Ep 598 - Night Shadow (feat. Dan Soder, Chris O'Connor, Billy)

Quick Read

The hosts and guests share bizarre personal anecdotes, from tonsil stones and nipple surgeries to drunk falls, sleep paralysis, and the strange aerodynamics of Olympic ski jumpers.
Tonsil stones are real and smell terrible.
Olympic ski jumpers reportedly use penile injections to optimize suit aerodynamics.
Comedians, even Louis CK, get nervous before big arena shows.

Summary

This episode features hosts and guests Dan Soder, Chris O'Connor, and Billy engaging in wide-ranging, often gross-out, comedic discussions. Topics include the discovery of tonsil stones, childhood experiences with 'puffy nipples' and HGH-induced lactation, the perils of drunk falling, and the existential dread of sleep paralysis. They also touch on pop culture, like the Punisher series and the Liver King's eccentric diet, and share behind-the-scenes stories from a recent Madison Square Garden comedy show, including Louis CK's nervousness and bombing with act-outs.
The episode offers a raw, unfiltered look into the comedic minds of the hosts and guests, providing relatable (and sometimes cringeworthy) human experiences and observations on everything from bodily functions to the absurdities of modern life and professional comedy.

Takeaways

  • The hosts and guests recounted personal experiences with tonsil stones and 'puffy nipples,' including a story of HGH-induced lactation.
  • Matt is described as being 'juiced to the gills' with HGH, a common 'biohacking' trend in Austin.
  • La Mer, a recurring character, is characterized by his 'MSNBC brain' and habit of ordering GrubHub and falling asleep.
  • Discussions included the dangers and embarrassments of drunk falls and the unsettling experience of sleep paralysis.
  • Comedians shared behind-the-scenes details from a Madison Square Garden show, noting Louis CK's nervousness and the challenges of performing while sick.
  • A bizarre Olympic rule was revealed: ski jumpers reportedly inject their penises to create more 'flap' for aerodynamic advantage during suit fittings.

Insights

1The Reality of Tonsil Stones

Chris O'Connor described coughing up 'tonsil stones' as a child, which he likened to 'gunk in your tonsils' that 'smell like [shit]'. One friend even required surgery due to severe tonsil stone issues.

Chris O'Connor's personal anecdote about tonsil stones and a friend's surgery.

2Nipple Puffs and HGH

The discussion covered 'puffy nipples' and a technique to make them 'hard' before swimming. A story was shared about a kid whose nipples lactated due to HGH use, leading him to poke them with a pin. The Rock also reportedly had nipple surgery for this issue.

Anecdotes about 'puffy nipples,' a specific story of HGH-induced lactation, and mention of The Rock's nipple surgery.

3Matt's 'Juiced' Lifestyle

Matt is described as being 'juiced to the gills' and engaging in 'biohacking' in Austin, implying steroid use or similar performance enhancers, which is framed as a common Austin lifestyle.

Comments from the hosts about Matt being 'juiced to the gills' and 'biohacking' in Austin.

4La Mer's 'MSNBC Brain' and GrubHub Habits

La Mer is characterized as having an 'MSNBC brain,' agreeing with 'anything on The View.' He also has a habit of ordering GrubHub and falling asleep, requiring friends to call him to retrieve his food from his doorstep.

Descriptions of La Mer's political leanings and specific anecdotes about his GrubHub ordering and sleeping habits.

5The 'Drunk Fall' and Aging

The hosts shared numerous anecdotes about 'drunk falls,' noting the slow-motion realization during a fall and the painful aftermath. This was contrasted with elderly people's frequent falls, which are often met with less concern by the elderly themselves than by their families.

Personal stories of drunk falls and observations about elderly relatives' reactions to falling.

6First Time Busters and Calf Cramps

The guests recounted their first experiences with ejaculation, describing panic and fear of having 'broken something.' This was humorously compared to the first time experiencing a calf cramp while sleeping, leading to a similar fear of severe injury.

Personal anecdotes about first ejaculation and first calf cramp experiences.

7Sleep Paralysis and Dream Realism

Several hosts experienced sleep paralysis, describing it as a terrifying state where one is scared and unable to move. They noted the vividness of dreams, including one where a person believed someone walked across their room.

Personal accounts of experiencing sleep paralysis and vivid, frightening dreams.

8College Class Confusion

One host recounted accidentally missing a construction safety class and a physics lab for over a month because he screenshotted his course schedule on MLK Day, a day off, and used that as his weekly reference.

A specific anecdote about a college student missing classes due to a screenshot error.

9Philosophy Class Difficulty

A host described enrolling in a 400-level philosophy class at the University of Arizona, known for its top philosophy department, without prerequisite knowledge. He struggled with Descartes' rationalism, finding the texts incomprehensible.

