Democracy Now
Democracy Now
March 16, 2026

"A Sense of Despair": Many Iranians Fear a Prolonged War — and What Comes After

Quick Read

Amidst escalating US-Israeli strikes and Iranian retaliation, experts reveal a profound sense of despair among Iranians caught between a brutal regime and external war, challenging simplistic narratives.
Iranians feel isolated, unable to align with either the repressive regime or the external war efforts.
So-called 'surgical strikes' cause widespread civilian damage, like a glass shortage in Tehran.
War paralyzes internal protest movements, shifting focus to survival and causing deep, lasting trauma.

Summary

This episode of Democracy Now features Professors Nagme Sarabi and Amir Ahmedi Orion, who discuss the complex and devastating reality for Iranians amidst ongoing US-Israeli military actions and internal regime repression. They highlight that many Iranians feel trapped, neither supporting the war nor the current Islamic Republic, leading to widespread isolation and despair. The discussion emphasizes the often-overlooked civilian impact, such as a glass shortage in Tehran due to shockwaves from 'surgical strikes,' and the long-term psychological trauma of war. Both guests critique Western media's polarized coverage and stress the importance of recognizing Iran as a source of complex ideas, not just a 'cause.' Ahmedi Orion explains his shift in viewing Iran from a 'parent' to a 'fragile child' needing protection, arguing that war paralyzes protest movements by forcing people into survival mode, making political change a distant fantasy.
Understanding the nuanced perspective of Iranians caught between a repressive domestic regime and external military conflict is critical for a comprehensive view of geopolitical events. This analysis reveals how war, even 'surgical' strikes, devastates civilian life and undermines internal movements for change, challenging simplistic 'liberation' narratives and highlighting the profound psychological and social costs often ignored in international discourse. It underscores the importance of listening to voices from within affected regions to grasp the true human impact of conflict.

Takeaways

  • Many Iranians are 'stuck' between a repressive regime and external war, feeling they are neither pro-war nor pro-regime.
  • The civilian impact of war extends beyond direct casualties, including widespread damage to homes and psychological trauma.
  • Western media coverage often oversimplifies the Iranian situation, presenting it as either anti-war or pro-liberation.
  • War, even 'precise' attacks, causes severe civilian casualties, cultural damage, and environmental harm.
  • The Iranian regime actively views its own population as an enemy, using threats and violence against dissenters.
  • War paralyzes political and protest movements by forcing the population into survival mode, making organized change a 'fantasy'.

Insights

1The 'Stuck' Reality of Iranians

Many Iranians feel trapped between the brutality of their own government and the destructive impact of external war. They cannot align with either side, leading to a profound sense of isolation and despair. This challenges the binary choice often presented by external observers.

Professor Sarabi notes, 'a lot of people have been trying to understand and express what it means to be neither of these two things in a society and in a world in which is very very polarized.' She adds, 'There's a sense of isolation that is developing among that segment of the population. A sense of withdrawal.'

2Hidden Civilian Costs of 'Surgical Strikes'

Even supposedly precise military strikes have widespread civilian impacts that go beyond direct targets. Shockwaves from bombings cause extensive damage to surrounding neighborhoods, disrupting everyday life and creating unexpected shortages.

Sarabi provides the example of a 'glass shortage in Tehran' where 'shock waves are going through the neighborhood and pulling down a wall or shattering constantly glasses,' leaving people in 'half destroyed homes trying to protect their properties.'

3War Paralyzes Internal Protest Movements

The onset and continuation of war, regardless of its stated objectives, effectively halts any potential for organized political protest or meaningful change from within. Civilian populations shift entirely to survival mode, making political action a secondary concern.

Professor Ahmedi Orion states, 'as soon as the bombs start to fall, people's survival instinct kick in. They look for shelter, they look for water and food. They want to protect their family, especially their kids.' He concludes that the expectation for people to 'organize a political movement... is a fantasy.'

4Iran as a 'Child' Needing Protection

For many in the diaspora, the experience of war transforms their relationship with their homeland from one of a 'parent' (fatherland/motherland) to a 'fragile child' that needs protection from external forces, intensifying feelings of vulnerability and responsibility.

Ahmedi Orion describes a 'switch in my head' where Iran 'didn't look like a parent anymore... but a child that needs some sort of a protection.' This feeling intensified after various conflicts, including the '12-day war' and the January massacre.

Quotes

"

"We do have a tendency in times of war to focus on the dead and on the destruction. And we tend to forget that there are people who after the bombs fall have to go about some kind of life."

Nagme Sarabi
"

"Don't treat the Middle East or Iran just as a cause, but as people who are thinking through and incorporating these thoughts into our own analyses of what's going on."

Nagme Sarabi
"

"Nothing good comes out of any war, there's no clean war, there's no clean bombing."

Amir Ahmedi Orion
"

"The exhaustion that it will cause, the sense of draining and the despair that it will cause, it has caused already after 2 weeks is so profound and so paralyzing that the expectation that people come out of this war and organize a political movement... It's a fantasy."

Amir Ahmedi Orion

Q&A

Recent Questions

Related Episodes