Samuel Reineberg - They Eliminated an Active Shooter in 4 Minutes | SRS #295
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Cadet Samuel Reineberg and fellow ROTC cadets immediately engaged an active shooter, Muhammad Jalah, in their classroom.
- ❖Colonel Brandon Shaw, the class instructor, was fatally wounded but initiated the engagement by bear-hugging the shooter.
- ❖The cadets, without firearms, neutralized the shooter within four minutes using physical force, including a small knife and dislodging an eye.
- ❖Two other cadets were injured during the engagement; one was shot in the leg, another in the belly.
- ❖Reineberg provided immediate first aid to Colonel Shaw, attempting to stop severe bleeding from a femoral artery wound.
- ❖The university initially sent a controversial email to Reineberg, stating no intention of pressing charges against him, which was later disavowed by the university president.
- ❖Muhammad Jalah, the shooter, had a history of radicalization, attempting to provide material support to ISIS, and was released from prison 2.5 years early due to a drug abuse program loophole.
- ❖Reineberg is processing the trauma of the event, particularly the loss of Colonel Shaw, and remains committed to serving in the Army.
- ❖The Old Dominion University president committed to increased security for ROTC events and memorializing Colonel Shaw.
Insights
1Immediate, Unarmed Response Neutralized Active Shooter
Cadet Samuel Reineberg and a team of fellow ROTC cadets immediately engaged an active shooter who entered their classroom, shouting 'Allah Akbar' and opening fire. Despite being unarmed (except for one cadet with a small knife), they physically subdued and killed the shooter within four minutes of the first shot. Colonel Brandon Shaw, the instructor, initiated the engagement while being shot.
The shooter yelled 'Allah Akbar' and started shooting Colonel Shaw. Colonel Shaw was able to bear hug the shooter. I saw another cadet already on top of the shooter with a knife. We had our hands on the top of the slide of this Glock. We're pushing the gun back away and forcing the muzzle away from our classmates. He had been stabbed. He'd been beat. Took an eye out. After a minute, minute and a half, he was gone. (, , , , , , )
2Systemic Failure Led to Shooter's Early Release
The active shooter, Muhammad Jalah, was a convicted terrorist who had attempted to provide material support to ISIS. He was sentenced to 11 years but released 2.5 years early from federal prison after completing a residential drug abuse program, despite having no drug convictions. This was identified as a legal loophole that has since been closed.
Muhammad Jalah...pleads guilty to attempting to provide material support to ISIS. Sentenced February 10th, 2017 to 11 years in a federal prison plus 5 years supervised release... He only served 8 and a half years. Released on December 23rd, 2024, approximately 2 and a half years early. Reason for early release: completed a residential drug abuse program. Despite having no drug convictions, only terrorism convictions. Federal law prohibits violent offenders from early release via ARDAP. This was a legal loophole. The Federal Bureau of Prisons has since closed the loophole in 2025. (, , )
3University's Initial Response to Cadets Caused Distress
Days after the incident, Cadet Reineberg received an email from a university official stating that Old Dominion University had no intention of pressing charges against him in accordance with the student code of conduct for his actions. This email caused significant distress and confusion among the cadets, implying their heroic actions might have been subject to disciplinary action.
I woke up one morning... I got this like really weird mail from some like associate assistant to the vice president of like the student conduct committee... 'Hey Samuel, just want to let you know ODU doesn't have any intention of pressing charges against you in accordance with like the student code of conduct.' (, )
4Colonel Shaw's Heroism and Last Moments
Colonel Brandon Shaw, the ROTC instructor, was the first to be shot but immediately engaged the shooter, bear-hugging him and bringing him to the ground, which allowed the cadets to move in. Despite being critically wounded in the femoral artery, he regained consciousness multiple times while Reineberg provided aid, even asking for his inhaler, before succumbing to his injuries at the hospital.
He drew his gun, yelled 'Allah Akbar' and started shooting my professor. Shaw, Colonel Shaw, he had like was able to kind of like take step forward, some steps forward and kind of grab and pull him in, bear hug him. (, ) He's hitting the leg upper and upper leg like high up in the leg. He came back for like a minute maybe and he's trying to fight me to get up. He's asking, he's like, 'I need my inhaler.' (, , )
Bottom Line
The host alleges that the U.S. government sends '40 to 87 million dollars every week to the Taliban,' suggesting this indirectly funds terrorism that could lead to domestic attacks like the one at ODU.
This claim, if accurate, points to a severe disconnect between foreign policy and domestic security, potentially creating a pipeline for radicalization and attacks within the US, undermining the very soldiers who defend the nation.
