premarital home without his knowledge, leading to Eric cutting off her credit cards.
Text messages between Kouri and Chelsea Barney (Exhibit 2-2D).
6Kouri's Reaction to Eric's Estate Plan and the 'Pants-Off' Wake
A recorded phone call from March 19, 2022, between Kouri, Chelsea Barney, and Eric's best friend Bryce Kudson, revealed Kouri's intense anger over Eric's updated estate plan, which put his assets (including the marital home) into a trust controlled by his sister Katie. Kouri claimed Eric 'never gave me a chance' and expressed fury at his family. The call also referenced a chaotic gathering on March 5th (two days after Eric's death) where Bryce Kudson allegedly removed his pants, and Kouri was filmed drinking, leading to accusations of being an 'incompetent mother' from Eric's sister Amy.
Recorded phone call (Exhibits 2-46 and 2-47) and testimony from Chelsea Barney and Ally Staking.
7Kouri's 'Life Story' and Quest for Happiness
A document from a 'finding true self retreat' in Sedona, Arizona, in February 2021, written by Kouri in the third person, detailed a difficult childhood with an alcoholic father (who killed a cop while DUI) and a compulsive gambler mother. It portrayed Kouri's life as a series of attempts to find happiness through marriage, children, and education, always feeling 'not enough' or 'selfish' by her husband.
Kouri Richins's 'life story' document (Exhibit 2-4) from the Sedona retreat.
8Kouri's Relief Over 'Undetermined' Cause of Death
Text messages from June 6, 2022, show Kouri expressing significant relief and using multiple exclamation points upon learning the medical examiner's report listed Eric's manner of death as 'undetermined' and mentioned 'a trace of fentanyl.' She mischaracterized the findings to her friend, claiming his lungs were 'shot to shit' and the fentanyl 'put his lungs overboard.'
Text messages between Kouri and Chelsea Barney (Exhibit 2-123D).
Notable Moments
Judge M's 'I feel like you're intentionally ignoring the point' comment to the defense during a sidebar, highlighting perceived repetitive arguments.
Reveals the judge's frustration with the defense's legal arguments, suggesting they were not engaging productively with prior rulings.
Defense attorney Miss Lewis's repeated attempts to introduce hearsay about the source of THC gummies, leading to sustained objections and the judge's exasperation.
Demonstrates the defense's struggle to lay proper foundation for evidence, potentially impacting the jury's perception of their competence.
The prosecution's attorney, Mr. Bledworth, jokingly citing a fictional case, 'Takes v. Backies,' to request re-opening direct examination, which Miss Lewis initially took seriously.
Provided a moment of levity in a tense trial, but also highlighted Miss Lewis's perceived lack of awareness or exhaustion.
The revelation of a photo from a post-death gathering at Kouri's house on March 5, 2022, depicting Bryce Kudson (Eric's best friend) without pants, and Kouri drinking.
Contradicts the defense's narrative of Kouri as a grieving widow and paints a picture of a chaotic and potentially inappropriate gathering shortly after Eric's unexpected death.
The disclosure that a previously testified witness (estate planning attorney Crystal Bowman Carter) had a scheduled appointment with a juror's spouse, which was proactively postponed until after the trial.
Quotes
"I feel like you're intentionally ignoring the fact that I'll be instructing the jury to not consider the other half of the call. But I understand your position and you have to acknowledge that you have the power to subpoena the people on the other side of the call if you want to. But let's stay focused on the half that the jury would be allowed to consider from each of these calls. And that's your client's own statements."
"She said that in many ways it would be better if he were dead."
"I swear she said, 'uh, in many ways it would be better if he just died.'"
"It was memorable for me enough that after I met with the private detective, I went and talked to my friends and without prompting I said, 'Hey, remember that conversation I told you about? What what did I tell you about it?' and they were able to confirm exactly what I said in my statement here because it is a very big deal and I respect the justice system very much that I am never going to get on this stand and say something that I don't know as truth."
"I just tried Chelse so [__] hard to save him. his lifeless body on my bedroom floor. His eyes, his yellow body cold. It was so cold. I pumped so damn hard on so hard, screaming at him to come back to life that I needed him. He was gone, Chucking gone. He never even gave me a sign he needed [__] help. I would have woken up. I could have helped him. This is so [__] yo."
"I hired the law firm that represents the Jazz. It cost me 100K. I will [__] win. They will not take from me what is mine and what I worked my ass for. They won't. Thanks, friend. I love you."
"I mean, it's not like you're some [__] black widow. Like, that's not what you go after. You don't go after your husband dying and you don't go after money."
"If you were if you were gonna do it, you would have like shot him in his head, right? Like two years ago, like years ago."
"Yes. And we all teased Corey for trying to kill him or poison him or whatever he thought it was."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
Kouri Richins’ Lover Testifies Against Her in Murder Trial - H3 After Dark #25
"Kouri Richins, a Utah mother, is accused of poisoning her husband with fentanyl after he discovered her massive debt and attempts to manipulate his will and life insurance, leading to a dramatic trial involving her lover's testimony and her own incriminating actions."
Millionaire Husband Tries To Kill His Wife Multiple Times | The Case of Sergio and Tatiana Pino
"A millionaire real estate developer, Sergio Pino, orchestrated multiple attempts on his wife Tatiana's life, including poisoning and hiring hitmen, to avoid a costly divorce, ultimately taking his own life when confronted by the FBI."
Nancy Guthrie Investigation Mess, Shock Lawsuit Against "The Tell" Author, Kouri Richins Bombshells
"Megyn Kelly and her legal panel dissect a bombshell lawsuit against author Amy Griffin for allegedly stealing a sexual assault story, the ongoing Kouri Richins murder trial involving fentanyl poisoning, and a harrowing IVF clinic mix-up where parents received the wrong baby."
UT v. Kouri Richins - Trial Day 8 - Insurance, Estates and the Paramour testifies!
"Day 8 of the Kouri Richins murder trial brought explosive testimony from insurance experts, estate attorneys, and Kouri's paramour, revealing complex financial maneuvers, Eric's efforts to protect his estate from Kouri, and intimate, incriminating text messages."