A personal story about struggling in an advanced philosophy class without proper background.

10Grimm Fairy Tales and Heroin

The hosts speculated that classic grim fairy tale authors were likely 'fucked up on heroin' when writing their scary stories, drawing a parallel between the dark themes and drug-induced states.

Speculation and humorous theory about the inspiration behind Grimm fairy tales.

11Liver King's Waterburger Outing and HGH

The Liver King was seen at Waterburger with his family, ordering a massive meal during what was described as a 'psychosis' phase. It was revealed he spent '30,000 of HGH a month,' leading to skepticism about his 'ancestral' diet claims.

Discussion of a video showing Liver King at Waterburger and details about his reported HGH expenditure.

12Olympic Ski Jumpers and Penile Injections

A bizarre Olympic practice was discussed where ski jumpers reportedly inject their penises to make them 'bigger' during suit fittings. This creates extra 'flap' in the suit to provide aerodynamic lift, carrying them '9 feet farther,' though the penis returns to normal size during competition.

A claim about a specific, unusual practice among Olympic ski jumpers for aerodynamic advantage.

13Figure Skating Scoring

The hosts observed that figure skating scoring is heavily weighted towards 'dancing' and 'presentation' (50% of points) rather than just technical 'moves,' humorously attributing this to the 'gay' nature of the sport.

Observation and humorous commentary on the scoring criteria in figure skating.

Notable Moments

Madison Square Garden Comedy Show Experience

The hosts and guests recounted their experiences performing at Madison Square Garden, including the unique atmosphere, the surprise appearance of Louis CK, and the challenges of performing while sick or as an opener.

Quotes

"

"MSNBC brain is crazy because now that means you also have stuck through the shifting through the through the the trans surgery that the network went through where it's like that's my dead name. My new network name is SA."

Dan Soder
"

"I'll tell to Alex Jones might be the biggest victim of this Epstein [shit] because like he tried and then he fell for the Hillary [shit] and then he kept falling into Epstein traps. Joe Rogan, too."

Dan Soder
"

"When you drunk fall, there's so much time to be like, 'No way. I'm falling.'"

Dan Soder
"

"Aderall hitting the drinking scene was like steroids in baseball in the late 90s."

Dan Soder
"

"I was like, 'Do I need to tell my Did I break something?'"

Chris O'Connor
"

"Supposedly all those grim fairy tale people were on heroin and [shit] like Hans and GR all that. They were just [shit] up on heroin and made all these scary ass tears."

Dan Soder
"

"How could I be raping women when I like men?"

Dan Soder
"

"You know what I found out about the Olympics? Do you know those ski jumpers? Yeah. do this [shit] where when they're getting fitted for suit, they like shoot something in their dick to make their dick bigger."

Dan Soder

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes

Ep 594 - Gooniverse (feat. Steve Gerben & Billy)
Matt and Shane's Secret PodcastJan 14, 2026

Ep 594 - Gooniverse (feat. Steve Gerben & Billy)

"The hosts and guests dive into a chaotic mix of personal fitness goals, political commentary, bizarre internet subcultures, and hilariously awkward social encounters, all while maintaining their signature irreverent humor."

ComedyPersonal AnecdotesPolitics+2
Tracy Morgan Claims He Is the King of New York and Started the Riverboat Brawl, Talks Reggie Dinkins
A Closer Look - Late Night with Seth MeyersApr 1, 2026

Tracy Morgan Claims He Is the King of New York and Started the Riverboat Brawl, Talks Reggie Dinkins

"Tracy Morgan delivers a masterclass in comedic chaos, claiming to be Jacques Cousteau's grandson, the 'King of New York,' and the instigator of the infamous Alabama riverboat brawl."

ComedyCelebrity InterviewTracy Morgan+2
The Chappell Roan Situation Explained - H3 Show #249
The H3 PodcastMar 23, 2026

The Chappell Roan Situation Explained - H3 Show #249

"The H3 Podcast crew dissects celebrity controversies, from Chappell Roan's alleged security incident and Justin Timberlake's DUI bodycam to a $27 million lawsuit over Lion King lyrics, highlighting the blurred lines of public perception and personal responsibility."

Celebrity CultureInternet DramaPublic Perception+2
Mile High Club w/ Mark Normand! | Are You Garbage Comedy Podcast w/ Kevin Ryan & H. Foley
Are You Garbage? Comedy PodcastMar 22, 2026

Mile High Club w/ Mark Normand! | Are You Garbage Comedy Podcast w/ Kevin Ryan & H. Foley

"Comedian Mark Normand joins the 'Are You Garbage?' hosts to dissect what truly defines 'classy' versus 'trashy' behavior, from self-checkout theft to the perils of owning a vintage car and the unexpected realities of cruise ship life."

ComedyPersonal AnecdotesConsumer Behavior+2