Investigate and expose the full extent of US government financial flows to entities with known ties to terrorism, advocating for policy changes that prevent such funds from inadvertently supporting groups that threaten American lives.
The university's initial email to Cadet Reineberg, stating they had 'no intention of pressing charges' for his actions in neutralizing a terrorist, highlights a potential bureaucratic and legal disconnect in how institutions perceive and respond to self-defense in active shooter situations.
This suggests a need for clear, pre-established policies and legal protections for individuals who act heroically in self-defense or defense of others on university campuses, preventing them from feeling scrutinized or criminalized for saving lives.
Advocate for 'Good Samaritan' laws or specific campus policies that unequivocally protect individuals who use necessary force to stop an active threat, ensuring they are recognized as heroes, not potential liabilities.
Key Concepts
Instinctive Action Under Duress
The cadets' immediate and coordinated response to the active shooter, without conscious deliberation, demonstrates a 'fight or flight' response leaning heavily into trained or innate 'fight' instincts, especially in military-trained individuals. Reineberg describes 'no thinking involved, just doing' during the critical moments.
Lessons
- Familiarize yourself with active shooter response protocols (Run, Hide, Fight) and consider training in basic trauma care (e.g., tourniquet application) as immediate medical intervention can be life-saving.
- Advocate for robust security measures and clear policies on self-defense for individuals on campuses and in public spaces, ensuring heroes are protected, not penalized.
- Engage with local and national political processes to demand accountability for policy decisions, such as early release programs, that may inadvertently enable dangerous individuals to re-offend.
Notable Moments
Reineberg describes the indifferent feeling of receiving a medal at Colonel Shaw's funeral, overwhelmed by the presence of Shaw's grieving family and his own 'survivor's guilt' over Shaw's death.
This moment powerfully conveys the complex emotional toll of heroism and loss, illustrating that accolades can feel hollow in the face of tragedy and personal responsibility.
Reineberg recounts the university president's personal apology for the 'no charges' email and sharing his own experience with a past campus shooting where no one intervened, highlighting the contrast with the ODU cadets' actions.
This shows a leader's empathetic and corrective response to a bureaucratic misstep, validating the cadets' heroism and acknowledging the profound impact of their actions compared to a passive response.
Reineberg's emotional prayer for Colonel Shaw's family, particularly his son, at the end of the podcast.
This moment underscores the deep personal connection and grief felt by Reineberg for his fallen mentor, humanizing the profound loss and the lasting impact on the families of victims.
Quotes
"I don't know how to if it's survivors guilt, but yeah, you were working on him trying to revive him. Not revive him. Uh keep him alive. Stop the bleeding."
"Is this ROC or is this a seminar? I don't know who it was, but somebody in the front was like, 'Yeah, like that was ROC.' And uh he soon as that person said yeah, he drew his gun uh yelled 'Allah Akbar' and and started shooting."
"I had turn around like I'm on my knees. I'm turning around while holding the gun like rest still wrestling with the guy. I turn around I was like everyone get the hell out of here. Every everybody run and somebody call 911. Somebody call 911. Everyone get the hell out."
"I took his ID from him. I look at it. I couldn't even see what it said because I'm like, my vision's kind of like this, just a tunnel. And I was like, threw it back at him. I'm like, I'm not answering your [__] questions."
"ODU doesn't have any intention of uh pressing charges against you in accordance with like the student code of conduct... for the actions you took personally that day."
"It's hard to conceptualize that especially... being a soldier wanting to defend the country... it's hard, it's difficult."
"The country is still worth defending Sam. Politicians are not. They are not worth defending."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
NYPD Presser Addressing Counter Protester Improvised Explosive Attack
"NYPD and federal authorities announced federal terrorism charges against two individuals, Amir Balot and Ibraim Caillumi, for deploying ISIS-inspired improvised explosive devices during a protest in New York City."
Islamic Immigrant Terrorist Commits MASS SHOOTING At Texas Bar In REVENGE For Attacks Against Iran
"A mass shooting in Austin, Texas, is framed by the host as an act of Islamic terrorism by a naturalized immigrant, motivated by US actions against Iran, and allegedly downplayed by mainstream media."
WOKE Woman FINDS OUT On Live Stream While Trying To Prove Partying With Migrants For NYE Is Safe!
"A German streamer's live broadcast intended to show the safety of New Year's Eve celebrations in Cologne ended in two attacks, which the host uses to argue against mass migration policies."
🚨 IT'S OVER!! TRUMP F*CKING LEFT NATO 😂😂😂
"The host vehemently argues for a US withdrawal from NATO, asserting Europe's 'wokeness' and reliance on American resources, while celebrating aggressive US action against Iran and condemning 'leftist' judicial and social policies as suicidal."