Softball coach orchestrated the murder of ex-fiancé with the help of former player, prosecutor says
Quick Read
Summary
Takeaways
- ❖Shea Brier was found shot in the back on a remote bridge in Jay County, Indiana, and died from his injuries.
- ❖His ex-fiancée, EJ Steven, was the primary suspect due to a contentious custody battle over their daughter.
- ❖EJ Steven initially lied to detectives about her last contact with Shea, but phone records proved otherwise.
- ❖A friend, Christy Cybre, reported that EJ and Shelby Heston had discussed various methods of 'getting rid of' Shea, including a prior attempt to poison him.
- ❖EJ, Shelby, and Hannah Kapki drove Shea to the bridge, where Shelby shot him. EJ then returned to throw Shea's cell phone into the river to prevent him from calling for help.
- ❖Prosecutors argued EJ orchestrated the murder to eliminate a 'problem' in her life, while the defense claimed it was a 'joke' that went wrong.
- ❖EJ Steven and Shelby Heston were convicted of murder and sentenced to 55 years each; Hannah Kapki pleaded guilty to voluntary manslaughter and received a shorter sentence.
Insights
1EJ Steven's Deceptive Conduct and Lack of Remorse
EJ Steven, Shea's ex-fiancée, initially showed little emotion when informed of Shea's death and lied about her last contact with him. Phone records later revealed she called him around midnight, hours before he was found. Her demeanor during interrogation, described as 'cool and calm,' further raised suspicions among detectives.
EJ's lack of emotion (), her lie about the last call (), and her 'butt dial' explanation ().
2Prior Attempted Poisoning of Shea Brier
Christy Cybre, a friend of EJ, testified that EJ and Shelby had previously attempted to poison Shea by crushing ibuprofen pills into his tea. This incident, which occurred months before the shooting, demonstrated a pattern of planning to harm Shea, contradicting claims that the murder was a spontaneous act or a 'joke'.
Christy's testimony: 'They did talk about how they one time did put pills in his tea and tried to OD him. I crushed up ibuprofen, I believe. And he did drink the whole glass, but nothing happened to him.'
3The 'Joking' Nature of Murder Discussions and Test Firing
EJ claimed that discussions about killing Shea were 'joking,' but evidence showed the group test-fired Shelby's rifle in the church parking lot hours before the murder. Prosecutors argued that this action transformed any 'joke' into a serious, premeditated act, indicating clear intent.
EJ's statement: 'Joking about like it wasn't a full serious conversation.' (); Prosecutor's counter: 'The minute you take that gun out and you fire it to see how loud it's going to be, that's like, okay, now this is real, right?'
4Post-Shooting Actions to Ensure Shea's Death
After shooting Shea, the group drove away but then turned back. EJ and Shelby exited the vehicle to retrieve Shea's cell phone and throw it into the river, admitting to police they were 'scared that he could call 911.' This act demonstrated a callous intent to prevent Shea from receiving help, ensuring his death.
EJ's admission: 'You scared that he could call 911? Yeah.' (); Prosecutor's argument: 'His only lifeline was that cell phone possibly... And you left him there to die in the cold.'
5Manipulative Power Dynamic Between EJ and Shelby
Prosecutors and family friends suggested a significant power dynamic and potential manipulation by EJ over Shelby, who was 10 years younger and had been coached by EJ. Shelby's text message, 'I'm killing that bastard with my own two hands,' and the fact that EJ's name was saved as 'bae' in Shelby's phone, indicated a deep, possibly romantic or controlling, relationship that fueled Shelby's animosity towards Shea.
Shelby's text message: 'I'm killing that bastard with my own two hands.' (); EJ's name in Shelby's phone as 'ba'/'bae' (); Family friend's description of EJ as a 'wannabe cult leader' ().
Lessons
- Take threats seriously, even if framed as 'jokes,' especially when they involve discussions of violence or prior attempts to harm someone.
- Recognize and address manipulative dynamics in relationships, particularly when there's a significant age or authority imbalance, as these can lead to individuals being coerced into harmful actions.
- Seek legal counsel immediately in custody disputes to formalize parental rights and establish clear boundaries, rather than attempting informal or confrontational resolutions.
Notable Moments
Shea Brier is found injured on a remote bridge, later dying from a bullet wound to the heart.
This is the inciting incident, setting off the murder investigation that unravels the complex plot.
EJ Steven's initial interview with detectives reveals her lack of emotion and dishonesty about her last contact with Shea.
This immediately flags EJ as a person of interest and a potential suspect, contradicting her claims of innocence.
Christy Cybre, a friend of EJ, contacts police and reveals EJ and Shelby had discussed 'getting rid of' Shea and even attempted to poison him.
Christy's testimony provides crucial evidence of premeditation and intent, transforming casual 'venting' into a serious conspiracy.
EJ, Shelby, and Hannah test-fire the rifle in the church parking lot hours before the murder.
This act demonstrates a clear escalation from discussion to preparation, undermining any claims that the shooting was accidental or unplanned.
After the shooting, EJ and Shelby return to the bridge to throw Shea's cell phone into the river.
This demonstrates a cold-blooded attempt to prevent Shea from calling for help, confirming their intent to leave him to die.
Shelby Heston apologizes to Shea's family during her sentencing, unlike EJ Steven.
This moment highlights a perceived difference in remorse between the two main perpetrators, with some believing Shelby was manipulated by EJ.
Quotes
"I didn't want her to be with him at all. I was like, that little girl will be just fine without him."
"Can it stay on Facebook? Does it have to be put out there?"
"You could have made a difference. You could have said no. You could have said, 'Let's get out of here.'"
"She had the misfortune of finding comfort in a wannabe cult leader who literally destroyed several families for her own self-interest."
Q&A
Recent Questions
Related Episodes
Cheating Fire Chief Murders Wife Hours Before Divorce
"A decorated fire chief, just hours before his divorce was finalized, murdered his wife to avoid financial ruin, then meticulously crafted a false narrative of her sudden medical death."
Military Wife Has Lover Kill Husband in Brutal Conspiracy
"A decorated Army Sergeant's murder on New Year's Eve unravels into a shocking conspiracy involving his wife and her lover, meticulously planned for life insurance money and a new life."
Alex Murdaugh Crimes, Jodi Arias Trial, "Bad Vegan" Deep Dive - Megyn's "True Crime" Mega-Episode
"This true crime mega-episode dissects the generational criminality of the Murdaugh family, the psychological manipulation behind the 'Bad Vegan' scandal, and the chilling premeditation and trial controversies of the Jodi Arias murder case."
The Blue River Murder | Full Episode
"A mother of three vanishes during a blizzard in a small Colorado town, only to be found brutally murdered, leading investigators to uncover a web of secrets and a husband's dark past."